MSB Reference Transport/DAC Review
Even for someone working in audio media, the opportunity to audition MSB Reference level components, let alone the even higher-end Select series, is exceptionally rare. Like most audiophiles, my previous encounters were limited to audio shows. This time, thanks to Soundray, I had the privilege of borrowing the Reference Transport and DAC, complete with the dedicated Powerbase. This full suite of MSB’s top-tier digital source components recreated music with astonishing realism, the kind that lingers in your dreams.
American Craftsmanship
MSB was founded in 1986 by Mark Brasfield, initially focusing on modifications and upgrades for Philips CD players. Larry Gullman joined as a partner in 1989, continuing the pursuit of excellence in digital audio sources. By 1994, Larry Gullman had acquired full ownership, leading the company until 2016 when he passed the baton to his two sons, Jonathan and Daniel Gullman. I have had the pleasure of interviewing all three key figures in MSB’s history—father and sons—and their passion and dedication to research, design, and precision manufacturing are truly impressive. To this day, they proudly uphold the banner of “Made in the USA.”
My first encounter with MSB equipment was in the 1990s with the Millennium 2.4.6, an external processor for DTS signals in two-channel systems. It was a novel experience at the time, adding a 3D spatial dimension to stereo sound, almost creating a surround sound effect from two channels. However, as multi-channel surround systems became mainstream, the Millennium faded into obsolescence. Subsequently, MSB launched the 24/96 Link DAC, one of the few DACs at the time capable of upsampling 16-bit audio to 24-bit, achieving remarkable sales success and laying a solid foundation for MSB’s long-term development. This history underscores MSB’s origins in digital-to-analog conversion and their continued dedication to this field.
From Affordable to High-End
In its early days, MSB adopted a more accessible approach, utilizing commercially available chips in their products. However, this changed around the year 2000 with the introduction of the Platinum DAC. This marked the first time MSB employed their own in-house designed and manufactured Ladder DAC, moving away from off-the-shelf DAC chips. For over a decade, they relentlessly refined and perfected their Ladder DAC technology.
The phrase “perfected” is not my own assessment, but the words of founder Larry Gullman himself. In 2015, when MSB unveiled the Select DAC, priced at a staggering $90,000 USD, he genuinely believed MSB had reached the state-of-the-art. To demonstrate this conviction, he personally carried the Select DAC prototype across thirteen countries spanning Asia, Europe, and America, hosting product launch events. At these events, Larry Gullman earnestly declared, “The Select DAC is, to date, the best DAC we are capable of making!”
Reference DAC: A More Accessible Flagship
The Select DAC, launched in 2015, represented the culmination of MSB’s fifteen-year-plus investment in their in-house designed Ladder DAC, achieving state-of-the-art performance. However, with a price tag of $90,000 USD, it occupied the pinnacle of MSB’s pricing, making it accessible to a relatively limited customer base. Consequently, MSB took the Select DAC as a blueprint and developed a comparatively simplified version – the Reference DAC, which is the subject of this review.
The price? Still not inexpensive, but significantly less than half the cost of the Select DAC.
As for the companion Reference Transport, it was not launched simultaneously with the DAC, arriving later. However, these two components together form a complete digital music source solution. With these two units, whether you’re using physical CD/SACDs or connecting to computer and network digital streams, everything is covered. They also include preamp volume control functionality. Simply pair the Reference Transport/DAC with a power amplifier and speakers, and your audio system is complete.
Proprietary Ladder DAC Technology
Moving from commercially available DAC chips to in-house designed and manufactured DACs signifies MSB’s unique stance and expertise in digital-to-analog conversion technology. It’s a path less traveled, and certainly not an easy one.
Ladder DACs are now a buzzword in high-end DACs. Spotting one immediately signals premium status. For example, dCS’s Ring DAC also employs Ladder DAC technology at its core. The fundamental principle of a Ladder DAC involves a “ladder” formed by cascading precision resistors, which modulates to create an analog signal. However, achieving precision in this process varies greatly among manufacturers.
