Exogal Comet DAC image

Exogal Comet DAC Review


Not long ago, I spotted the brand Exogal on a new content assignment list at the editorial office.

Never having encountered this brand before, curiosity led me to do some research online, and I discovered that it’s quite remarkable.

My curiosity didn’t kill the cat, but it did give me the opportunity to savor this wonderful piece of equipment.

A Treasure That Seems to Come From Outside The Galaxy

Exogal was founded in 2014 by four veterans of the audio industry: current CEO Jeff Haagenstad, COO Jan Larsen, CTO Jim Kinne, and VP of Engineering Larry Jacoby. Previously, they all worked at Wadia, with Jim Kinne being the designer of the classic Wadia 27 decoding computer, 270 transport, and 790 Power DAC.

Just thinking about those top-tier digital sources, legendary in audio history, is enough to make any audiophile drool. The designers of these dream machines striking out on their own to create their own brand is certainly exciting. The brand name itself is intriguing. What kind of word is Exogal? But those foreigners love to put roots together to form new words, something we can’t really do in Chinese.

“Exo” is a prefix meaning “out of,” and “gal” is the first three letters of “Galaxy.” Put them together, and you get “out of the galaxy.” What does that mean? In plain language, these four founders are telling you, “You won’t find our products anywhere else on Earth!” Quite a boast, isn’t it? But if you’re the designer of the Wadia 27, Wadia 270, and Wadia 790, it doesn’t sound like empty bragging; it feels more like setting a new standard for oneself.

The Exogal Comet DAC features an external power supply. The version that the distributor sent includes a power supply, which is definitely a necessary upgrade.

Chassis Design That Considers Mechanical Strength and Material Properties

Compared to Wadia’s PowerDAC of yesteryear, the Exogal Comet DAC looks rather unassuming, a bit smaller than a ream of A4 paper, but its construction is excellent.

The chassis is milled from solid aluminum, with rounded corners, and the front and rear panels are slightly concave, while the left and right sides protrude slightly. This curved design provides mechanical strength to the chassis and suppresses resonance.

Exogal Comet DAC Review

The top cover is a black glass (or acrylic) panel with the Exogal logo, a simple drawing resembling a cosmic galaxy.

The front panel has a roughly 1-inch square LCD screen. The lettering on the screen is quite unique, somewhat like a laser label, which I’ve never seen before on audio equipment.

The bottom has a transparent acrylic base plate, using four stainless steel beads instead of typical cones or feet, reducing the contact points between the Comet DAC and the surface it sits on to a minimum.

I’ve also seen online that some Japanese manufacturers are modifying the Exogal Comet DAC, replacing the acrylic base with carbon fiber to enhance the rigidity of the unit itself, thereby improving the high frequencies and resolution.

Additionally, they are modifying the power supply, and these modifications are “said” to significantly improve the performance of the Comet DAC.

Whether the sound is truly improved, I haven’t heard it, so I can’t say for sure.

However, this also shows that the materials used in the equipment’s chassis can indeed affect the sound due to resonance.

Exogal has its design ideas, and Japanese businesses have their aesthetic preferences.

But this also demonstrates that the Exogal Comet DAC has the inherent quality that makes it worthwhile for the Japanese to modify it in pursuit of even higher performance.

In addition to the curved chassis for increased rigidity, the bottom uses an acrylic plate and stainless steel bead cones, utilizing different materials and minimal contact points to address vibration issues.

Not Just a DAC, But Also a Preamp and Headphone Amp

Exogal Comet DAC Review

Despite having experience designing classic machines, Exogal isn’t solely focused on pursuing audio performance excellence.

The Comet DAC supports up to PCM 32bit/384KHz and DSD128, not the industry’s top specifications, but certainly sufficient.

It has a total of four digital inputs: one AES/EBU, one optical, one BNC, and one USB type B.

