Audiobyte Black Dragon DAC Review image

Audiobyte Black Dragon DAC Review


What do you expect from a digital-to-analog converter (DAC) that costs just under $2,300 USD? At this price point, it’s not exactly cheap; true entry-level models on the market probably shouldn’t exceed $1,600 USD.

And if it were an advanced DAC, how much do you think it should be worth? If a dealer priced it at $3,200 USD, consumers might hesitate: can you really get something good at this price? Not to mention the price range between $1,600 and $3,200 USD, where products are even harder to sell. It’s neither expensive nor cheap. Where does this product fit in? Is it entry-level? Or advanced? Audiobyte’s Black Dragon sits in this awkward price range. Even more awkward is that it lacks visual flair. As its name suggests, it’s all black. The entire chassis is black, with no apparent design elements for aesthetics. It’s just a sturdy little tank, with fins on both sides for heat dissipation. Everything follows function.

A DAC like this sells for nearly $2,300 USD? How can dealers sell it? How can consumers justify buying it? Once you’ve heard it, you’ll buy it.

Once you’ve compared it, you’ll buy it without hesitation.

Holds Its Own Alongside Hi-End Gear Costing Many Times More

This is a DAC full of surprises.

It may not look like much, but it’s incredibly capable.

I’ve heard it several times before, but it was never the focus. It was always just a supporting player.

This time, it was the star, with the Electrocompaniet EMC 1 MK4 player, EC 4.8 preamp, EC Nemo monoblock power amps, Franco Serblin Ktema speakers, sister brand Rockna Wavedream Net digital streaming transport, and a full set of ASI cables as supporting cast.

It’s like filming a Hollywood blockbuster, casting a bunch of A-list actors, but they’re all supporting roles. The lead is a newcomer, a young actor fresh out of the gate.

A movie like that would certainly generate a lot of buzz.

The setup I heard at HiFiReport that day was just like that.

However, if those big-name stars are willing to support this newcomer, it means this actor is something special. And if he actually performs well, he’ll become a star overnight.

Listening to the Black Dragon that day, I thought that although this combination is practically impossible, this little black dragon truly proved its worth.

Can I just call it the Black Dragon? It’s a bit more familiar in Chinese, and it makes the article flow better without the English name.

What’s so good about it? For a description of the usual “normal” audio review, you can refer to Lin Zhiyu’s article “The Shortcut to Hi-End.” In addition, the manufacturer recently upgraded the Black Dragon to support the DSD512 format and added Bluetooth remote control functionality.

All Black Dragons currently on sale are the updated version. Existing users can pay for an upgrade, which costs only $380 USD.

Lin Zhiyu listened to the upgraded Black Dragon and compared the differences between the new and old versions.

Audiobyte Black Dragon DAC Review

He bought the Black Dragon after hearing it in 2015, and this year he became the first user to upgrade.

For those who already own a Black Dragon, Lin Zhiyu’s advice is to upgrade quickly. For those who are not yet Black Dragon users, he suggests considering it as a potential upgrade target, because it’s a shortcut to Hi-End, a shortcut among shortcuts.

Two Key Elements of Hi-End DACs: Combining Technical and Artistic Excellence

Zhiyu has already written two articles, so what else can I add? Therefore, I decided to take a different approach and write a less conventional review.

What do you expect from a Hi-End DAC? I think there are at least two things that a Hi-End DAC should have, or rather, that any component in a Hi-End audio system should achieve.

One is that it must be able to clearly distinguish between various differences in recordings, including recording techniques and file formats.

This is related to the performance of the equipment itself, a matter of technical prowess.

The other is that it should be able to transport you into the music.

What does this mean? A true Hi-End audio system should make you naturally ignore the audio performance and instead bring a live performance to you, or transport you to a musical performance setting.

This isn’t about reproducing the original sound; it’s about “immerse,” immersing yourself in an emotion, an environment.

This emphasizes not the sound, but the music. This is the artistic level of audio.

Whether at the technical level or the artistic level, the purpose of audio is the music being played.

When the technical level of the audio equipment is high, you can hear more information in the music. When the artistic level of the equipment is high, you can listen more deeply.

Hi-End audio should be like this: letting you hear more, letting you listen deeply.

Audio is Important, Music is More Important

But there’s a problem here.

Many audiophiles often focus on the hardware (equipment) but neglect the importance of the software (recordings). They may go to great lengths to find equipment that sounds good, but do they value the software equally? In fact, the software is even more important.

The entire audio system, regardless of price, from a mobile phone with headphones to a multi-million dollar luxury system, ultimately serves the music, to play music.

