Lals Classical 8EX

File: Lals Classical 8EX Review


Lals Classical 8EX Horns

Lals Audio is a company dedicated to speaker design and manufacturing. To be more precise, Lals Audio is not just a speaker expert, but a horn speaker specialist. The Classical 8EX I auditioned at their Xizhi headquarters is their latest two-way horn speaker launched this year. Although priced under 60,000 NTD, it incorporates circular wooden horns, clearly aiming to introduce a broader audience to the captivating world of horn speakers.

The Founder’s Technical Roots

I have a long-standing acquaintance with Mr. Huang, the driving force behind Lals Audio. Our paths first crossed nearly two decades ago when he served as the factory manager at JK Audio. I recall personally visiting the JK Audio factory in Xizhi to collect my PM 10 horn speakers, and it was Mr. Huang himself who kindly assisted me in loading them into my vehicle.

At that time, Mr. Huang had not yet embarked on his entrepreneurial journey. As factory manager at JK Audio, he oversaw speaker production management and contributed to design and development. Subsequently, he ventured out to establish Lals Audio, naturally concentrating on the realm of horn speakers, an area he was intimately familiar with.

Indeed, horn technology represents a truly classic speaker design. Imagine cinemas a century ago attempting to operate without horn speakers – silent films might have been the only option! The emergence of highly efficient horn speakers propelled the advent of sound-equipped movie theaters, blending audio and visuals seamlessly. Even today, horn speakers stand as an enduring and timeless design in the history of audio.

However, this might raise a question for many readers: if horn speakers are such a timeless classic, why are they less prevalent today compared to traditional dome dynamic driver designs?

Horns: A Premium Build

The answer is straightforward: the manufacturing cost of horn assemblies significantly surpasses that of conventional dynamic drivers. This higher cost naturally translates to a higher price point, making it challenging for horn speakers to compete directly with traditional dynamic driver speakers in terms of affordability. Consequently, horn speakers we encounter in the market, from brands like JBL, Avantgarde, Accapella, and others, typically command a premium price.

However, Lals Audio, by managing both design and production internally, maintains tight control over costs from the ground up. Furthermore, Mr. Huang’s unwavering commitment to promoting horn speakers allows them to consistently offer remarkably competitive pricing.

Consider the Classical 8EX under review: it pairs an 8-inch woofer with a genuine 44mm titanium diaphragm compression driver for the high frequencies, yet boasts a suggested retail price of only 68,000 NTD (approximately $2250 USD). Comparable offerings from imported brands often carry a considerably higher price tag. For the same 68,000 NTD investment in a two-way speaker, competitors might offer a traditional dynamic tweeter coupled with a mid-bass driver. In contrast, the Classical 8EX delivers a compression driver paired with an 8-inch mid-bass unit. The cost disparity is substantial. Even disregarding the 8-inch mid-bass, the tweeter section of the Classical 8EX alone represents a cost several times greater than that of typical designs. A conventional dome tweeter is essentially a single component, perhaps with a simple shallow horn-shaped metal ring for mounting. But the Classical 8EX tweeter is a “bona fide” compression driver.

The Real Compression Driver

What makes it “bona fide”? It’s the complete assembly: diaphragm, compression driver, throat, and wooden circular horn—each element is essential. The Classical 8EX tweeter employs a 44mm titanium diaphragm. Compare this to a standard 1-inch dome tweeter, which measures only 25.4mm in diameter. Lals Audio’s 44mm diaphragm boasts nearly double the surface area. A larger tweeter diaphragm contributes to superior low-frequency extension, enabling a lower crossover point and smoother integration between the tweeter and mid-bass driver.

This large diaphragm works in concert with a compression driver. As the diaphragm vibrates, high frequencies are channeled through the compression driver’s narrow gap. This constricted passage accelerates the airflow of sound waves, intensifying energy and boosting efficiency. The high frequencies exiting the compression driver then traverse the throat and finally disperse through the wooden horn.

While the operating principle may seem straightforward, each stage involves intricate engineering. The material of the compression driver, the precision of the gap opening, and the throat’s length, diameter, and flare all influence frequency response. Similarly, the horn’s shape, curvature, opening, length, and material – every minute detail impacts sound quality and timbre. Achieving a harmonious and refined sound hinges entirely on the designer’s expertise.

Wider Baffle for Enhanced Bass

Turning our attention back to the Classical 8EX, it represents Lals Audio’s most compact horn speaker utilizing a compression driver. Its predecessor was the Classical 8M. Comparing the two, specifications are nearly identical – compression driver and mid-bass unit are practically the same. However, the earlier Classical 8M featured a narrow baffle design, while the Classical 8EX returns to a classic wide baffle configuration. I initially assumed this was to increase cabinet volume, but Mr. Huang clarified that internal volumes are almost the same, as the Classical 8EX cabinet is shallower. The primary motivation for the wider baffle is enhanced soundstage performance.