Why BNC but no coaxial? Coaxial is more commonly used than BNC in audio equipment, but Exogal believes BNC has better specifications. The RCA connector on a coaxial cable may not always be 75 ohms, but BNC allows for the selection of 75-ohm connectors, so they chose BNC.

What if my turntable’s digital output uses RCA coaxial? Don’t worry, the factory includes a BNC-to-RCA adapter, so a turntable with coaxial output can still be used.

In addition to the four digital inputs, there’s also a set of RCA analog input jacks, allowing you to connect other source devices.

Why this design? Because Exogal believes that in an era where source outputs are sufficient, a preamp can actually be omitted.

Therefore, they designed a digital volume control for the Comet DAC, from 0 to 100, in 0.5 increments, totaling 200 steps.

Users only need to connect the Comet DAC to a power amp or active speakers, without an additional preamp.

This is their idea, and they’ve implemented this concept, even creating an Ion power amp to be sold with the Comet DAC as a combo called the Ion PowerDAC (the name sounds familiar, doesn’t it?). This simple yet consistently designed system perfectly embodies Exogal’s vision for the future of home audio.

The Exogal Comet DAC has two sets of analog outputs, balanced and unbalanced.

Digital inputs include USB type B, BNC, optical, and AES/EBU, each with one set, plus one set of RCA analog inputs.

Exogal Comet DAC Review

On the right, there are also two HDMI ports for connecting to Exogal’s own equipment.

Analog outputs include one set each of balanced and unbalanced outputs. In addition, there is a headphone output, a 6.3mm output jack located on the right side of the chassis.

The manufacturer states that this headphone output circuit is independent. The high-level output circuit uses the Texas Instruments TI PCM4104 DAC chip, while the headphone output circuit uses the TI PCM5122 DAC chip.

However, Exogal’s approach is also interesting: they don’t use the decoding portion of these chips, only their analog outputs. So how do they handle decoding? Exogal uses a custom 6-core DSP chip, implementing their own decoding concepts.

Seeing it this way, isn’t the Exogal Comet DAC quite something? Furthermore, they’ve designed an EXONET interface based on HDMI, which can be connected to other Exogal equipment.

Currently, they only have one power amp. If they release more equipment in the future, these can be used for future Exogal system expansion.

The remote control functions can be completely replaced by a mobile phone.

On the right are the BNC-to-RCA adapter and the Bluetooth antenna for remote control.

Mobile Phone as Remote Control

The Comet DAC comes with a remote control, but the manufacturer recommends using a mobile device as a remote control instead.

They launched the EXO Remote control app, where input and output switching, volume control, and power switch are all available.

These functions can of course be operated on the remote control, but after getting the Comet DAC, I didn’t even bother to unpack the remote control. I’m enjoying using it on my phone.

Exogal Comet DAC Review

The manufacturer provides apps for iOS and Android, suitable for both phones and tablets.

How does the phone communicate with the Comet DAC? Via Bluetooth.

Before use, be sure to install the included short antenna, so you can directly control the device via your phone without even pairing.

Will it consume power? The manufacturer uses Bluetooth 4.3, which is already low-energy Bluetooth. If you find your mobile device’s battery draining quickly, it’s mostly due to the app. The EXO Remote’s background features a rotating interwoven curve, like DNA, which is constantly rotating and changing colors, quite beautiful, but it will consume a bit more power.

If you only use it as a DAC, you hardly need to open the app after setting it up, unless you’re turning it on/off or switching input gears. So, the actual power consumption is actually okay.

The remote control app interface is very beautiful, with the light arc constantly rotating and changing colors.

Volume control is in 0.5 increments, and every time you turn it on, the volume will jump back to 65.

Insistence on Manufacturing in the USA

Another thing worth mentioning is that Exogal’s products are all manufactured in the USA.

Isn’t the cost of production in the United States very high? Yes, the cost of production in the United States is definitely higher than setting up factories in Asia or third-world countries, but Exogal believes it’s necessary to keep production in the United States for product quality.

