H2O Audio Surge S Waterproof Sport Headphones (Short Cord Design) - photo 1

H2O Audio Surge S+ Waterproof Sport Headphones Review


The H2O Audio Surge S+ is a wired, in-ear headphone built for swimmers and water athletes, and its entire value proposition is keeping stereo audio functional at the bottom of a pool.

Quick Verdict

The Surge S+ is the default earbud for lap swimmers who want full IPX8 submersion without buying a dedicated underwater MP3 ecosystem. The IPX8 rating (12 ft / 3.6 m) means complete submersion is within spec, not just splash resistance. The core limitation is fit: the tips seat deep in the canal, which blocks water for most users but makes removal awkward and invites strain on the thin wires. For anyone whose primary use is pool swimming with a consumer MP3 player, the combination of IPX8 sealing, five tip sizes, and a one-year warranty makes this the practical pick.

First published at hifireport.com. Copying or republishing this content is prohibited.

Pros and Cons

Pros:

H2O Audio Surge S Waterproof Sport Headphones (Short Cord Design) - photo 5
  • IPX8 rated for full submersion to 12 ft / 3.6 m, well beyond splash-proof territory
  • Five earplug sizes (XS through XL) plus three additional tip sets for a secure seal
  • Short-cord design cuts down on snagging and tangled cable in the water
  • One-year warranty backed by a small-business support team that replaces defective units
  • Stereo image with usable bass that outperforms the stock earbuds shipped with most waterproof MP3 players

Cons:

First published at hifireport.com. Copying or republishing this content is prohibited.

  • Deep-seating tips have no stem or handle, making extraction difficult and straining the thin wire
  • Water can seep around the seal for users with wider ear canals, muffling audio mid-swim
  • No active noise cancellation; isolation is purely passive through the tip
  • Wired design limits use to swimmers or athletes who carry a small MP3 player or iPod

Who Should Buy This

The Surge S+ fits the daily lap swimmer who already owns a waterproof MP3 player (the SEWOBYE unit is a common pairing per owner reports) and needs earbuds that survive 12-foot submersion without committing to a fully integrated underwater system. H2O Audio describes the line as designed for athletes by athletes, and the product targets swimmers, runners, cyclists, paddle-boarders, and surfers who need a single pair of earbuds that handles rain, heavy perspiration, and full submersion. One owner who has swam two miles a day for over a decade and worked with earbuds and MP3 players for roughly 12 years settled on the Surge S+ as the one set that survives the kick-against-the-wall pressure without degrading.

H2O Audio Surge S Waterproof Sport Headphones (Short Cord Design) - photo 4

A second strong profile is the open-water cyclist, runner, or paddle-boarder who wants one pair of earbuds that handles rain, heavy perspiration, and an accidental dunk in a lake. A third is the gym-goer who cranks interval sessions and wants sweat-proof stereo without worrying about dripping onto equipment.

Skip this product if you are an audiophile seeking high-fidelity listening while submerged. Several reviewers who A/B tested the Surge S+ against sealed consumer in-ears such as the Shure SE215 or SE535 found the latter delivered noticeably cleaner mids and more layered detail, even underwater. If tonal accuracy matters more than convenience, a passive in-ear with a good physical seal will sound better than the Surge S+ in the pool.

H2O Audio Surge S Waterproof Sport Headphones (Short Cord Design) - photo 7

Build and Comfort

The housing is sheared to an ergonomic profile that sits flush with the outer ear, aligning the driver axis with the ear canal. The body is small, and the rubber tips are soft; owners report that the material stays comfortable even when the largest size is twisted and squeezed into place. The short cord is the defining design choice: long enough to reach a neck-worn MP3 player without excess slack, yet short enough to reduce the chance of catching on pool ladders or handlebars. Earlier H2O Audio models drew criticism for cords that were too long and occasionally weak rubber on the ear pieces; the short-cord Surge S+ is the revised design that addresses both shortcomings. The plug is a straight connector, and one UK-based owner noted it protrudes noticeably to one side, so he anchored it to his goggles strap with a cable tie to limit flex at the junction.

