Edifier Stax Spirit S5
|

Edifier Stax Spirit S5 Wireless Headphone Review


Is this Edifier? Or Stax? What exactly is Stax Spirit? The answer is simple: it’s Edifier, not Stax.

However, the inclusion of the Stax name in the model designation isn’t merely happenstance.

Edifier initially gained recognition for its computer speakers. Later, they recruited Phil Jones, a former designer for Acoustic Energy, which significantly advanced their speaker development capabilities, leading to the creation of their high-end brand, Airpulse.

Concurrently, they began releasing headphones, encompassing both in-ear and over-ear models.

In 2011, Edifier fully acquired Stax, the renowned Japanese electrostatic headphone manufacturer. Then, in 2016, they invested in Audeze, the American planar magnetic headphone brand. These strategic moves provided Edifier with significant technological breakthroughs in headphone design and manufacturing.

In 2022, they unveiled their first product combining the fruits of these two major investments: the Stax Spirit S3, a planar magnetic Bluetooth headphone. Its overall design referenced Audeze while refining the details. Coupled with the Edifier Connect App, it even offered EQ simulation of Stax headphones’ sound signature.

Following two years of further development, they’ve now launched a new planar magnetic Bluetooth headphone, the Stax Spirit S5, continuing to challenge the resolve of headphone enthusiasts.

Refined Aesthetics, Dapper Style

Compared to the Stax Spirit S3, I find the Stax Spirit S5’s appearance more appealing. The latter is noticeably more refined in every aspect than the former.

The Stax Spirit S3 featured a gold logo and carbon fiber weave texture on the earcups, giving it a lively and dynamic character. The Stax Spirit S5, however, opts for a more subdued dark grey logo background and switches the earcup exterior to a cowhide finish. The lines of the earcups themselves are also more rounded.

The overall style is more restrained yet feels more premium, sophisticated, and undeniably dapper. The subtle design changes on the Stax Spirit S5 indicate that Edifier is maturing as a brand.

The Edifier Stax Spirit S5 offers excellent wearing comfort. The clamping force from the headband is moderate, preventing it from feeling like it’s squeezing your head. The underside of the headband features a cushioning pad wrapped in soft, fine leather, contributing significantly to comfort both in terms of pressure relief and contact with the top of your head.

Genuine Leather Earcups Plus Cooling Pads

Edifier continues the practice from the Stax Spirit S3 by including two sets of earpads: one made from genuine lambskin and another covered in a cooling, breathable mesh fabric. Both types of pads offer a high-quality feel.

The genuine leather earcups emit a subtle leather aroma, and their warm tone and natural texture contribute to a sense of luxury. The cooling mesh fabric pads are indeed comfortable to wear, feeling more refreshing than the leather ones. A major drawback of over-ear headphones can be heat buildup, and these cooling earpads effectively address this issue for users.

Many headphones in this price range don’t even include genuine leather earcups, and it’s even rarer to find a manufacturer providing two different sets of pads for replacement, specifically considering wearing comfort and coolness. Edifier’s attention to detail here is commendable.

Foldable Design with Sturdy Joints

Structurally, Edifier has clearly invested significant effort in the Stax Spirit high-end series. To make these Bluetooth headphones portable, both the S3 and S5 models are designed to be foldable. Each headphone features two joints where the headband connects to the earcups. These joints need to rotate in different directions, and the headband also needs length adjustment.

These joints require both flexibility and stability to prevent noise during movement. The structural design quality of the Stax Spirit S5 is excellent, feeling robust and free from unwanted creaks.

Ultra-Low Distortion Planar Diaphragm with EqualMass Technology

The biggest difference between the Edifier Stax Spirit S5 and conventional headphones lies in its use of a planar magnetic driver instead of a dynamic driver. As a company originating from speaker manufacturing, Edifier possesses considerable expertise in drivers. Their speakers utilize not only dynamic drivers but also ribbon tweeters. However, planar magnetic drivers haven’t appeared in their speakers, yet they feature in their headphones first.

Following the Edifier Stax Spirit S3, the Stax Spirit S5 again employs a planar magnetic diaphragm. A planar diaphragm is significantly lighter than a dynamic cone and has a larger surface area, offering much faster transient response compared to traditional dynamic drivers, which is a significant advantage.

Metal traces, equivalent to a voice coil, are printed on the surface of the diaphragm to react to magnetic forces. Magnets located behind the diaphragm do not make direct contact with it but drive the diaphragm via magnetic force to produce sound. Edifier emphasizes their proprietary EqualMass technology for the magnetic traces, where multiple traces of equal width are distributed in parallel. This ensures both uniform weight distribution across the diaphragm and even distribution of driving force, resulting in lower distortion.