Their solution to the cost problem is to try to find cooperative manufacturers within their home state of Minnesota, which can reduce some costs.

Exogal Comet DAC Review

If you are an audiophile who still has a origin obsession, rest assured that the Exogal Comet DAC, from design to materials to manufacturing, is all in the USA.

The top cover and bottom plate are made of acrylic material, combined with an aluminum alloy chassis, using both soft and hard materials to suppress vibration.

Natural and Smooth Sound

The audition process took place at my home, with two sets of amplifiers used: a NuPrime DAC-10H with an ST-10 power amp, and an Audiomat Adagio II vacuum tube integrated amplifier.

Among them, the DAC-10H is not only a preamp but also a reference DAC and headphone amp.

The transports included an Audio Aero Prima MK2 CD player (used as a transport) and an Auralic Aries Mini digital streaming transport. The former was used to play CDs, and the latter was used to play streaming files, including lossless music and MQA files from Tidal.

The speakers were PEL Quattro Plus with JMR Magic Stand speaker stands.

My first impression of the Exogal Comet DAC is that it’s quite natural and smooth, without a very strong or distinct audio personality, but playing music on it seems to make everything sound beautiful.

Furthermore, its extension at both ends is quite good. The upward extension gives harmonics ample opportunity to express themselves, and the downward extension isn’t forced, but smooth and natural. I can’t feel any particular frequency range being emphasized.

In the low frequencies, the quantity is appropriate, with both resolution and richness, allowing the music to have a solid foundation while maintaining transparency.

Moreover, it has sufficient detail information without giving people an overly analytical, grainy, or stimulating sensation. On the contrary, its sound has a smooth texture, a kind of “analog flavor,” and in this price range of DACs, the Exogal Comet is among the best.

The soundstage is open and deep, with clear layers and distinct outlines, providing a full sense of presence whether it’s large-scale orchestral music or small-scale chamber music.

Exogal Comet DAC Review

The Comet DAC’s top cover and external power supply both have the company’s identification logo.

Clear Details Without Being Stimulating

For example, listening to Yang Xuefei’s solo guitar album, the instrumentation here is extremely simple, just a classical guitar, but it doesn’t sound boring because of it.

The arrangements on this album are interesting and even popular. Not only are there standard guitar pieces, but also pop song arrangements. One moment it’s Albéniz, the next it’s Tárrega, then Paul McCartney, and later you’ll even hear John Williams’ Schindler’s List.

I heard very clear string plucking, and also enjoyed the rich resonance of the guitar’s soundbox.

For example, the first track is Albéniz’s famous Asturias, and the tremolo is clearly audible, which makes it particularly enjoyable.

Yang Xuefei plays with tenderness and elegance, without deliberately flaunting her technique, but the sound system can add some listening interest to it.

I listened to it first on the NuPrime pre and power amps, and then switched to the Audiomat Adagio II, which uses two KT88 tubes per channel in a push-pull configuration, but the manufacturer is so skilled that this push-pull machine has transparency and tonal purity that surpasses even single-ended machines.

I heard a more vivid performance on the Adagio II. I compared it with the DAC-10H, and the Comet’s slightly brighter tone, combined with a more focused sound, made the image more distinct.

Take the example of Bach arrangements co-performed by Yo-Yo Ma, Edgar Meyer, and Chris Thile.

This album is also interesting, with a cello, a double bass, and a mandolin.

Exogal Comet DAC Review

The instrumentation is different from the usual classical music trio instrumentation. Here, all three instruments have the opportunity to play the lead, and even the double bass doesn’t just play the role of basso continuo.

The Exogal Comet makes the timbre of the low-pitched string instruments warm and full, but still maintains a considerable delicate and smooth texture. The slightly raised reverb makes the low-pitched string instruments even more lustrous.