Long-term comfort hinges on tip size. The product ships with five earplug sizes from XS to XL and three additional tip sets. Reviewers consistently recommend starting with the largest tip and working down; a tighter seal both blocks water and improves bass response. Some users with wider canals still report occasional leakage, and one long-time owner swapped to aftermarket memory-foam tips (the New Bee 12-pack) that expand when wet and hold a better seal, though they degrade over time and need periodic replacement. The fit is also a personal-geometry issue: one reviewer in Italy tried every available tip and still saw a small amount of water entering one ear, a problem he attributed to his own ear shape rather than the product.

H2O Audio Surge S Waterproof Sport Headphones (Short Cord Design) - photo 3

Sound Quality

Bass and Low-End

The Surge S+ delivers a warm, bass-forward stereo image that is a clear step up from the flimsy earbuds bundled with most waterproof MP3 players, though it will not compete with a dedicated audiophile in-ear. One reviewer who owns custom-molded IEMs and high-end over-ears rated the product highly for its use case, noting that underwater bubble noise washes out fine detail regardless of driver quality, so a solid fundamental tone with a decent soundstage is the realistic target. Bass is the standout; owners describe the low end as punchy and present, which helps mask the constant water rush in a pool. Owners also note the output is loud enough to cut through the constant water rush of a lap swim, which is the primary volume challenge in that environment.

Treble and Mids

The mid and upper range is where the product falls short. A reviewer who compared the Surge S+ against three consumer in-ear models (including a Shure SE535 and a SE215, plus a Creative EP-630 and a Panasonic RP-HJE120-S) described the H2O sound as muddy in the highs and mids, with superior layering on the Shure units even submerged. The same reviewer found that the Creative EP-630 and the Panasonic RP-HJE120-S, both standard consumer in-ears, also functioned acceptably underwater and ranked above the Surge S+ in overall clarity. For lap swimmers listening to pop, rock, or electronic sets, the muddiness is tolerable. For classical or jazz, the loss of treble detail and spatial separation is more noticeable, though one reviewer who plays Chopin nocturnes and Brahms concertos while swimming called the experience “blissful” and reported extending his sessions from 15 to 20 minutes to 30 to 40 minutes non-stop. The added endurance, he noted, made the workout genuinely more enjoyable.

H2O Audio Surge S Waterproof Sport Headphones (Short Cord Design) - photo 2

Cancelling the Noise

There is no active noise cancellation in the Surge S+; isolation comes entirely from the physical seal of the tip in the ear canal. The IPX8-rated tip, when seated correctly, blocks the constant pool-water noise well enough that stereo detail comes through, and owners report that starting with the largest tip and wiping the outer ear dry before insertion makes a meaningful difference. The three-step sealing process that owners report works best: start with the largest tip and work down, wipe the outer ear (not the canal) with a dry swab to remove oil and sweat before insertion, then pull the top of the ear back with the opposite hand to stretch the canal open before seating the bud. The practical ceiling is your anatomy: users with wider canals or shallow conchae will feel water seeping around the tip after a few laps, and the music becomes muffled and distant, as two separate reviewers described. The design offers no mechanical seal beyond the tip, so the level of isolation is only as good as your fit.

Battery Life

The Surge S+ has no battery and no onboard electronics; it is a passive wired earbud powered entirely by whatever MP3 player, iPod, or phone it plugs into. There is no charge cycle to manage and no battery degradation to worry about over months of pool use. The only longevity concern is mechanical: the thin wire can fatigue where it meets the plug, particularly if the straight connector flexes against a neck strap or goggles, and the in-ear housing has no reinforced strain relief at the ear exit. One owner reported a one-side speaker muffle after 18 months of use at two to three hours per week in the water, which is a reasonable service life for a submersible product.

H2O Audio Surge S Waterproof Sport Headphones (Short Cord Design) - photo 6

Owner Feedback

The aggregate rating sits at 3.9 out of 5 across 869 reviews, a number that masks a sharp split between satisfied swimmers and frustrated fit-mismatch users. The five-star cluster, which makes up the majority of the sample, centers on swimmers who found a tip size that sealed completely and then stopped thinking about the earbuds. One long-time owner, now in his sixth year buying the Surge line, praised the company’s warranty response: a set that arrived with one non-functional driver was replaced promptly after a single email to the support team. That same owner noted that after years of trying cheap and expensive alternatives, more expensive did not usually mean better, and the H2O units used daily often lasted well over a year. Another reviewer noted the sound is loud and bassy, the cable length suits a neck-worn player, and he has experienced no leakage with the largest tip.

