TAD R1TX_ Review_1
|

TAD R1TX Flagship Review


Tong Wei Audio has several listening rooms, each with different décor and sonic characteristics. According to Hu Nai-Yuan, they once moved the TAD R1 upstairs to a listening room, but the sound wasn’t as good as in the downstairs room, so they went through the effort of moving it back down. Just how effective is the downstairs listening room?

The moment I sat down and listened, I immediately felt the sound was clean and expansive, with excellent extension at both the low and high ends, without feeling overly restrained. Furthermore, the midrange was lively and full-bodied, showing no signs of coloration. Overall, it’s a very successful listening space.

Tong Wei Audio Listening Room

How exactly did Tong Wei Audio create this space? Aside from the floor, the entire area is covered in perforated metal acoustic panels, commonly seen in public buildings. No, not metal! I touched the panels, and they felt cool, making me think they were metal. However, after receiving information from the designer, Chen Zhi-An, son of Tong Wei Audio’s owner, I learned that it’s a composite recycled material made from a mixture of multiple materials.

I’ve copied the details provided by Tong Wei Audio regarding the materials and design of this sonically excellent space below:

“I am Chen Zhi-An, the designer of Tong Wei’s listening room and the person in charge of Dian Song Acoustics Co., Ltd. Our company focuses on representing professional audio brands (German CODA AUDIO/BMS Speaker Group) and integrating electroacoustics with architectural acoustics.

1. The material is made from a mixture of solid wood boards, MDF, wood fiber, and high polyethylene composite. 2. The joining method is a tongue-and-groove interlocking system. 3. Black non-woven fabric is adhered to the back of the acoustic panels. 4. Different models (perforation rates) offer varying sound absorption effects. 5. There are nearly 8 color options (Cedar, Asian Teak, Golden Maple, Thai Teak, Rosewood, Red Elm, Mahogany, Cherry). The ones sold in Taiwan are mostly the first five.

The white color at Tong Wei was spray-painted by the designer himself (this product is less promoted now because it only has flame-retardant properties; we are currently focused on developing grooved acoustic panels with fire resistance) – The distributing vendor is Lei Neng Xing Ye Co., Ltd. in Kaohsiung – formerly known as Xin Jing Jie.

Before designing this room, we first referenced the RT (reverberation time) results obtained from AFMG EASE software to consider how to arrange the acoustic panels. What’s special about this room is that while both side walls use diffusion-absorption panels, they are actual solid wood panels installed over glass wool insulation behind them (utilizing panel vibration to absorb bass and diffusers to scatter high frequencies). So, both side walls are designed for diffusion.

Most people would think it’s entirely absorbent just by looking. Only the ceiling and the rear wall use direct acoustic panel installation with absorbent cotton. This ensures the space isn’t overly dead.”

Origins of the TAD R1TX

Having discussed Tong Wei Audio’s listening space, let’s return to the R1TX. The R1TX evolved from the Model One, first launched by TAD in 2003. The Model One was the first pair of TAD consumer Hi-End loudspeakers completed by Andrew Jones leading the TAD design team. During his time at TAD, Andrew Jones visited Taiwan multiple times and is well-known among Taiwanese audiophiles. He majored in Physics and Acoustics at university and also studied Quantum Mechanics.

After graduation, he researched computer-aided crossover networks (sponsored by Celestion speakers) and worked on noise control and cancellation, which was seemingly unrelated to loudspeaker design. However, he developed a passion for audio from middle school, attending AES lectures and audio shows, where he met Laurie Fincham, who was the technical director at KEF. One day, he received an offer letter from KEF, marking his entry into the field of Hi-End loudspeaker design.

Andrew Jones worked at KEF from 1983 to 1994. After leaving KEF, he moved from the UK to the US. After a brief period as a freelancer, he worked at Infinity Speakers for less than 3 years. In 2000 (or 1997), TAD decided to enter the consumer market. Invited by Floyd Toole, Andrew Jones joined Pioneer’s diaphragm material research department, studying materials including beryllium diaphragms.