MSB’s Ladder DAC is termed a Sign Magnitude Ladder DAC. The Reference DAC is equipped with the latest generation Hybrid DAC, identical to that in the Select DAC. The only difference lies in the number of Hybrid DAC modules. The top-tier Select DAC utilizes eight modules, while the Reference DAC uses half that number, featuring four Hybrid DAC modules.
The Cost Factor of Ladder DAC
To assume that designing and manufacturing one’s own DAC is a guaranteed path to audio supremacy would be to underestimate MSB’s expertise in the digital-to-analog domain.
Ladder DAC technology is not new; in fact, it’s one of the earliest forms of digital-to-analog conversion. The classic Philips TDA 1541 DAC of yesteryear was based on a Ladder DAC architecture, and its current soaring prices in the second-hand market attest to its exceptional sonic qualities. However, if Ladder DACs are so superior, why did Delta-Sigma DAC chips become the mainstream? The answer is simple: cost. Delta-Sigma DACs utilize digital computation. Increasing the sampling rate from 16-bit to 20-bit or 24-bit in a Delta-Sigma DAC doesn’t significantly increase chip size; it primarily involves algorithm changes. In contrast, Ladder DACs employ discrete precision resistor networks. Each bit of added precision doubles the number of components, proportionally increasing circuit size and complexity. Creating a 24-bit discrete resistor network is significantly more challenging and costly. In the late 1980s, as CD rapidly gained popularity, the imperative to drive down CD player prices favored the mass-producible and cost-effective Delta-Sigma DAC, supplanting the more expensive Ladder DAC. Ladder DAC technology became the domain of a select few brands committed to uncompromising sound quality, continuing to invest in its research and refinement, with MSB being a prominent example.
Exceptional Low-Level Signal Recovery
It is crucial to understand that Ladder DAC is merely a digital-to-analog conversion architecture. The specific implementation details vary significantly among manufacturers. MSB employs its proprietary Sign Magnitude Ladder DAC, distinguished by its exceptional ability to handle low-level signals. In contrast, Delta-Sigma DACs rely on digital computation for decoding. Post-decoding digital noise necessitates digital filtering, which can inadvertently filter out subtle, low-level signals embedded within the recording.
MSB’s Sign Magnitude Ladder DAC, however, passively outputs analog signals solely through resistor networks. The output signal is voltage directly, eliminating the need for I/V conversion and, consequently, the need for additional op-amp amplification stages.
In essence, the Sign Magnitude Ladder DAC, with its simplified architecture, is designed to reproduce every detail within a digital recording, ensuring even the faintest signals, buried deep in the mix, are not lost due to digital filtering.
Modular Design for Future-Proofing
Another distinctive feature of MSB is their adoption of a fully modular design. Given the rapid pace of digital technology evolution, new applications emerge every few years. For instance, the once-ubiquitous S/PDIF digital interface is now primarily relegated to traditional CD transports. Connecting to computers or networks requires USB or RJ45 interfaces. Without modular design, changes in digital interface standards could render older equipment obsolete. MSB’s modular approach provides future upgradeability, mitigating obsolescence. For example, to accommodate current trends like Roon and MQA, MSB offers network interface modules, keeping their products current.
While MSB is not alone in employing modular design to future-proof digital equipment, their commitment to consistently delivering on this promise, by continually releasing new application modules, earns consumer trust. Some brands have touted modular upgrades, but failed to deliver a diverse range of options. MSB is not such a manufacturer of empty promises. Their array of expansion modules is extensive, encompassing digital interfaces, analog outputs, the exclusive Pro ISL digital interface, and even modular clock upgrades. If you’re inclined to explore upgrades, MSB offers ample opportunities.
Galaxy Femto 33 Clock for Supreme Accuracy
The Reference DAC under review, paired with the Reference Transport, is equipped with the Pro ISL fiber optic digital module in addition to the standard S/PDIF input. Analog output modules include both balanced and unbalanced options. The unit also has two available module slots, allowing for the addition of a Network Renderer V2 module for network streaming with Roon Ready and MQA decoding, supporting up to 32bit/768kHz and 4xDSD.
Furthermore, while the standard clock is the Galaxy Femto 77, the reviewed Reference DAC has been upgraded to the even more precise Galaxy Femto 33 module.