Audiobyte Black Dragon DAC Review

When you have a good audio system, you should also have software that matches it in quantity and quality. High-quality recordings, in particular, are crucial.

The funny thing is, some recordings that are touted for their sound effects don’t actually sound that great. Conversely, some recordings that seem unremarkable at first listen can, when played correctly, move you deeply and leave a lasting impression.

Both of these experiences are related to one thing in an audio system: information.

Some recordings that are easy to play with a pleasant sound may not be rich in information; they’re just pleasing to the ear. Those overlooked recordings may simply be because the audio system hasn’t unearthed enough information.

The entire audio system can be seen as a process of amplifying and transmitting musical signals.

The musical signal is picked up from the source, may undergo digital-to-analog conversion, and then amplification.

Therefore, the better the audio system, the more emphasis is placed on low distortion and minimal signal loss when reproducing the musical signal.

This is what audiophiles pursue.

However, if the music being played doesn’t contain that information, even the most excellent audio system can’t do anything about it.

The audio system can only passively reproduce the sound to the best of its ability based on the signal it receives.

If the hidden information in the music hasn’t been unearthed before, it will sound mediocre. Once it’s unearthed, the music takes on a whole new appearance.

This is why we pursue better audio systems, and it should also be why we pursue higher-quality music – having good audio equipment but no good music is like a hero with no place to use his skills; having good music but insufficient audio performance means burying these artistic assets.

The Black Dragon Has a High Degree of Recording Discrimination

The Black Dragon is the gatekeeper that allows you to examine the value of your music collection.

It completely reflects the essence of the musical signal, whether it’s a CD or a file.

Of course, there are many devices on the market with this capability, but in terms of recording discrimination, the Black Dragon is better than any DAC under $3,200 USD, and by a significant margin.

Perhaps it can be said that, in terms of price, it’s the best performer in its price range. In terms of performance, it’s the cheapest among its peers.

Challenge One of Discrimination – Differences in Sampling Rates, and the Distinction Between PCM and DSD

In HiFiReport’s listening room, I followed HiFiReport’s owner, Zhu, through a series of comparisons. The Black Dragon was undefeated; you could always discover the differences in the music.

Audiobyte Black Dragon DAC Review

For example, he compiled a playlist featuring six different versions of the fourth track, “Et misericordia,” from the album “Magnificat,” including 24bit/44.1KHz, 24bit/96KHz, 24bit/192KHz, 24bit/352.8KHz (all Flac), DSD128, and DSD256.

Under the PCM format, the higher the sampling rate, the more focused the sound became, the more defined the sound sources were, and the better the separation between them. The lower the sampling rate, the looser and slightly more blurred the sound appeared.

From 44.1K to 96K, then to 192K, and finally to 352.8K, every step up brought a noticeable change, a consistent and perceptible shift.

Subjectively speaking, once you’ve heard the higher resolution, you can’t go back.

The same difference existed between DSD128 and DSD256.

Interestingly, there’s a difference in the listening experience between PCM and DSD. Comparing 24bit/352.8KHz and DSD128, PCM sounded more analytical and sharper, while DSD was relatively smoother and gentler, in terms of the sound’s lines.

In addition, PCM felt like it had a cleaner sound base, while DSD had a better sense of air.

After hearing this, you might be thinking, “So when I buy files online, should I choose high-resolution PCM or DSD?” That depends on what kind of sound you prefer.

Interesting, right? The Black Dragon can hear all these differences.

Challenge Two of Discrimination – File Quality is Everything

It’s not over yet.

Speaking of the quality of music files, Zhu also gave a series of demonstrations to show how the Black Dragon can distinguish between good and bad recordings.

First, he used The Carpenters’ 1973 self-titled album as an example. This album collected their singles released between 1969 and 1973, with the first track being the famous “We’ve Only Just Begun.”

He first played the CD, an early first-edition US CD. After listening to the song, he played a DSD64 file.

The two sounds were worlds apart.

The DSD64 file initially sounded round, warm, and smooth, with well-defined sound sources.

In comparison, the CD sounded a bit rougher, with a more noticeable tightness in dynamic passages.

“DSD seems to sound better.” “Really? Listen to the CD again.” Zhu put the CD back on.

Audiobyte Black Dragon DAC Review

Oh! The CD’s soundstage was much wider and deeper, and the information in the music was significantly richer. Compared again, the DSD64 file sounded truly uninteresting. Not only was the soundstage smaller, but the sound bodies were also smaller. The biggest difference was the amount of information and bandwidth. It didn’t seem to be a matter of headroom; in fact, the dynamics were compressed.

