Chartwell BBC LS3/5 Vintage Speakers Review

Chartwell BBC LS3/5 Vintage Speakers Review


Ultra-Classic BBC LS3/5 Reproduction

What speakers did I go to listen to? And what kind of speakers deserve the title “Ultra-Classic Reproduction”? The answer is the Chartwell BBC LS3/5 launched by Graham Audio from the UK.

In fact, just the brand name and model number are quite intriguing.

The company name is Graham Audio, and judging from the article posting dates on their company website, they were established around 2013. However, the people behind it are all veterans in the audio industry.

The principal, Paul Graham, has worked in professional audio for over twenty years, including recording, broadcasting, and live performances. He has a particular fondness for the classic old BBC sound, which led him to establish Graham Audio, bringing together a professional industry team dedicated to reproducing BBC monitor speakers. They started with the BBC LS5/9, followed by the LS5/8, and their latest work is the LS3/5.

Chartwell BBC LS3/5 Vintage Speakers Review

Wait, did I miss a letter? Did I get the model number wrong? Isn’t BBC’s classic bookshelf speaker the LS 3/5A? Why does Graham Audio’s Chartwell brand model call it BBC LS3/5? Why isn’t there an “A” at the end? I didn’t miss anything – their speaker is indeed called the LS3/5, absolutely certain without the “A”.

This is because BBC’s earliest speaker, designed by Spendor, was called the LS3/5. However, BBC, being a public institution in the UK, couldn’t directly purchase from Spendor and had to open public tenders. Rogers, Harbeth, and KEF all joined in with their input, and ultimately KEF’s drivers were adopted. With slightly modified specifications, it could no longer be called the LS3/5, so an “A” was added to differentiate it – that’s how our familiar LS3/5A came to be.

Finding the “Authentic” Designer

But shouldn’t Graham’s use of the Chartwell name be considered just another “enthusiast’s feat”? Does it mean that LS3/5A reproductions by British companies count while those made with old components in Asia don’t? The key lies in Graham’s choice of designer, who can be considered “authentic” – Derek Hughes, whose connection with BBC Monitors began in his teenage years.

How so? He is Spencer Hughes’ son, and Spencer was a key figure in bringing the series of BBC Monitors to life. He was also the owner of Spendor, so Derek was immersed in the so-called “BBC sound” from his youth, with deep family roots in the tradition.

Chartwell BBC LS3/5 Vintage Speakers Review

Paul Graham, who has a passion for BBC Monitor reproduction, found the authentic successor in Derek. But why doesn’t their new Chartwell LS3/5 have an “A” suffix? Because when Spencer designed the earliest LS3/5, he only made 20 pairs for BBC testing and evaluation. Later, BBC accepted Spencer’s design but had to open public tenders, so they slightly modified the specifications to become the LS3/5A, and the original 20 pairs of LS3/5 were returned to Spencer. This Chartwell LS3/5 reproduction is based on that original design, making it somewhat different from the common LS3/5A.

First Batch of Only 150 Pairs – All Sold Out

That’s how I ordered the Chartwell LS3/5 at the Munich High End Show in May. After returning to Taiwan, I met Mr. Zhang from Soundray at the Yuanshan Audio Show and asked if the speakers had arrived. Mr. Zhang said the factory hadn’t delivered yet and asked me to be patient. Little did I know I would have to wait until the end of the year.

Reportedly, Graham only produced 150 pairs in the first batch, and they were all sold out. Taiwan only received 5 pairs, all at Yuedian.

Having just received my Chartwell LS3/5, I was curious to hear how others would pair it. Mr. Hong at Yuedian is an old acquaintance – I used to listen to his LS3/5A setups during my university days. Although I couldn’t afford any of the equipment I wanted to buy back then, this poor student learned quite a lot about audio from listening to Mr. Hong’s expertise.

Chartwell BBC LS3/5 Vintage Speakers Review

Is It Authentically Original?

Mr. Hong hesitated for a moment, saying that the Chartwell LS3/5 was clearly excellent upon first listen, especially with its clean and transparent sound foundation and very black musical background. While it felt more transparent than previous LS3/5As and less rich, it still retained the BBC Monitor character.

Moreover, Mr. Hong mentioned that despite the speaker’s small size, the bass extension was very natural. You don’t immediately think it’s a small speaker lacking in bass. I agree – after a few days of running in the Chartwell LS3/5 at home, I too liked it immediately, though it didn’t feel exactly like an LS3/5A, yet still maintained that British flavor.

Perhaps we shouldn’t think about whether the Chartwell LS3/5 “equals” the LS3/5A, but rather consider it as a “new creation with old heritage” by BBC Monitor designers. This might be a fairer way to approach these speakers.

Capable of Presenting Deep and Spacious Soundstage

After hearing my comment, Mr. Hong suggested starting with Roksan, pairing with the Roksan K3 BT amplifier, which outputs 150 watts, and using the Naim CD5 Si as the digital source.