Originally, TAD only produced driver units for professional audio and was not involved in finished products for the home market. When they decided to enter the consumer market, the first product they launched was the Model One, spearheaded by Andrew Jones.

In 2015, Andrew Jones left TAD to join Elac. In 2022, he moved to MoFi Electronics, and the MoFi SourcePoint 8 and 10 speakers you see now are his designs. The “SourcePoint” concept is essentially a coaxial driver. This is an extension of the Uni-Q coaxial driver research he was involved in while at KEF. Later, during his time at TAD, he developed the “CST coaxial driver” (Coherence Source Transducer). However, you shouldn’t assume CST is Andrew Jones’ patent.

Pioneer had already developed coaxial drivers as early as 1954 and applied for a patent in 1977, with the applicant being Pioneer engineer Takasuka. Andrew Jones should be credited with optimizing and developing the CST coaxial driver based on the research patents of previous Pioneer engineers.

As for beryllium diaphragms, Japanese companies like Pioneer and Yamaha had successfully developed them as early as the 1970s and used them in tweeter and midrange drivers. However, Japanese manufacturers later stopped producing beryllium diaphragms, leaving them dormant for a long time until they were “reawakened” by Focal’s introduction of beryllium tweeter drivers.

Getting back to the Model One, I witnessed its debut at CES in 2003. The cabinet displayed at the show was constructed from cross-sections of plywood glued and fixed together. This method was quite revolutionary in the speaker industry at the time, and later, several speakers, including the Magico Mini, also adopted this cabinet construction. Conversely, TAD abandoned this method for the successor model, the Reference One, because the cost of this cabinet was too high.

There’s an anecdote here: since the Model One was priced at $45,000 USD at the time, which was unaffordable for most people, Andrew Jones used the Model One’s research technology to develop Pioneer’s EX series speakers. That 5.1 channel speaker system was priced at over $30,000 USD back then. I bought a set for multichannel use at the magazine office. We once disassembled the CST driver from the EX and saw that it was stamped with the TAD logo.

Evolution of the R1 Series

In 2007, TAD launched the R1, which was introduced in Taiwan in 2008. In 2012, the R1 MK 2 was released in Japan and in Taiwan in 2014. In 2019, TAD launched the R1TX in Japan, but it wasn’t imported and introduced in Taiwan until 2022. The R1TX cabinet comes in two different wood veneers and colors: Emerald Black (TAD-R1TX-EB) and Beryl Red (TAD-R1TX-BR). There was also a special blue version (St. Maria Aquamarine) TAD-R1TX-LTD, but this was a limited edition and is now out of production.

R1TX Improvements

So, what are the differences between the R1TX and its predecessor (R1 MK II)? Firstly, the cabinet is now built in collaboration with the renowned Japanese furniture manufacturer Tendo Mokko (founded in 1940). The internal structure has also been improved based on Tendo’s research, and the molding process for the cabinet has been refined. The side and back panel structure has been changed from the original three pieces to two, making the cabinet more rigid.

Secondly, the curved top of the cabinet is smoother, and the angle has been improved. Thirdly, the crossover has been upgraded. Fourthly, the woofer drivers, including the surrounds and magnetic systems, have been improved. Fifthly, the internal damping materials have also been refined. Sixthly, the voice coil former is lighter and stronger. Seventhly, the Emerald Black color option was added.

Overall, the biggest difference between the R1TX and its predecessor is the cabinet being manufactured by Tendo Mokko; the rest are detailed improvements. Therefore, if you didn’t buy the R1 MK II, you missed out because there is a significant price difference between the R1TX and its predecessor. Why the price increase? Everything has been rising in price since COVID-19, so you can’t blame TAD.

Cabinet Design

The R1TX’s cabinet still features the teardrop-shaped SILENT (Structurally Inert Laminated Enclosure Technology) structure, crafted by Tendo Mokko. The SILENT cabinet side walls have an average thickness of 50mm (thickest point is 137mm). The internal structure is inspired by aircraft wings and ship compartments, using four layers of 21mm thick birch plywood as “diaphragms” to support the cabinet. The diaphragms are bonded to the cabinet using high-frequency hot press molding.