Without that amount of information, limited bandwidth, and compressed soundstage, why would I need two million-dollar speakers to play it? “Could this DSD64 be homemade?” “Yes, someone gave it to me. I heard the source was a vinyl rip by an audiophile.” “The ripping technique was good, and the vinyl was in good condition with a very quiet background, but something was missing.” Even though it was a DSD64 file, it couldn’t compare to the Red Book standard CD.

You really can’t just look at the specifications; you have to listen with your ears and judge with your heart.

Next, Zhu switched to Elissa Lee Koljonen’s album “Heartbreak,” with the opening track being Milstein’s arrangement of Chopin’s Nocturne No. 20.

He first played the CD, also an early US edition, and then played the DSD64 file.

This time, DSD undoubtedly won, not only with richer details and a better sense of air, but also maintaining the smoothness of the sound lines. The music sounded more natural and fluid than the CD.

The CD was already very good, but DSD was even better.

The same experience occurred with Julia Fischer’s performance of the Tchaikovsky Violin Concerto.

The EMC-1 UP MK4 could only play the CD layer of this disc, but just listening to the CD was already very good.

Switching to the native DSD64 file, it was different again, not only smooth and natural, but also with clearer stage layering and more vivid dynamic contrast.

There’s no doubt that the native DSD file has better sound quality than the CD.

Zhu’s point was: the source of the music determines its quality.

A Word of Advice – Purchasing Files Through Legal Channels is the Best Policy

Many people search for free downloadable music files online. I would like to sincerely advise against this. Firstly, we have no way of knowing the source of these files. They may be genuine files released by the original manufacturer, or they may be upsampled files made by enthusiasts. The quality is uneven and mixed. Putting on the wrong file can mislead you.

Secondly, music is intellectual property. For the sake of original rights, it’s best to purchase downloads through legal channels.

Challenge Three of Discrimination – Different Ripping Methods, Different Sound Quality

Another interesting comparison was to let the Black Dragon reveal the differences in CD ripping methods.

Two CDs, one was Carreras’ famous Misa Criolla, and the other was the soundtrack to the movie “Atonement.”

Both rounds of comparisons were between the CD and its ripped file.

Audiobyte Black Dragon DAC Review

In the first round of Misa Criolla’s Kyrie, the CD slightly outperformed the file.

The CD won with a wider and deeper soundstage, and the drums were fuller and more solid. However, the sound quality of this file was very close to the CD, and it was difficult to distinguish between them without careful listening.

The second round was a different story.

As soon as the file was played, it was clear that it was losing, and it was a loss from the tip-off, trailing all the way.

The biggest flaw was the looseness. The sound was completely loose, especially the low frequencies, which were loose and lifeless. The music sounded as boring as chewing wax.

The two files in these two rounds had three differences. The Kyrie, which was closer to the CD, was a WAV file ripped slowly at 1:1 speed using EAC software. The “Atonement” soundtrack, which had a bigger difference, was a FLAC file ripped at high speed using EAC.

Moreover, the former was ripped using an old SCSI-interface CD-ROM built into a desktop computer, reading and ripping slowly. The latter was ripped using a portable, slim external optical drive.

Different formats, different ripping speeds, and different optical drives resulted in vastly different performances.

Based on the above listening comparisons, the Black Dragon’s ability to discern the essence of sound is truly remarkable.

It’s truly impressive that it can easily cross the threshold of a Hi-End source at this price of just under $2,300 USD.

But there’s something even more fascinating.

The Artistic Level is Difficult to Describe, But Extremely Important

When it comes to sound, you can listen with your ears, but when it comes to music, you have to experience it with your heart.

This sounds a bit metaphysical, but this is the realm that Hi-End audio should reach, to elevate the listener from listening to sound to appreciating music.

There used to be a saying in the audio world: “like being there.”

Many people criticize this statement as exaggerated and pretentious, arguing that live music goes through recording, reproduction, and playback, through many links. The sound production principle of speakers is different from that of real instruments or human voices, and with the limitations of dynamics, how can it be “like being there”? This criticism is undeniable in its argument, but these discussions remain at the level of physical sound, not psychological perception.

Beauty is spiritual, abstract, and intuitive.

Returning to the beginning of this section, appreciating musical art is a psychological activity related to aesthetics; it’s about your heart.

Audiobyte Black Dragon DAC Review

Audiobyte’s manufacturer talks about science, and audio is a product of science. However, audio should serve art; its job is to reproduce music.