Dual Device Pairing and Ultra-Low 89ms Latency

In terms of Bluetooth specifications, the Stax Spirit S5 is equipped with the Qualcomm QCC5181 Bluetooth chip, featuring Bluetooth version 5.4. It supports Snapdragon Sound, aptX, aptX HD, aptX Adaptive, aptX Lossless, LHDC, LDAC, and other high-resolution audio decoding up to 24bit/96kHz.

Naturally, to benefit from codecs beyond AAC and SBC, you need devices that also support these encodings to achieve the best results. (If you’re an Apple user, these features won’t be utilized.) Additionally, it offers an 89ms low-latency mode. While this isn’t crucial for listening to music, for gaming and watching videos, seamless audio-visual synchronization provides a much better experience.

Bluetooth 5.4 also ensures stable transmission and allows simultaneous connection to two Bluetooth devices. This enables the Stax Spirit S5 to be paired with both a phone and a laptop, allowing for seamless switching between work, entertainment, and calls. If you frequently make phone calls or participate in online meetings, the Stax Spirit S5 utilizes Qualcomm aptX Voice wideband voice codec, providing 32kHz voice call quality within the Bluetooth range. It also features dual microphones that capture your voice while simultaneously picking up ambient noise, then use noise cancellation to accurately filter background sounds, ensuring clear call quality.

Exceptionally Long 80-Hour Battery Life

The Edifier Stax Spirit S5 incorporates a built-in 1,500mAh rechargeable battery, providing an impressive 80 hours of continuous playback on a full charge, virtually unparalleled in the market. Typical over-ear Bluetooth headphones offer around 20-30 hours of battery life; achieving 40 hours is usually a significant selling point. The Stax Spirit S5 boasting 80 hours is truly remarkable.

What happens if you forget to charge the headphones because the battery life is so good, and they run out of power? Edifier has included a 3.5mm analog headphone jack. If charging isn’t convenient, you can still listen to music using an analog headphone cable.

Edifier ConneX App for EQ Adjustment

The Edifier Stax Spirit S5 is compatible with the new Edifier App. Downloading Edifier ConneX on your phone allows you to configure various functions, including selecting EQ modes. The interface of the new Edifier ConneX differs from the previous Edifier Connect App; the Stax Spirit S5 is only compatible with the new Edifier ConneX.

Upon entering the App, the main page offers settings for “Earpad Setting,” “Sound Effects” (EQ), and “Game Mode.” If you switch to the “Ice-feel Earpads,” the manufacturer provides some EQ compensation tailored to the material characteristics of these pads. Game mode is essentially a toggle for enabling or disabling low latency. If you’re listening to music and don’t need low latency, you can turn this off for slightly better sound quality.

There are three preset EQ sound effects: “Classic,” “Dynamic,” and “Monitor.” The “Classic” mode is the factory default, emphasizing balanced frequencies across the board, appealing to most users. This mode is suitable for the widest range of music genres and was my preferred mode during the S5 trial. “Dynamic” mode slightly boosts the bass and treble, making the low end fuller and enhancing resolution. Some manufacturers call this tuning “V-shape” based on the EQ curve; it’s more pleasing for pop and rock music. The “Monitor” mode offers a relatively neutral sound, slightly reducing the bass quantity to highlight details in the mid-high frequencies. I also really liked this mode, especially when I was preparing new lecture pieces while wearing the Stax Spirit S5; the clean sound signature allowed me to clearly grasp the musical texture.

Finally, there is a customizable “Audiophile” mode, where users can adjust gain/cut for four frequency bands and tweak the Q value, allowing you to create your own personalized sound profile. This “Audiophile” mode can also save presets, which can be recalled anytime.

This brings me to a question. The first planar magnetic headphone from Edifier, the Stax Spirit S3, carried the Stax name but didn’t use an electrostatic driver, instead employing the planar magnetic technology from Audeze. However, the S3’s app included a “Stax” EQ preset, allowing users to experience a sound similar to Stax’s transparent signature. This option is notably absent in the EQ presets available for the Stax Spirit S5. Should the manufacturer consider adding a “Stax” EQ preset in the future?

Excellent Transparency and Resolution with Warm, Soft, and Enduring Sound Quality

Although the Edifier Stax Spirit S5 itself does not utilize Stax’s electrostatic technology and currently lacks a “Stax mode” EQ, its transparency and resolution are nonetheless impressive. Its tonal character leans slightly towards softness, so even with outstanding resolution, there isn’t excessive sibilance or sharpness that could cause listening discomfort.

Taking Diana Krall’s “The Girl in the Other Room” as an example, I really enjoyed how it rendered the guitar melody and arpeggios. While it’s not the natural sound of an acoustic guitar, amplified through pickups and an amp, it presents a different kind of sweet, rounded tone with a slight vibrato. As for Diana Krall’s vocals, the pronunciation is clear and stands out with a palpable presence. Vocal details are abundant and distinct, but the soft, warm sound quality of Edifier’s planar magnetic driver ensures that everything sounds non-aggressive, remaining comfortable and pleasant.