This structure results in extremely low cabinet resonance, allowing the drivers’ sound energy to be fully transmitted.

The top of the R1TX cabinet is curved and slopes backward by 4 degrees, allowing the four drivers to form a Time Alignment arrangement, ensuring the sound from each driver reaches the listener’s ears simultaneously. The CST driver is located at the top, with two 10-inch woofers below it. The CST covers the frequency range from 250Hz to 100kHz, while the two woofers handle frequencies below 250Hz.

CST Driver Technology

The CST coaxial driver comprises a 35mm beryllium tweeter and a 160mm beryllium midrange, with a crossover point set at 2kHz. The tweeter driver may seem unremarkable, but the shape of its diaphragm is created using HSDOM (Harmonized Synthetic Diaphragm Optimum Method) computer analysis to achieve the optimal curve. The beryllium diaphragms of both the tweeter and midrange drivers are produced using the Vapor Deposition technique, which TAD has employed for over 40 years.

Vapor Deposition involves vaporizing beryllium under high temperature and pressure, allowing the beryllium molecules to naturally deposit onto a mold, gradually forming the diaphragm. This method is expensive and technically challenging, which is why some other manufacturers produce beryllium diaphragms using a rolling process instead.

The CST coaxial driver is fixed using their ISO (isolation) technology, which isolates the CST driver from contact with the cabinet, preventing mutual interference between the driver and cabinet vibrations. More specifically, there is a metal ring where the CST driver contacts the cabinet, and two more metal rings in front of the coaxial driver’s surround. These front and rear rings clamp the driver, providing isolation between the driver and the cabinet.

Woofer Details

The two 10-inch woofers used in the R1TX are quite heavy and are placed at the cabinet’s center of gravity. The cabinet’s low center of gravity is achieved because the base is made from a combination of a 15mm thick aluminum alloy plate (weighing 12 kg) bonded with multiple layers of birch plywood. The entire cabinet weighs a hefty 150 kg. Even the design of the three spikes underneath is sophisticated; one is cone-shaped, and the other two are dome-shaped.

This spike structure makes the cabinet more stable and reduces vibration.

These two woofers are impressive. They use short voice coils, performing a 26mm piston-like motion within a 33mm long magnetic gap. They also employ an OFGMS (Optimized Field Geometry Magnet Structure) magnetic system. In traditional loudspeaker magnetic systems, reluctance affects the uniform distribution of magnetic flux density.

To solve this problem, the OFGMS has a slot in the top plate, which makes the magnetic flux density distribution more uniform, increasing it by 4%, from the original 0.48 Tesla to 0.50 Tesla. Furthermore, to compensate for the reduced voice coil strength caused by the short voice coil, Aramid fiber is wound 80 turns around the top of the voice coil and then solidified with hot resin. This reduces the overall weight of the voice coil former while increasing its strength.

In addition to the improved magnetic system, the woofers use a dual spider design, combined with a special surround design (Corrugated Surround, the same multi-layer fabric surround used in their professional drivers). This allows the woofer to withstand very large excursions (+/-15mm) without distortion, and the magnetic system’s driving force on the diaphragm is also increased by 4%.

These two woofers have a voice coil diameter of 100mm and are driven by powerful neodymium magnets. The diaphragm structure is a “Tri-Laminate Composite Cone” (TLCC) sandwich construction, with a core layer of Acrylamide foam material and outer layers of Aramid fiber. Furthermore, the central dust cap is made using the same method as the diaphragm. The voice coil is directly connected to the dust cap, driving the entire diaphragm.

At the bottom of the cabinet, there is their Aerodynamic Port System bass reflex port. The internal structure of this port looks like a curved ‘W’ or can be seen as a horn shape, which allows the back wave airflow from the woofers to be released in a compressed manner. This not only prevents port noise but also results in clearer bass.

