Esoteric S-05_A30 Review_1
|

Esoteric S-05 Class A Amp Review


Esoteric, the renowned Japanese Hi-Fi manufacturer, currently offers three power amplifiers in its lineup: the flagship Grandioso M1X, the step-down S-02, and the S-05, which just hit the market last month. Among these three, the S-05 holds a unique position, despite being the entry-level model, as it’s the only one featuring a pure Class A amplification circuit.

What is Pure Class A?

Seeing the words “pure Class A” immediately made my eyes light up. For audiophiles, pure Class A represents the amplification topology with the lowest distortion and purest sound quality. While modern Class AB amplifiers sound excellent, and Class D amplifiers are rapidly gaining prominence, the ideal state represented by pure Class A remains unparalleled in the hearts of many enthusiasts.

The question is, how pure is the S-05’s Class A? Many amplifiers on the market claim to be Class A, but most achieve this by simply increasing the bias current to a limited extent. This reduces crossover distortion in the push-pull output stage, mimicking some characteristics of Class A operation.

Let’s quickly examine the S-05’s specifications. With an 8-ohm load, the output power is a mere 30 watts, yet the quiescent power consumption astonishingly reaches 210 watts! Now, that’s the real deal! The S-05 embodies the true “pure Class A” amplifier that audiophiles dream of: the least efficient, hottest-running, but absolutely free from crossover distortion. It minimizes harsh odd-order harmonic distortion and delivers the purest, most beautiful sound quality.

At this point, my eyes weren’t just bright; they were practically burning with fiery passion, like a character straight out of a manga!

Sufficient Power for Pure Class A

While pure Class A is wonderful, could the output power be a bit higher? To be honest, it’s difficult. A pure Class A amplifier producing 30 watts already consumes a whopping 210 watts just idling. If the output power were increased, the power consumption would skyrocket further, the operating temperature would be even higher, and the size, weight, and capacity of the power supply would become much more extreme, inevitably leading to a significantly higher price.

Looking back, 30 watts is actually a carefully calculated, just-right setting. Is 30 watts enough? Let’s try a calculation. Assume we pair it with a pair of speakers with 90dB sensitivity. 90dB means that when the amplifier outputs 1 watt, the sound pressure level measured at one meter from the speaker is 90dB. If the speaker is a point source radiating spherical sound waves, the sound pressure decreases by 6dB for every doubling of distance.

So, roughly estimated, if the listening position is 3 meters from the speakers, the sound pressure we hear is about 81dB. This level is actually sufficient for typical music listening, and at this point, the amplifier is only using about 1 watt of power.

Let’s say we occasionally want to listen to large-scale symphonies with significant dynamics. If we turn up the volume, the playback SPL might sometimes exceed 90dB. This is already a volume level that might prompt neighbors to knock on the door and complain. To achieve this volume, how many watts does the amplifier need to output? According to the formula, the sound pressure increases by 3dB for every doubling of amplifier power.

So, at 2 watts, the listening SPL is 84dB; at 4 watts, it’s 87dB; at 8 watts, it reaches 90dB; at 16 watts, it’s 93dB; and at 32 watts, the SPL reaches 96dB. Having calculated this, you should now realize whether the S-05’s 30 watts are sufficient – the answer is precisely adequate.

Of course, the S-05’s output power isn’t strictly limited to 30 watts. When the impedance is halved to 4 ohms, the S-05’s output power can double to 60 watts. However, Esoteric honestly states that at this level, it may not be operating in pure Class A mode. This is acceptable; when the music occasionally requires more power, it’s enough that the S-05 has the headroom to drive the speakers effectively.

My point is, in a typical room size, listening to music at the most comfortable volume of 70 to 80dB, high power isn’t necessarily required. The crucial factor is whether the amplifier can still operate within its optimal linear range during low to medium volume playback. It is under these conditions that a pure Class A amplifier truly demonstrates its advantage.

Most likely, you’ve heard of the concept of the “golden watt.” Even at low power output, a pure Class A amplifier operates in its optimal linear state, fully revealing the music’s details, timbre, dynamics, and balance. This characteristic is precisely what we need most for actual music listening, and it’s where Class AB or Class D amplification simply cannot compete. Now you understand why audiophiles are so enamored with pure Class A, and why my eyes were blazing!

Flagship Technologies Inherited

Esoteric actually has another integrated amplifier, the F-03A, which also features pure Class A amplification. Comparing the circuit designs of the S-05 and F-03A reveals a high degree of similarity. Initially, I thought the S-05 was simply a power amplifier version transplanting the F-03A’s circuit. However, I later discovered that the S-05 truly inherits design principles from the top-tier flagship Grandioso M1X power amplifier. Two key technologies highlight this connection:

Firstly, the S-05 inherits the SJ-BJT01 Super Junction Bipolar Transistor, first utilized in the Grandioso M1X. This power transistor technology was presented in 2020 at the ISPSD conference by New Japan Radio and Yamanashi University. Esoteric specially commissioned New Japan Radio to manufacture it and first used it in the Grandioso M1X. The S-05 is only the second amplifier in the world to employ this power transistor. What are the advantages of this transistor?

Higher power handling, greater current output, faster response speed, and a wider linear operating range. The S-05 uses three pairs of these transistors in parallel push-pull per channel, making the 30-watt output a very conservative rating with significant headroom.

Secondly, among Esoteric’s three power amplifiers, only the Grandioso M1X and the S-05 are equipped with the proprietary ESL-A analog transmission interface. This interface transmits current 100 times greater than standard interfaces, effectively eliminating noise and impedance variations during transmission.