Jitter, or timing errors, has long been recognized as a critical issue in digital audio. The solution lies in using high-precision clocks. MSB’s clocks are named Galaxy Femto, signifying “cosmic femtosecond.” Starting with the Galaxy Femto 140, they progressed to the Galaxy Femto 77 and then the Galaxy Femto 33. The numerical designation represents the clock’s timing error in femtoseconds. 140 denotes 140 femtoseconds, 77 signifies 77 femtoseconds, and 33 indicates 33 femtoseconds.
What exactly is a femtosecond? We can perceive a second on a wristwatch. A millisecond is one-thousandth of a second (0.001 seconds). The digits on a digital stopwatch change so rapidly, they may blur to the human eye. A femtosecond, however, is a quadrillionth of a second (10^-15 seconds), or a decimal point followed by 14 zeros and then a 1. This illustrates the extraordinary precision of the Galaxy Femto 33 clock.
Universal Format Playback with Reference Transport
The Reference DAC can be considered a simplified version of the Select DAC. However, when MSB initially launched these DACs, a matching transport was not available. The Universal Transport at the time retained an older design aesthetic, not quite matching the new DACs visually. It was not until the Reference Transport that the styling aligned with the new generation.
What sets the Reference Transport apart from typical CD/SACD transports is its software compatibility. It is remarkably versatile, supporting not only DSD and PCM, but also Dolby TrueHD, DTS-HD, Dolby Atmos, and DST:X. This broad compatibility stems from its foundation as a modified Oppo UDP-203 player, renowned for its exceptional disc reading capabilities.
The Reference Transport, despite its premium price, is based on a relatively affordable Oppo player. This fact may provoke criticism, with some decrying it as a ripoff. However, the Reference Transport retains only the optical disc drive mechanism, control circuitry, and video pathways from the Oppo. Virtually everything else is redesigned and rebuilt. Even the disc tray is meticulously machined from aluminum alloy. These handcrafted components, coupled with the heavy-duty chassis and custom-designed power supply, produced in limited quantities, inevitably lead to high manufacturing costs. Moreover, when paired with MSB’s own DACs, the Reference Transport gains a unique advantage: the exclusive Pro ISL (Pro Isolated Synchronous Link) fiber optic transmission.
Exclusive Pro ISL Digital Interface
Previously, MSB’s top digital interface was Pro I2S. However, the Pro ISL fiber optic interface offers superior noise isolation, boasting a bandwidth of 3 MHz and incorporating bi-directional communication and real-time error detection technologies. This is a proprietary MSB technology, exclusively compatible with MSB DACs.
One might question if fiber optic transmission is prone to high jitter. This concern is valid for standard Toslink connections where the connectors themselves can introduce jitter. MSB, however, utilizes proprietary connectors, eliminating this issue.
MSB’s technological prowess is undeniable. I’ve attempted to simplify the explanation, as ultimately, all audio technology innovations and advancements serve one purpose: music reproduction. The most crucial evaluation is always through listening.
The complete Reference Transport/DAC system, along with the dedicated Powerbase, arrived in three custom-made crates—an imposing sight. However, the Powerbase is designed to power only one component, so I connected it to the Reference DAC, leaving the Reference Transport to be powered through a power strip.
Direct Drive to Power Amp for Enhanced Transparency
The listening sessions took place in the HiFiReport editorial office, using Wilson Audio Alexia 2 speakers and EAR 868 PL preamplifier and 509 II power amplifier. The Reference DAC, equipped with volume control, can be connected directly to a power amplifier. I compared both configurations—with and without the preamplifier. Adding the 868 PL preamplifier imparted a slightly richer sonic texture and enhanced warmth. Connecting directly to the 509 II power amplifier resulted in a more articulate and faster sound.
Both configurations were excellent and offered distinct sonic flavors. However, bypassing the 868 PL preamplifier seemed to better highlight the intrinsic sonic characteristics of the Reference Transport/DAC. Therefore, subsequent listening was conducted with the DAC directly driving the 509 II power amplifier.