Crossover & Connectivity

The back panel of the R1TX is made of 27mm thick aluminum alloy, and the crossover is mounted on this plate to improve heat dissipation. The crossover is divided into two sections: one for the midrange/tweeter and one for the woofer. In fact, the midrange/tweeter section is further divided into two boards for the tweeter and midrange. The air-core inductors, resistors, and PP film capacitors used in the crossover are custom-made.

The speaker binding posts are also custom-made, larger than standard posts, with thicker gold plating. All internal wiring is kept away from the magnets to avoid magnetic induction.

Listening Experience

Having covered the key highlights of the R1TX and the listening room at the beginning, let’s move on to the listening impressions. I typically use streaming for my “equipment reviews,” but unfortunately, Tong Wei Audio’s Aurender streamers were all sold out before I arrived, and new stock was still on the way. Fortunately, Hu Nai-Yuan brought over twenty CDs for me to listen to. I selected 16 of them for this review.

The accompanying equipment that day included the TAD-C700 preamplifier, TAD M-700S stereo power amplifier, and TAD D-1000TX CD player. The speaker placement was done by Hu Nai-Yuan.

The first CD I listened to was Guo Jin-Fa’s “Taiwan Ren.” The vocals were focused and full-bodied, the piano accompaniment was clear, the sound density was high, and the sense of presence was excellent. This is clearly a characteristic of the R1TX’s midrange. The second CD was Hugh Masekela’s “Hope.” As expected, the brass instruments were dazzling, bright yet not harsh, and had the necessary weight. The overall music was lively and dynamic. The bass was full, focused, and clear.

Especially on the final track, “Coal Train,” the R1TX demonstrated an excellent dynamic range and transient response, with a strong contrast between soft and loud passages. Even at the loudest peaks, the R1TX handled it effortlessly, showing no signs of strain.

Next, I listened to Mutter playing Tchaikovsky’s “Violin Concerto.” The violin was clear, bright, and transparent, without any lingering resonance. The violin lines were focused and had substance, the body resonance was beautiful, and the texture of the bow on the strings was clear and realistic. Honestly, these impressions are similar to what I heard from the R1 and R1 MK II previously, but the overall performance seems to be even better. Then I listened to the familiar piece “Sadness.”

The bowing transitions of the violin were delicate and smooth, the sound was sweet, and the violin lines were fine yet had substance, not sounding thin or unsubstantial. The piano had a rich woody tone and was lively and dynamic, not sounding stiff.

After that was Oscar Peterson’s “We Get Requests.” Indeed, the R1TX’s Double Bass performance was outstanding. Not only could I seemingly see the thick strings vibrating with my eyes, but the physical presence of the strings seemed to float in the air, felt deep in my chest. The plucking texture was very realistic, lively, and dynamic. The piano notes were solid, full-bodied, and substantial, with a sense of weight.

In this listening space, none of the double bass notes sounded bloated, indicating the absence of bass peaks, which is one reason why the music sounded clean and clear.

Next was Yo-Yo Ma and Bobby McFerrin’s “Hush.” The positioning of the vocals and cello was very clear, with sharp outlines, not blurry. The cello had a beautiful woody tone, carrying a nasal quality, and was warm. Then came RR Records’ “Danse Macabre.” The violin was sweet; just hearing such a violin sound was captivating. The kick drum notes were full and elastic, and the bass quantity was sufficient without being muddy.

Although the music had plenty of low-frequency content, the overall liveliness and transient response of the music were not compromised in the slightest. The high frequencies sounded delicate, soft, and warm, while the low frequencies sounded full, substantial, and clear. These are truly excellent speakers.

Next was Nils Lofgren’s “Nils Lofgren Band Live.” Of course, Hu Nai-Yuan played the test track, “Bass & Drum Intro.” The electric bass had strong energy, power, bounce, and liveliness. In this track, the R1TX demonstrated extremely high tolerance, maintaining clarity without getting rough around the edges. This is truly remarkable and shows that the two 10-inch woofers are very powerful and agile.