Ideal Pairing: The N-05XD

Within Esoteric’s product line, which source component also features ESL-A and can be paired with the S-05? Esoteric has already planned for you. The N-05XD network player, also bearing the “5” designation, is the S-05’s perfect partner.

The N-05XD features volume control and incorporates the flagship Master Sound Discrete DAC technology. The S-05 inherits key amplification technology from the flagship power amplifier. Connected via the proprietary ESL-A interface, the two are practically a miniaturized version of the Grandioso flagship series. Grandioso owners might even envy the S-05’s pure Class A amplification.

Just compare the price difference between these two series, and you’ll understand how incredibly value-packed the N-05XD plus S-05 combination is!

Other Technical Features

Here are other technical features of the S-05: Firstly, it’s a dual-mono design with no global negative feedback, the shortest signal path, a minimalist circuit structure, and even independent rectification circuits for the left and right channels. Secondly, it uses a substantial 940VA EI transformer, providing better power quality than a toroidal transformer and capable of delivering more sufficient current during dynamic music playback, which is also a highly conservative setting for the S-05.

Thirdly, each channel uses four 10,000uF filter capacitors, the same grade used in the Grandioso flagship. Fourthly, it minimizes transmission impedance from the power supply to the output stage, significantly improving speaker control. Fifthly, optimized internal circuit layout enhances heat dissipation efficiency and maintains stable operating temperature.

Sixthly, the chassis top cover features a semi-floating structure, combined with proprietary anti-vibration metal feet, greatly reducing chassis resonance interference.

Listening Impressions

This listening session took place in the distributor’s listening room, paired with the N-05XD streaming source driving 91dB sensitivity Tannoy Stirling GR speakers. This setup can be considered the ideal match for the S-05. First, we listened to the Kossler Duo performing Saint-Saëns’ “Danse Macabre” on two classical guitars. The round, full, and meaty texture of the plucking was unmistakably the hallmark of pure Class A amplification.

The instant force of the pluck wasn’t an exaggerated burst, yet the control over attack and decay was instantaneous. The focus was on the quality of the overtones; I heard warm-toned, softer, and more natural harmonics – a quality rarely found in other amplifiers.

Next, listening to trumpeter Wynton Marsalis play “Napoli,” the trumpet’s focus, penetration, stability at high notes, and nimble response to rapid staccato were impeccable. But what struck me most again were the trumpet’s overtones – that golden, warm luster, not only delicate and pure but seemingly richer in layers, a characteristic I hadn’t experienced with other amplifiers.

Listening to Augustin Dumay and Maria João Pires’ performance of Franck’s Violin Sonata, the violin lines were focused, with ample energy on sustained notes, and sweet and tender in quiet passages. These qualities were beautiful. However, my attention was once again drawn to the slightly warm overtones that permeated the music. Previously, I only heard the airy overtones of this performance; now, I discovered how fantastically colorful the overtones blending from the violin and piano truly were!

Listening to Kathleen Battle sing Bach’s “Ave Maria,” the pure Class A midrange was simply unbeatable. The thickness, density, and elasticity of the human voice were so natural, the subtle emotional nuances so delicate, and the high notes sung with such purity, radiance, and solemnity. Such a voice truly possesses the magic to draw one into the music.

What surprised me most was the S-05’s performance with the Tannoy Stirling GR when playing jazz. The kick drum hits were fierce, full, and solid, the bass was tight and bouncy, the piano had rich, rounded luster, and the brass instruments sounded bright, dense, and full of fervor, unleashing their passionate energy without restraint. I had previously thought that Tannoy’s Prestige series coaxial speakers were only suitable for classical music.

Unexpectedly, driven by the S-05, they were equally adept at playing jazz.

The Value of Overtone Reproduction

It’s not difficult to make an amplifier powerful, nor is it difficult to produce abundant bass. However, reproducing realistic and mellow musical texture, especially the rendition of overtones, is the true value of an ultimate Hi-End amplifier. The timbre of voices and instruments is built upon the most subtle overtones. Any distortion or noise from the amplifier will damage the most precious overtones in the music and recording.

If the overtone structure is destroyed, no matter how powerful the amplifier, we can only hear the shell of the music but cannot feel its soul. Yes, the S-05 runs hot and consumes a lot of power, but for that purest 30 watts, for hearing the most moving soul deep within the music, every bit of effort is worthwhile.

Specifications

* Type: Stereo solid-state power amplifier
* Release Date: 2022
* Frequency Response: 5Hz-100kHz (+0/-3dB, 8 ohms)
* Output Power Per Channel:

* 30 watts (8 ohms)
* 60 watts (4 ohms)
* 120 watts (Bridged, 8 ohms)
* Optimal Speaker Impedance Range:
* 4-16 ohms
* 8-16 ohms (Bridged)
* Total Harmonic Distortion: 0.007% (1kHz, 8 ohms, 30 watts)

* Signal-to-Noise Ratio: 102dB (XLR)
* Input Terminals: ESL-A × 1, RCA × 1, XLR × 1
* Power Consumption: 245 watts (Quiescent: 210 watts)
* Dimensions (WHD): 445×191×444mm
* Weight: 30.7 kg

Highlights

* True full-power, crossover distortion-free pure Class A amplification.
* The second amplifier in the world to use the SJ-BJT01 bipolar power transistor.
* Minimalist circuit, shortest signal path, no global negative feedback, dual-mono architecture.
* Rich and full sound quality, abundant overtone color, direct and unrestrained bass.

Notes & Recommendations

* Best paired with speakers having high sensitivity (90dB or above) if possible.
* Pairing with Esoteric’s own N-05XD streaming source using the proprietary ESL-A interface is the optimal combination.