Elac FS 407 Floorstanding Speaker Review
|

Elac FS 407 Floorstanding Speaker Review


At audio shows, the equipment that tends to steal the spotlight is often massive, super-sized systems. However, for most people, truly practical equipment is what matters. The Elac FS 407 is a perfect example – measuring around one meter in height with a footprint slightly larger than an A4 paper, it can fit into most home spaces. Yet, the musical experience it delivers genuinely transcends its modest dimensions.

The manufacturer’s claim that the FS 407 is understated in design but uncompromising in sound performance is absolutely true.

JET 5 Tweeter: A Hallmark of High-End Speakers

I’ve visited the Elac factory twice and was deeply impressed by their meticulous design, research, and manufacturing processes. In 2016, Elac launched the flagship Concentro speakers, elevating the brand to new heights.

In Elac’s product hierarchy, the Concentro sits at the top, followed by the Line 500 series, then the Line 400 series (where the FS 407 belongs), and subsequently Line 300, Line 260, Line 240.3, and Line 70.

Elac FS 407 Floorstanding Speaker Review

Additionally, they have the Uni-Fi Slim, Debut, and Adante series with coaxial drivers – new designs introduced after Andrew Jones joined Elac. However, in terms of the brand’s long-standing identity, speakers featuring JET air motion tweeters are undoubtedly Elac’s most classic products.

Air motion tweeters weren’t invented by Elac, and many manufacturers produce similar technologies. However, the JET air motion tweeter is Elac’s “proprietary technique”. Other manufacturers cannot call their designs “JET” – typically, air motion tweeters are called Emitters or Air Motion Tweeters. JET is an acronym for Jet Emitter Tweeter, encompassing Elac’s exclusive patents, including special manufacturing processes, ultra-thin aluminum diaphragms, and unique adhesives and damping materials.

All JET air motion tweeters are designed and handcrafted by Elac at their factory in Keil, Germany. The FS 407 uses the fifth-generation JET air motion tweeter, known as JET 5.

The working principle of JET was proposed by Dr. Oscar Heil in the 1970s, with the design theory already well-established. The main challenge was manufacturing. Interestingly, Dr. Heil did not patent his design, so all tweeters based on his theory are called air motion tweeters.

Air motion tweeters offer significant advantages: a massive diaphragm size allows moving more air and provides the widest dispersion angle. However, they are challenging to manufacture, especially controlling noise from large-area diaphragms – a persistent challenge for all manufacturers.

Elac is no exception. Each JET generation has improved noise and distortion characteristics. The JET 5 used in the FS 407 represents their current pinnacle of tweeter technology.

An interesting side note: If you drive a Porsche with a Burmester high-end car audio system, the tweeter is a JET 4, specially designed for automotive audio.

Crystal Surface Diaphragm and 2.5-Way Design

The FS 407 employs a 2.5-way design with dual mid-bass drivers featuring “crystal surface diaphragms” – a name derived from the crystal-like surface texture of the diaphragm, not from adding actual crystal materials.

The concept is straightforward. While typical mid-bass diaphragms use concave designs, Elac innovated by pressing special crystal-like patterns onto smooth concave surfaces. This increases aluminum diaphragm rigidity and reduces cone breakup distortion during intense piston-like movements.

The principle might seem simple, but determining the optimal pattern shape requires extensive experimentation and measurement – something difficult for others to replicate.

Moreover, Elac’s mid-bass drivers aren’t simply aluminum diaphragms. They use “Aluminum-Sandwich AS Technology” – a sandwich construction with a paper core, sandwiched between aluminum alloy layers, bonded with special adhesives. This approach provides the high rigidity of aluminum alloy while the paper core offers appropriate damping, achieving a driver diaphragm that is “stiff, light, and high in internal resistance”.

Wide Suspension for Extended Excursion

Elac’s mid-bass drivers also feature extraordinary excursion. The TT 180 mid-bass driver in the FS 407 offers a maximum front-to-back movement of +/-15mm – a total of three centimeters. If you look closely, you’ll notice wider suspensions compared to similarly sized drivers, designed to accommodate this extensive movement. This long excursion enables Elac to move substantial air volumes, resulting in powerful musical dynamics.

While these design principles might sound simple and rooted in basic driver design fundamentals, executing them perfectly requires meticulous attention to every detail.

Given Elac’s capability to design and manufacture their own drivers, their speaker discussions always begin with the drivers themselves.

As for the speaker cabinet, the FS 407 uses traditional MDF material with a simple, square design – nothing overly fancy, but with carefully considered details.

For instance, the FS 407 features a magnetic grille. When removed, the speaker panel remains pristine, without unsightly mounting holes – beautiful even without the grille.

The final notable feature is the dedicated foot design, allowing easy height and level adjustments. The manufacturer provides two options: metal spikes and soft plastic pads. For wooden floors, use the non-damaging soft pads; for marble surfaces or carpets, metal spikes are recommended.

Elac FS 407 Floorstanding Speaker Review

Downward-Firing Bass Reflex Port: A Positioning Advantage

For typical home spaces, the FS 407 features an important design that makes music enjoyment easier: a downward-firing bass reflex port.

Traditionally, bass reflex ports are either front or rear-facing. Forward-facing ports reduce wall interference but might slightly decrease volume. Rear-facing ports require careful positioning, as proximity to walls can create low-frequency standing waves, adding unwanted bass thickness without cleanliness.

The solution? Downward firing! By directing the port downward, low-frequency extension occurs more naturally, with minimal wall interference.