The one- and two-star reviews cluster around two issues. The first is the deep-seating tip with no retrieval handle: one reviewer called it a “fatal flaw,” explaining that pulling the thin wire to extract the bud creates shorts or detached conductors over time. The second is water ingress for users whose ear geometry does not match the available tip sizes; even the largest plug leaks for some, and the resulting muffled, distant sound is described as deal-breaking. A small number of reviewers who ordered internationally reported an inability to return a defective unit through local consumer-protection channels, which suggests a gap in warranty coverage outside the US.

Should You Buy It

The Surge S+ is the pragmatic choice if your non-negotiable is that the earbuds survive full submersion and you do not want to buy a dedicated underwater MP3 ecosystem. The IPX8 spec, the five-plus-three tip assortment, and the one-year warranty cover the mechanical side of pool use. What the product does not cover is audiophile-grade sound or a retrieval-friendly tip design, and those two gaps are what keep the rating at 3.9 rather than higher. If you can live with a warm, bass-leaning stereo image and you take a minute to dial in tip size and the ear-cleaning routine, the earbuds will reliably get you through 30-minute and 40-minute laps without a dead driver or a flooded ear.

Best for lap swimmers and water athletes who want a no-fuss, fully submersible stereo pair to clip to a consumer MP3 player, and who accept a warm, bass-leaning sound profile in exchange for genuine IPX8 wet-weather reliability.

Specifications

  • Waterproof Rating: IPX8 (submersion to 12 ft / 3.6 m)
  • Driver Type: In-ear, wired stereo
  • Cord: Short, straight-plug connector
  • Ear Tips: Five sizes (XS through XL) plus three additional tip sets
  • Warranty: 1 year
  • Compatibility: iPods and consumer MP3 players
  • Intended Use: Swimming, running, cycling, surfing, paddle boarding, gym workouts
  • Housing: Sheared ergonomic design, flush-ear profile
  • Power: Passive (no battery; powered by source device)
  • Availability (Amazon US): Currently listed as unavailable

FAQ

Do these earbuds work in open water, not just pools?

First published at hifireport.com. Copying or republishing this content is prohibited.

The IPX8 rating covers full submersion to 12 ft, so a dip in a lake or ocean is within spec. Owners who run, cycle, or paddle-board in rain and heavy sweat report the same performance. The short cord reduces the chance of snagging on natural obstacles compared to a long cable.

Can I use them with a phone or Bluetooth player?

No. The Surge S+ is a wired, passive earbud with a straight plug. It connects to a waterproof MP3 player or iPod. There is no Bluetooth module, no charging port, and no wireless pairing of any kind.

What if water still gets in my ear even with the largest tip?

Start with the XL tip, wipe the outer ear with a dry swab before insertion, and pull the top of the ear back with your free hand to open the canal before seating the bud. One owner also found that aftermarket memory-foam tips, such as the New Bee 12-pack, expand when wet and hold a tighter seal than the stock rubber.

Does the one-year warranty cover international buyers?

The warranty is administered by H2O Audio as a US small business. At least one reviewer in Brazil reported an inability to return a defective unit through local consumer-protection channels, so international buyers should confirm coverage before ordering.

H2O Audio Surge S+ Waterproof Sport Headphones, (Short Cord Design) – in-Ear Sweatproof Earbuds for Swimming, Running, Cycling – IPX8 Waterproof, Compatible with iPods & MP3 Players
  • SUPERIOR SOUND. Our Waterproof headphone technology uses the highest quality internal sound components to produce the best possible sound under water with premium bass.
  • HIGHEST WATERPROOF RATING. 100% waterproof stereo earphones that can withstand heavy perspiration, rain, and complete submersion to 12ft/3.6m underwater with an IPX8 rating.
  • PEACE OF MIND with H2O Audio's 1 Year Warranty: Buy with confidence! Our product includes industry leading 1 YEAR WARRANTY. We are a small business and stand behind all the products we make.