What comes out of the Black Dragon is music, not just sound.

What’s the difference? It allows people to appreciate the music, enter the scene, and even be infected by the emotions.

Transparent Image, Lively Stage, Rich Details

It has a very transparent image. I don’t feel any barrier between me and the music being played. In terms of transparency, the Black Dragon is first-rate, regardless of price.

It has a very lively stage, not only with clear sound images and concrete sound bodies, but also with high independence of sound sources, and it’s lively and vibrant. In this regard, it can be compared to any DAC in the $10,000 USD class.

Furthermore, its detail information is very rich, and the subtle textures in the music are also visible. How many turns are in a vibrato, how many layers of trembling are hidden in a throat’s vibrato, how many subtle movements are in a pursed lip.

These details build up to reality.

Rich and Distinct Layers, Wide and Orderly Soundstage

The Black Dragon has another unique ability among DACs in the same price range: it has rich layers. I’m not talking about spatial layers here, but layers of texture, color, and dynamics.

The same blue can have different shades of blue. Add a little bit of other colors, and the blue changes again. Add gold powder or pearl powder? Then it becomes a brilliant blue or pearl blue.

The same cotton, pure cotton, combed cotton, mercerized cotton, and some blended cotton fabrics all feel different.

As for dynamic layers, it can be said to be the contrast between strong and weak. The Black Dragon is clear in the weak parts, so even if it’s very weak, you can still hear it clearly. In this way, the contrast is clearly drawn.

Texture, color, and dynamics all have layers. The Black Dragon can express these differences. This alone shows its extraordinary nature.

Its soundstage is wide, with width, depth, and height.

How the music was captured in a space during recording, the Black Dragon can reproduce it.

The depth, in particular, is remarkable.

Many DACs can expand the width, but when it comes to depth layering, they can’t expand it while maintaining order.

Makes You Forget About Audio, and Only Think About Music

Audiobyte Black Dragon DAC Review

When all of the above are combined, the Black Dragon has an extremely outstanding musicality, a kind of alluring charm. As you listen, you are drawn into the wonderful realm of music.

At that time, you won’t be thinking about audio, you’ll only be thinking about music.

Even monophonic historical recordings can be so fascinating.

Hi-End audio should be like this.

The Black Dragon lowers the threshold of Hi-End to a level that everyone can afford.

There’s Always Something Better

I’ve said so much about it, is the Black Dragon really that powerful, truly invincible? Of course not, it still has its limitations.

Just comparing it to the sister brand’s Rockna Wavedream DAC, you know that there is indeed a Dragon-slaying Saber in the world.

At the end of my listening session at HiFiReport, I asked Zhu to replace the Black Dragon with the Wavedream DAC.

“Are you sure you want to do this? It’s cruel.” “Yes, please replace it. I want to know how much the Black Dragon differs from the Wavedream.” As Liza Ferschtman’s performance of Mendelssohn’s Violin Concerto began, I knew that the treasured saber could indeed slay the dragon.

The Wavedream DAC’s sound was more atmospheric, the soundstage was wider, the dynamic performance was more effortless, and the sound lines were smoother, the music flowed more smoothly, and the listening experience was more natural.

The Black Dragon seemed smaller in scale, and the sound was tighter and more precise.

The advantage of the Black Dragon over other DACs in the same price range can be compared to the advantage of the Wavedream DAC over the Black Dragon.

To claim to command the world, the Black Dragon is not enough. It takes something like the Wavedream DAC to compete for the title of supreme martial artist.

The Heaven Sword in its Price Range

I listened at HiFiReport and brought the Black Dragon back for a trial. I can say with certainty: if you care about music, not brand awareness, then this is it.

The Audiobyte Black Dragon is undoubtedly the Heaven Sword of DACs under $3,200 USD, or even under $4,800 USD (approximately $5,000 USD), and can compete with any challenger! I’m always decisive about great value products that are affordable.

This time, did I buy it?

Specifications

  • Type: USB DAC Headphone Amplifier
  • Digital Inputs: USB, S/PDIF coaxial, AES/EBU, Toslink, I2S over HDMI
  • Analog Outputs: RCA, XLR
  • Headphone Output: 6.3mm phone-jack
  • Supported Sampling Rates: 32bit/384kHz PCM, DSD512
  • Maximum Output: Single-ended 10Vpp, balanced 20Vpp, headphone amp 800 mW/32Ω
  • Dimensions: 240×90×300 mm (W×H×D)
  • Weight: 4.5 kg