Why aren’t downward-firing designs more common? The answer is simple: higher cost. Front or rear ports don’t require complex base material considerations. Downward-firing ports demand elevating the speaker, ensuring sufficient airflow space at the bottom, and carefully designing the port’s exit point to enhance both bass quantity and quality. These additional base design requirements increase manufacturing costs.

Punching Above Its Weight

In the HiFiReport listening room, the FS 407 initially appears small in a space of around 20 square meters. However, there’s no need for concern. Elac has always been about “punching above its weight” – much like my long-used 310.2 model, which, with sufficient amplifier power, becomes more dynamic the harder it’s driven, delivering musical energy that far exceeds expectations based on its cabinet size.

The FS 407, significantly larger than the 310.2, maintains Elac’s precise, quick performance but with a more relaxed listening experience. Its low-frequency response feels more spacious and fluid compared to bookshelf speakers that rely on amplifier power to squeeze out bass. The FS 407’s mid-low frequency performance is remarkably smooth and effortless.

Its amplifier compatibility is equally impressive. The 310.2 was more demanding, often hesitant with less powerful amplifiers. In contrast, the FS 407 is more accommodating. Using the Linear Acoustic LAV60 MK II with 100 watts, the speakers performed brilliantly – transparent, expansive, fast, and powerful.

Switching to the Oriole 1BV tube integrated amplifier (around 50 watts), the low-frequency performance became fuller, with a slightly slower speed and a more saturated musical presentation. Even this 50-watt unit drove the FS 407 comfortably.

I even tried the Integra DTR-50.7 surround amplifier, which drove the FS 407 without any power insufficiency. While its sound was lighter compared to the LAV 60 MK II or 1BV tube amp, it never felt underpowered.

Elac FS 407 Floorstanding Speaker Review

Effortless Positioning

Beyond easy sound and amplifier pairing, the FS 407 offers a third “ease” – positioning. Placed in my typical listening spot, the soundstage was immediately impressive. Even when positioned very close to the rear wall, compromising depth and width, the FS 407 maintained an acceptable soundstage without becoming completely flat.

While tight wall placement isn’t ideal, I understand many homes have spatial limitations. For those with restricted positioning options, the FS 407 is worth considering. The JET 5’s ultra-wide dispersion angle makes speaker placement more forgiving.

Best Paired with LAV 60 MK II

The FS 407 delivers an expansive, open-hearted sound performance. Playing Tchaikovsky’s “Mazeppa” by RR, the recording’s inherent transparency shines through. The gentle string section’s delightful opening gradually builds with percussion and woodwinds, creating increasingly intense musical scenes. The FS 407 handled the warming Mazeppa dance effortlessly – strings dense and lustrous, contrasting beautifully with the powerful percussion.

The LAV 60 MK II particularly excelled, driving the FS 407 with rich, energetic low frequencies, quick speed, and transparent soundstage. The 1BV tube amp offered fuller mid-low frequencies with a slightly denser tone, warmer brass, while even the DTR-50.7 surround amp produced substantial low-end volume.

Of these three amplifiers, the LAV 60 MK II remained my favorite, delivering not just abundant low-frequency presence but also incredibly vivid musical expression.

Jazz Club Atmosphere

The FS 407’s mid-high frequency detail and soundstage capabilities bring music to life. Take the Bill Evans Trio’s “Waltz for Debbie” – a jazz album capturing intimate club ambiance. In “My Foolish Heart,” a simple two-note piano introduction, brushed jazz drums, subtle percussion, and background audience sounds create a living, breathing performance.

These musical details emerge on the FS 407 with vibrant jazz club atmosphere. The full, concentrated bass remains powerful, with Bill Evans’ spontaneous piano creating a relaxed, leisurely jazz flavor.

Soaring, Non-Fatiguing Violin

The FS 407’s mid-high frequency performance, especially with strings, is particularly noteworthy. Powerful yet comfortable, never feeling tense.

In the “Carmen Fantasy” by Mutter and Lee, a massive orchestral performance unfolds. Brass, woodwinds, and strings interweave, with percussion adding excitement. The solo violin enters in low register, gradually rising and becoming more prominent. The FS 407 captures this violin’s transformative journey – from thick to light, from low to high – without becoming shrill. Even when reaching higher octaves, the violin remains delicate, with brilliant, non-fatiguing harmonic overtones.

Elac FS 407 Floorstanding Speaker Review

A Shortcut to Great Sound

Equipped with the JET 5, the FS 407 can be considered a “high-performance model” in the Elac family. Priced in the mid-range, its performance competes with the brand’s higher-end models. The mid-high frequencies are vibrant and dynamic, with an open and natural soundstage. The low-frequency response maintains Elac’s characteristic abundance. Its relatively compact floorstanding speaker size makes it easier to integrate into typical home environments.

With its easy-to-drive nature, excellent amplifier compatibility, and flexible positioning, the FS 407 truly represents a shortcut to enjoying outstanding sound!

Technical Specifications

  • Type: 3-driver, 2.5-way bass reflex floorstanding speaker
  • Drivers:
  • 2 × 150mm Crystal Diaphragm Mid-Bass Drivers
  • 1 × JET 5 Tweeter
  • Frequency Response: 30Hz ~ 50kHz
  • Crossover Points: 450Hz / 2.5kHz
  • Sensitivity: 88dB
  • Impedance: 4 ohms
  • Dimensions: 1038 × 260 × 314mm (H × W × D)
  • Weight: 20.4kg