In fact, Lals Audio’s higher-tier horn speakers predominantly feature wide baffle designs. Mr. Huang explained that this design approaches an infinite baffle, which strengthens bass frequencies. The effect is akin to “enlarging the drumhead,” naturally amplifying bass presence. However, narrow baffle designs are generally favored for home aesthetics, so the Classical 8M design leaned towards domestic appeal. Subsequently, prioritizing sonic performance, the Classical 8EX reverted to a wide baffle, optimizing bass reproduction.

Complementing the Classical 8EX’s custom circular wooden horn is an 8-inch woofer with a carbon fiber diaphragm. Mr. Huang emphasized their use of genuine carbon fiber diaphragms, distinguishing them from some manufacturers who employ dyed black fiberglass, a significantly different grade of material. Furthermore, while classic Lals Audio horn speakers typically feature folded cloth surrounds, the Classical 8EX’s 8-inch carbon fiber mid-bass unit utilizes a rubber surround. Mr. Huang acknowledged this as a cost-conscious decision. Implementing the same premium materials found in higher-end Lals Audio models would undermine the market positioning of their flagship offerings.

Finally, let’s consider the Classical 8EX speaker cabinet. All Lals Audio speakers are constructed from high-quality Russian birch plywood. This specialized plywood, produced under high pressure, boasts a density far exceeding standard MDF boards and comes at a higher cost. Examining the Classical 8EX closely reveals the distinct layers of Russian birch plywood. The circular horn itself is also crafted from Russian birch plywood, meticulously hand-cut with a knife wheel. Mr. Huang emphasized that to guarantee quality, Lals Audio’s Russian birch wood is specifically imported under his direct supervision. Speaker cabinets are entirely handcrafted in their own factory, without outsourcing, ensuring complete quality control.

With the design highlights of the Classical 8EX covered, it was time for a listening session.

Lals Audio paired the speakers with a Crown Amcron PSL-2 preamp and a Techron 5530 power amp. These are vintage studio-grade amplifiers, quite uncommon in typical hi-fi setups. The source was equally straightforward: a Macbook Pro with optical output, feeding an older Denon CD player, utilizing its internal DAC for digital-to-analog conversion. Sensing my raised eyebrow, Mr. Huang clarified, “Don’t perceive Lals Audio as a conventional retailer. We are the speaker manufacturer. The supporting equipment is purely for demonstration. We don’t obsess over high-end system synergy.” He further noted that these seasoned studio components are highly respected; brands like Westlake often favor Crown, prized for its excellent sound and near-indestructible reliability.

Unassuming System Setup

Don’t mistake Mr. Huang’s casual approach as indicative of underperformance. The ability to drive the speakers effectively without meticulously curated components suggests inherent speaker efficiency and ease of integration with diverse front-end equipment. Moreover, it reflects a deep confidence in their own speaker designs. Mr. Huang asserted that the speakers themselves exhibit low distortion and sound excellent regardless of associated equipment. Having personally overseen Lals Audio speaker development from initial concept to final production, he possesses intimate knowledge of their capabilities. Thus, when showcasing their sonic attributes, he refrains from emphasizing elaborate high-end system matching.

Given the host’s confidence, I began “making requests”! Since playback relied on Mr. Huang’s Macbook Pro, my CDs remained unused. I proceeded to “request” specific tracks for Mr. Huang to access from his iTunes library. I started with “Cotton Field” from “Belafonte Sings the Blues.” The bluesy double bass pizzicato on the Classical 8EX presented a texture that transcended mere physicality, with full, prominent note articulation. Belafonte’s vocals anchored centrally within the soundstage, the speakers seemingly dissolving into the space. The circular horn’s sound dispersion proved impressive, and the Classical 8EX exhibited minimal coloration in the midrange and treble, rendering vocals with a beautiful sense of openness.

Passing the Vocal Test

Why initiate the test with vocals? Because horn speakers are most vulnerable to coloration in the midrange and treble frequencies. Consider a simple analogy: to project your voice over a distance, cupping your hands around your mouth in a horn shape effectively amplifies your voice. However, you’ll immediately notice a thickening of the vocal timbre – that’s the coloration introduced by your hands acting as a horn. Detractors of horn speaker designs often cite this relatable example, arguing that horns inherently introduce coloration that is difficult to eliminate. While this is a recognized challenge in horn design, it’s not insurmountable. Through judicious material selection, horn geometry, damping techniques, and other design parameters, horn distortion can be significantly minimized. Hence, my initial focus on vocals was to assess any potential issues with excessive coloration.

The Belafonte track passed with flying colors. Next, I selected Rebecca Pidgeon’s “Spanish Harlem.” Again, double bass pizzicato took center stage, accompanied by pristine piano chords. Rebecca Pidgeon’s voice soared effortlessly, exhibiting beautiful extension in the midrange and treble, complemented by a solid and grounded low-frequency foundation. The Classical 8EX, despite its modest size, was positioned in Lals Audio’s relatively expansive listening space (approximately 530 sq ft). While the speakers appeared somewhat small in the room, the low-frequency solidity was remarkably impressive.