Then came “Larry Carlton Robben Ford Unplugged.” This CD highlights clean, dynamic, pure, and precise guitar playing. The R1TX presented a clean and transparent picture, without impurities, just pure guitar sound with fast string transient response. Next was Peter Paul Mary’s “In the Wind.” The positions of all three voices and guitars were very clear and stable, not blurry. Their vocal characteristics were also faithfully reproduced, with no noticeable coloration.

Stokowski’s “Rhapsodies” is an album every audiophile has. Of course, I listened to “The Moldau.” The R1TX displayed sweet, finely textured string sections, with inner voices appearing clearly. Beneath the massive orchestra, each section remained distinct. Clearly, the R1TX’s CST coaxial driver, two woofers, and hefty 150 kg cabinet all played their part. Next was Kyung Wha Chung playing Mendelssohn’s “Violin Concerto.”

The violin was sharp yet sweet, and the orchestra was also incisive yet not chaotic. The overall music had excellent transparency and extremely high resolution, and the woodwind harmonies were beautiful.

Again, it was Nils Lofgren, this time listening to “Keith Don’t Go” from the “Acoustic Live” album. I heard clean and dynamic steel-string guitar, with a softness that was not harsh on the ear, and an extremely wide soundstage. His vocal cord texture was very clear and prominent, but without causing any sense of pressure. The overall music sounded sweet and dynamic.

Next was the Filipino singer Vanessa Fernandez’s “Use Me.” I listened to the track “I Love You More Than You’ll Ever Know.” When Hu Nai-Yuan previously came to my place to listen to my system, he was so impressed by this song that he immediately bought the CD. As expected, the R1TX did not disappoint at all.

The sound was clear, had sufficient energy, the female singer’s voice was full and centered, the accompanying instruments were very dynamic, and best of all, the transient response was incredibly fast, making for a truly exhilarating listen.

Then came Etta Cameron and Nikolaj Hess With Friends’ “Etta.” This CD is a great recording, but the R1TX made it even better, bringing every subtle detail in the music to life in the air, and clearly presenting the texture of every instrument’s impact. Even better was the lead singer’s voice; the R1TX reproduced it in a truly captivating way. I believe it wasn’t the charm of coloration, but the charm of being incredibly realistic and neutral.

The last CD I chose was The All Star Percussion Ensemble’s “The All Star.” I listened to “Carmen Fantasy,” which is a percussion ensemble version. The R1TX presented a high degree of transparency, with various percussion instruments spread across a wide and deep soundstage. Even the quietest and most distant instruments had their initial attack texture clearly audible.

Furthermore, the overall sound was very clean, very sweet, and the transient response was incredibly fast, making it sound as if I wasn’t listening through a stereo system, but rather experiencing a live percussion performance. Such a stunning performance was truly amazing.

It is rare for me to hear such comprehensive sound performance during an “equipment review.” Most of the time, the performance is limited by the listening room conditions, which diminishes the true potential of the equipment. However, this review of the TAD R1TX at Tong Wei Audio in Taoyuan had almost no limitations, allowing me to hear the full potential of the R1TX.

The TAD R1TX’s sound is expansive and full-bodied, clean, clear, sweet, and distinct; it has ample power and fast response, capable of handling high power; the dynamic range between soft and loud is very wide, with soft passages revealing clarity and detail, and loud passages remaining stable, solid, and controlled. Such a top-tier performance undoubtedly still reigns supreme!

Specifications

* Type: Three-way, four-driver, bass reflex floorstanding speaker
* Introduced: 2019
* Drivers: 35mm Beryllium Tweeter / 160mm Beryllium Midrange CST Coaxial Driver × 1, 10-inch Tri-Laminate Composite Cone Woofer × 2
* Frequency Response: 21Hz – 100kHz
* Crossover Points: 250Hz, 2kHz
* Nominal Impedance: 4 ohms
* Sensitivity: 90dB (2.83V@1m)
* Weight: 150 kg
* Dimensions (WHD): 554 × 1293 × 698 mm

Highlights

* Features Beryllium tweeter and midrange drivers.
* Excellent performance from the CST coaxial driver.
* Teardrop-shaped cabinet, weighing 150 kg.
* Sound is expansive and full, with beautiful tone quality and exceptional detail.