EQ Adjustment to Suit Individual Preferences

Similarly, listening to Jose James singing “Ain’t No Sunshine,” his warm, clean baritone voice comes through clearly on the Stax Spirit S5, with distinct vocal lines and details. The tone also gains a touch of warmth, possessing a unique sensual charm compared to male singers with rougher, raspier voices. The bass notes here are full-bodied, providing a good opportunity to test the EQ modes. Listening in “Classic” mode, this feels closest to how I usually hear this track through headphones or speakers.

Switching to “Monitor” mode, the slightly reduced bass makes the bass less prominent, bringing the vocals and the subsequent percussion into sharper focus. In “Dynamic” mode, the bass becomes full and robust, with ample power and a strong rhythmic drive, offering yet another flavor. If I were to choose, I’d favor the “Monitor” mode for this track; the bass notes sound tighter, making the overall rhythm feel quicker and more defined.

Handles Guitar and Vocals Exceptionally Well

Whenever I encounter electrostatic or planar magnetic headphones, I invariably find myself listening to more guitar music or pieces with guitar accompaniment (or perhaps it’s a conscious choice I’m unaware of?). The Edifier Stax Spirit S5 is excellent at reproducing vocals because it offers plenty of detail while retaining a warm, smooth texture. It also possesses a unique ability with guitar music.

Planar diaphragms are known for their lightweight nature and fast response speed, giving them an edge in delicacy and clarity compared to dynamic drivers. This characteristic makes them perfectly suited for reproducing guitar music.

Appears Closed, Yet Sounds Open

Listening to Antonio Forcione Quartet’s album “AFQ in Concert,” the S5’s portrayal of Antonio Forcione’s guitar playing is truly exhilarating. The crisp, clean guitar sounds come with beautiful decay. The accompanying cello produces a nasal, almost vocal-like resonance, singing gently. The bass and drums provide the rhythm while laying the foundation for the track’s dynamic energy.

Here, I must mention that Edifier has placed a metal-mesh-covered opening on the top of the Stax Spirit S5’s earcups. Perhaps due to this design, these headphones, while visually appearing closed-back, possess an “open-back” soul. The sound feels relaxed, without any sense of confinement, congestion, or being overly centralized. Furthermore, the spatial presentation is excellent; the sound sources always have room to breathe and are presented with layers and order.

Clearly Defined Soundstage Layers, Unique Percussion Character

Because the soundstage and spaciousness are good, coupled with delicate sound quality and excellent transparency, these benefits are also evident when listening to large-scale orchestral music. Taking Joe Hisaishi conducting the New Japan Philharmonic World Dream Orchestra (W.D.O.)’s compilation “W.D.O. Best” as an example, the stage presented by the Stax Spirit S5 clearly delineates the orchestra’s layers.

In the track “World Dream,” whether it’s the gentle theme melody led by the strings, the soaring and vibrant passages created by the addition of brass and woodwinds, the impact provided by the drums, or the sense of victorious hope brought by the bells, the characteristics I previously mentioned are all evident. The crispness and precision of the percussion, in particular, have a unique character with planar magnetic headphones that dynamic headphones lack. Whether in “World Dream,” “American in Paris,” or “Un homme et une femme,” you can feel that special quality of planar magnetic drivers reproducing percussion.

Not Just ‘Another Pair,’ but Truly Unique

After true wireless earbuds surged in popularity, it was thought that over-ear headphones might decline. However, they’ve seen a resurgence in the past two years; walking down the street or riding the subway, you frequently see people wearing over-ear Bluetooth headphones. After all, over-ear headphones lack the feeling of something inserted into the ear canal, and the sound is fuller and more spacious. Wearing them on your head can also be seen as a fashion statement. While they are larger and less convenient to carry and store than true wireless earbuds, they still possess irreplaceable advantages.

In this “revived” market for over-ear headphones, the Edifier Stax Spirit S5 is certainly not just “another pair” of headphones. It’s different from your other collections or your other targets. It has everything others have – App configuration, EQ adjustment, dual-device pairing, Hi-Res audio certification. But it also has things others may not – an ultra-long 80-hour battery life, replaceable cooling earcups, low-latency game mode, and genuine leather earcups and finishes.

Most importantly, it’s a rare planar magnetic headphone in its class. The Edifier Stax Spirit S5 is definitely not “another pair”; it is what it is – a truly unique existence.

Specifications

Edifier Stax Spirit S5
* Type: Planar Magnetic Bluetooth Over-Ear Headphones
* Bluetooth: 5.4
* Bluetooth Range: 10 meters
* Audio Codecs: aptX, aptX HD, aptX Adaptive, aptX Lossless, LHDC, LDAC, SBC, AAC
* SPL: 94+/-3dB (A)
* Frequency Response: 10Hz~40kHz
* Battery Life: Approx. 80 hours