As for the mandolin, the plucked notes are clear and distinct. Because it lacks the soundbox resonance of a guitar, the timbre is thinner and flatter, short but clever. The Comet DAC can clearly present the essence of these instruments, allowing me to deeply appreciate the beauty of this music.

Lustrous Tones Make the Music More Gorgeous

Switching to a chamber orchestra, the instrumentation is larger, and the harmonies are richer. The Exogal Comet still presents the exquisite beauty of the music.

Listening to the Stuttgart Chamber Orchestra’s performance of Bach’s Goldberg Variations, this piece is famous, and there are as many arrangements as there are crossing the river.

This chamber orchestra version has a subtle and delicate timbre, shining with noble brilliance, which is exactly what the Exogal Comet excels at. It has the ability to reproduce the beauty hidden within the music.

I still paired it with the Adagio II, which excels in tonal expression, and the harmonies of each section of the string section are clear.

On the keyboard, the pianist only has two hands. In the orchestra, there can be five parts, and the music sounds more layered and more varied.

I like the luster of the strings on the Exogal Comet. It sounds as if it’s glistening with oil, but how can it be so natural? It doesn’t infect any color, and doesn’t leave a trace of greasiness.

Excellent Soundstage Reproduction, Laying Out Depth and Layers

Of course, playing truly large-scale music is also no problem. Listening to Copland’s “Fanfare for the Common Man,” the Exogal Comet makes the bass drum and timpani sound powerful and forceful, and the three-note ostinato has a full spirit.

Exogal Comet DAC Review

The brass instruments blow out the brilliance of metallic tones. I turned up the volume to fully enjoy this shock and the cry of the brass.

Listening to Michael Tilson Thomas conducting the San Francisco Symphony’s Mahler Symphony No. 5.

Do I need to mention the brilliant light of the brass again? When the instrumentation of the music is larger, I found that the Exogal Comet’s soundstage performance is really good. It’s an open and deep stage, with the percussion and brass in the back having a distance from the string section in the front, and these can all be expressed.

In comparison, the NuPrime DAC-10H’s soundstage is a little bigger, but the density of the instrument’s sound is worse. I should be more familiar with my own equipment, but at this moment I feel that the Exogal Comet’s stage reproduction is more reasonable and more appropriate.

Mahler’s symphonies are not to be played around with. I turned up the volume to see if the Exogal Comet would have rough edges or imbalances.

But as long as the volume is within the range that my living room can accommodate, the music goes very calmly, and even the sudden large dynamics don’t show any crampedness.

I think the Exogal Comet’s power supply that the distributor sent is really effective. If it were the standard version, with a normal AC-to-DC adapter, it would definitely be discounted.

This power supply gives Mahler’s music both structure and momentum.

Sounds Good as a Preamp Too

Because the Exogal Comet DAC has volume control, the manufacturer also suggests that users may want to connect it directly to a power amp, which can save the money for a preamp.

My own NuPrime DAC-10H is also such a device, used as a DAC and preamp (and also a headphone amp), but the DAC-10H’s volume control is a pure analog R2R volume control, while the Comet DAC’s volume control uses a digital control chip.

Will digital volume control sound good? All doubts can only be answered after trying it. Blind guessing and thinking are useless.

Exogal Comet DAC Review

I connected it to the NuPrime, comparing the two paths of going straight to the ST-10 power amp and going through the DAC-10H, that is, whether or not to go through a layer of preamp.

However, because the DAC-10H is not a true 10x gain preamp, I deliberately turned up the gain of the DAC-10H (it has four gain levels that can be adjusted).

After listening, I have to say that Exogal has done a very good job of making the Comet DAC function as a preamp.

It’s not that there’s no difference, but the difference is very small.

If only used as a DAC, the music sounds a little deeper, and “seems” to sound a little fuller, especially below the mid-low frequencies.

I added “seems” because after comparing back and forth, there “seems” to be a little bit of difference, but it’s really not obvious.