Continuing with vocals and rock, I listened to Dire Straits’ “Walk of Life.” Electronic synthesizer chords, crisp guitar strums, and a light-hearted rock rhythm from the drum kit filled the space. Despite the sizeable listening area, the Classical 8EX handled the track with aplomb, creating a joyful and bright rock ambiance. Moving on to the Eagles’ classic “Hell Freezes Over,” specifically the acoustic guitar version of “Hotel California,” the familiar melody resonated beautifully through the Classical 8EX. The nylon-string guitar solo, contrasting with steel-string guitar chords, the varied rhythms of jazz drums and hand drums, and the intermittent cheers from the live audience – the Classical 8EX, though a bookshelf speaker, projected musical energy within the 530 sq ft space comparable to floor-standing speakers.

The Classical 8EX’s ability to generate unexpectedly potent musical energy stems from two factors: its inherent robustness and the substantial 180-watt output of the Crown amplifier. This synergy allowed the Classical 8EX to deliver an impressive sense of musical power. Furthermore, I noted the minimal acoustic treatment in Lals Audio’s listening space. Mr. Huang confirmed that the store lacked dedicated acoustic enhancements, aside from heavy curtains to mitigate reflections from the large street-facing glass windows. Consequently, the room reverberation characteristics during the audition closely resembled a typical domestic environment.

Classical Music Prowess

Time to transition to classical music. I began with Yo-Yo Ma’s “Bach Cello Suites” as a preliminary test. The prelude’s melody unfolded gracefully. The Classical 8EX rendered the cello with a balanced density, focused imaging, and a touch of spaciousness. Importantly, I could engage in conversation with Mr. Huang while enjoying the music without any sense of distraction. This “Six Evolutions” recording represents Yo-Yo Ma’s third interpretation of the Bach Cello Suites. The recording is recent, capturing rich digital detail. The Classical 8EX not only conveyed the cello’s resonance with appropriate fullness but also resolved subtle nuances like finger movements and taps on the cello neck, harmonizing with the musical phrasing to enhance the performance’s realism.

Switching to “Piazzolla: Histoire Du Tango,” I selected “Bordel 1900.” This passionate tango piece features a spirited interplay between flute and flamenco guitar. The Classical 8EX showcased the hallmark traits of horn speakers: clean, rapid transients and a vivid musical presentation. The flute emerged from the depths of the soundstage, while the percussive sounds of guitar body taps seemed closer. The two instruments were clearly positioned – flute on the left, guitar on the right. The nylon-string guitar notes were sharply defined, contrasting with the flute’s rich texture, weaving a vibrant tapestry of tango music.

Small ensembles posed no challenge for the Classical 8EX. For a more demanding test, I chose Stravinsky’s “The Firebird,” conducted by Pletnev with the Russian National Orchestra. I requested Mr. Huang to slightly increase the volume to assess the Classical 8EX’s low-end composure. Driven by the high-power amplifier, the “Infernal Dance” section of “The Firebird” exhibited adequate weight. Pletnev’s conducting was assured, with satisfying bass depth. The brass section seemed slightly recessed. It had been some time since I last heard Pletnev’s rendition, but at this point, Mr. Huang remarked, “This version sounds a bit dark, doesn’t it?” I concurred, suggesting that a comparison with the more familiar Reference Recordings version would immediately highlight the difference in recording quality.

Mr. Huang, ever proactive, promptly located the Reference Recordings version in iTunes and replayed it through the Classical 8EX. The initial explosive orchestral outburst instantly unleashed the Classical 8EX’s energy. The brass section gained brilliance and clarity, and the bass exhibited enhanced layering and dynamic impact. The triangle’s sound became even crisper. Mr. Huang emphasized that the Classical 8EX utilizes a genuine compression driver. Consequently, the triangle not only possessed a bright timbre but also conveyed its sonic weight, not just a fleeting “ting-ting-ding.” Even amidst the orchestra’s powerful sonic waves, the triangle’s clear sound retained a tangible presence – the unique high-frequency allure of horns.

Your Horn Speaker Gateway

Indeed, this very characteristic led me to acquire PM-10 horn speakers years ago, which remain in active use in the HiFiReport editorial office. The Classical 8EX, with its more compact form factor and approachable price, offers genuine two-way horn performance. If you’re seeking an accessible entry point into the world of horn speakers, a visit to Lals Audio to audition the Classical 8EX is highly recommended. It’s unlikely to disappoint.

Specifications

* Type: 2-way, 2-driver horn speaker
* Drivers: 44mm titanium diaphragm compression tweeter x 1, 8-inch carbon fiber diaphragm woofer x 1
* Frequency Response: 50 Hz – 20 kHz
* Crossover Frequency: 1200Hz
* Impedance: 8 ohms
* Sensitivity: 92dB / W(1m)
* Dimensions: 350 (W) x 520 (H) x 250 (D) mm
* Weight: 17 kg per speaker