This was a nice combination – an all-British system. Although the Chartwell LS3/5 looked like a toy in Yuedian’s showroom, appearing very small in proportion, the sound it produced was smooth and flowing.

Listening to Mozart’s Piano Trios K. 496 & K.502 performed by Pires, Dumay, and Wang Jian, the piano danced lightly, underpinned by the cello’s sustained notes, with the violin weaving decorative lines between them. As expected in Mozart’s piano trios, the piano takes the leading role. Despite the Chartwell LS3/5’s small dimensions, the trio sounded both transparent and fluid. The Roksan K3 BT drove them effortlessly, capable of presenting a deep and spacious soundstage.

After switching through several albums, I asked Mr. Hong if we could try a different combination. He mentioned that the distributor had just brought in a higher-end Roksan Caspian M2 integrated amplifier that we could try.

This Caspian M2, though higher-end, actually has less power, only 85 watts.

Listening to the same Mozart piece, the Caspian M2 displayed higher sound density, making the Chartwell LS3/5’s piano sound even more crystalline, with better transparency and more beautiful imaging of musical notes.

Although the Chartwell LS3/5 is rated at 83dB sensitivity and considered difficult to drive, both the 150-watt Roksan K3 BT and the 85-watt Caspian M2 could deliver ample volume and force. However, their sonic characters differed noticeably – the K3 BT sounded fluid, while the Caspian M2 was more compact and solid, with each note being more substantial and elastic, showing better detail rendering.

This shows that power isn’t everything – the amplifier’s “quality” is more crucial in matching.

Excellent at Expressing the Cello’s Subtle Transitions from Light to Heavy

After switching to the full Naim setup, with CD5 Si and Super Nait 2 connected via DIN cables, and the CD5 Si’s RCA output disabled to use only the DIN connection – this is the most orthodox Naim configuration! Yes, this was it. With the same Mozart piece by Pires, Dumay, and Wang Jian, the music came alive through the Chartwell LS3/5, especially in terms of low-frequency stability and credibility. While the Chartwell LS3/5 could never produce extreme bass, being factory-rated only down to 70Hz, the cello’s sustained notes sounded stable. The imaging was focused but not overly large, maintaining refined dimensions. The interweaving of piano, cello, and violin created proportions so exquisite that one could see the whole picture while clearly distinguishing their relationships.

The more I listened, the more captivating it became. I told Mr. Hong to pay attention to Wang Jian’s cello, particularly those transitions from light to heavy – that’s Wang Jian’s most enchanting playing characteristic. It’s a very refined quality that’s hard to describe; you have to hear it to understand.

Could the Chartwell LS3/5 express these subtle transitions in the cello from light to heavy? Absolutely no problem.

I also listened to Sara K.’s “Play On Words” and the “Les Misérables Live 2010 Recording” – both sounded best with the full Naim setup.

That day’s highlight was definitely Mozart, as I listened to the first movement completely through all three combinations. Then, with the full Naim setup, I tackled the most challenging piece: Mahler’s First Symphony, listening to Jan Willem de Vriend conducting the Netherlands Symphony Orchestra. I went straight to the most difficult fourth movement: “From Hell to Heaven.” Even during the earth-shattering explosions that pushed the Chartwell LS3/5 almost to its limits, the speakers held on without truly breaking up. This went beyond what you’d expect from bookshelf speakers, but I didn’t back down. In the midst of the “hellish” chaos, with waves of tremendous music nearly overwhelming the speakers, when the second theme of heaven arrived, the Chartwell LS3/5 returned to those beautifully rendered strings, floating in the air with delicacy, contrasting with the almost collapsing hell – this heaven was truly beautiful!

My Years-Long Search for “My Speakers”

I haven’t actually told the complete story about the Chartwell LS3/5, because these are “my speakers.” I came to Yuedian to seek guidance and to learn how I should set them up myself.

But I want to say that even as times change, and though the Chartwell LS3/5 is a “heritage piece made new,” that characteristic BBC Monitor flavor remains unchanged. Although the Chartwell LS3/5 is fresher, more transparent, and more robust, you can still tell immediately: “Ah! This is the British speaker sound!” Yes, it’s for this flavor that’s so hard to describe in words that I’ve been searching for many years!

Chartwell BBC LS3 5 Vintage Speakers Review image 5

Equipment Specifications:

  • Model: Chartwell LS3/5
  • Type: 2-way, 2-driver sealed bookshelf speaker
  • Frequency Response: 70Hz-20kHz ±3dB
  • Impedance: 9 ohms
  • Sensitivity: 83 dB
  • Recommended Amplifier Power: 25-50 watts
  • Dimensions: 300×190×170 mm (H×W×D)
  • Weight: 5.3 kg