If you use it directly as a preamp, it’s actually fine. The manufacturer proposed this solution, and also launched a solution with a 100W Ion power amp. The two have the same chassis and look very simple and consistent when placed together.

If you also want to simplify the system, I have no opinion.

(I really have no opinion, because the effect is really good.)

Headphone Output Is Not Just for Show

It also comes with a headphone output jack, which should also be tried.

Exogal Comet DAC Review

I plugged in Sennheiser HD700 headphones, and I felt that the Exogal Comet DAC’s headphone output quality is not bad, although it’s not yet at the level of amazing (I recently auditioned the Chord Dave, which was truly unforgettable), as an accessory function, it can already be praised.

The sound is warm and the resolution is visible. Compared with the DAC-10H, the latter wins in terms of fuller sound quality, but the former has a charming smooth texture.

Listening to it, I felt that I had to change my mind. This headphone output is not an accessory; it can really be used to listen to headphones.

However, the HD700 is not a difficult headphone to drive. If you are a serious headphone audiophile, I’m afraid that adding a headphone amp will make you more satisfied.

On the right side, there is a 6.3mm headphone jack, which also drives headphones well.

Three Suggestions for the Manufacturer

In terms of usage, I have a few thoughts, which I will also list for your reference.

First of all, I very much appreciate Exogal’s remote control method through a mobile phone app. I have to say that using a mobile phone to replace the traditional remote control is a trend and the future.

Currently, Exogal only has this Comet DAC. If they launch a streaming player or a DAC with integrated streaming functions in the future, the app can also be revised, and the functions will be more powerful. The current operation and application are still too simple.

However, this app control also has inconveniences. As long as I switch the output (analog output or headphone output), the volume will jump back to 65.

And the volume control operation follows the interface of the traditional remote control, and the speed of number changing is a bit slow. It takes 12 seconds to press from volume 65 to 100. The app development team can improve on this, but this is just a software problem, which can be completed through updates.

Secondly, because it emphasizes that the Comet DAC can be used as a preamp or headphone amp, but there are no physical buttons or knobs, it is a bit inconvenient to use.

Exogal Comet DAC Review

It’s okay to use it as a preamp, because the sound system may be far away from the seat, so you would originally operate it with a remote control.

But when used as a headphone amp, it is a desktop listening experience, but you still have to find your phone and enter the app to control the volume, which is really not in line with the habits of desktop listening headphone users. If you could give two volume control switches hidden next to the headphone jack, you can still maintain the simplicity of the panel, but it would be more user-friendly.

Finally, that display is really confusing.

The screen of about one inch square is already small enough, and this special LCD color has a technological and modern feel, but it is not clear to see.

Of course, all the information on the screen is actually on the phone, but since there is a screen, it still has to play a role, right? The front panel display is very special. I have only seen this design on the Exogal Comet DAC.

You have to be at a certain angle to see it clearly, and it is also affected by too much light.

This is really an inspiration from outside the galaxy!

Comet One Fully Demonstrates Its Strength

Finally, I still want to say that, in terms of sound performance, the Exogal Comet DAC, although it cannot be said to be a galaxy-level DAC that is difficult to reach on Earth, once the price is taken into account, it is enough to occupy a place in the leading group of cost performance.

As Exogal’s first shot, the Comet DAC is flashy enough. It is a veritable “comet,” shining brightly through space, waving to the planets.

After listening to it, I am already imagining what their next product will be. Will it really take us outside the galaxy? Exogal Comet DAC’s external power supply.

Equipment Specifications

Here are the specifications of this device.

  • Type: Digital-to-Analog Converter
  • Digital Inputs: AES/EBU (XLR), SPDIF on 75Ohm (BNC), Toslink, USB-B
  • Supported Resolutions: 32bit/384KHz; DSD 128
  • Analog Inputs: RCA x1
  • Analog Outputs: XLR x1; RCA x1
  • Dimensions: 47.6 x 190 x 292 mm (HxWxD)
  • Weight: 4.2 kg