Unparalleled Realism and Directness
If I were to pinpoint the most prominent sonic attribute of the Reference Transport/DAC, it would be the sheer directness and realism of its music reproduction. It is truly exceptional. Having auditioned numerous CD/SACD players and DACs over the years, few can rival the MSB in terms of sonic realism. Compared to the Merging NADAC currently used in our editorial office, the NADAC possesses a warmer tonal character, but in terms of detail retrieval and breathtaking realism, it falls slightly short. The MSB system projects an intense sense of musical realism, making instruments seem to float in the air, almost tangible.
Take, for instance, the “Jazz at the Pawnshop” 30th Anniversary SACD. “Limehouse Blues” is a timeless classic that I’ve listened to countless times. In this intimate club recording, the subtle details of the venue—the murmurs of the audience during the band’s soundcheck before the music begins, the sound engineer switching equipment, the clinking of glasses from the bar, distant conversations—all these ambient details are rendered with astonishing realism by the Reference Transport/DAC. Closing my eyes, I could vividly picture the Pawnshop recording venue.
The crisp snap of the snare drum initiates the rhythm, setting the tempo, followed by the other musicians joining in. Beneath the lead melody of the woodwinds, the piano and double bass provide lively accompaniment, punctuated by the delicate shimmer of the vibraphone. The notes feel intimately close, yet the soundstage is expansive, as if seated in the best spot in the club for a live performance. The sense of proximity creates a feeling of intimacy, while the spacious soundstage allows for relaxed and effortless listening. Despite countless listens, “Limehouse Blues” through the Reference Transport/DAC sounds remarkably fresh, revealing even more recording nuances and a more authentic sense of the recording venue.
Exquisite Guitar Detail Retrieval
This realism becomes even more pronounced with recordings of natural instruments. Listening to Opus 3’s “Showcase: Acoustic Music in Authentic Environment,” specifically Eric Bibb’s “I Want Jesus To Walk With Me,” a male vocal and guitar performance, the Reference Transport/DAC captures Eric Bibb’s solitary performance with both fidelity and emotional truth. The sonic truth lies in the authentic reproduction of the guitar and Eric Bibb’s voice. The acoustic guitar’s tone is warm, with pentatonic scales interwoven with arpeggiated chords. The guitar’s resonance is substantial, and the steel strings’ high frequencies are not overly bright but imbued with warmth, perfectly complementing Eric Bibb’s sincere and warm vocals, creating a rich bluesy atmosphere.
While this sparsely arranged recording isn’t particularly demanding for high-end equipment, and the bluesy mood is enjoyable even on more modest systems, the Reference Transport/DAC elevates the experience by portraying the guitar and vocals with such detail and realism, presenting a vivid musical image. The repetitive blues progression deepens in emotion with each repetition. In the final repetition, the acoustic guitar is not only plucked but also percussively tapped on the body. Eric Bibb’s vocal dynamics become more dramatic. The guitar is clearly finger-picked, evident from the absence of pick noise and the rounded, full-bodied note articulation. The guitarist likely intentionally uses the fleshy part of his fingers rather than fingernails, further enriching the guitar’s warmth and fullness. These recording details are rendered with exceptional realism by the Reference Transport/DAC. Not only is Eric Bibb’s voice captivating and expressive, but even the nuances of his guitar playing are captured with remarkable fidelity.
Unveiling Violin Nuances with Clarity
The Reference Transport/DAC’s ability to capture realistic detail is even more evident with violin recordings. Listening to Anne-Sophie Mutter’s “Across the Stars,” specifically “Rey’s Theme” from “Star Wars: The Force Awakens,” Mutter’s solo violin theme, played in the high register, reveals brilliant notes and delicate bow strokes. Through the Reference Transport/DAC, these notes become even more vivid. As the full orchestra enters, the violin continues the theme, while the double basses provide a rhythmic pizzicato accompaniment. The brass section emerges powerfully from the rear of the soundstage, expanding the orchestral scale. The orchestra swells like a tidal wave, against which the solo violin navigates. This musical dynamic—a single instrument contending with a full orchestra—mirrors the theme of Rey, the protagonist of the film. The violin embodies Rey, and the orchestra represents the forces of destiny she must confront alone.
Mutter’s recording of film themes, while not strictly classical, leans towards a pop-crossover style. The recording itself reflects this approach. Through the Reference Transport/DAC, the enhanced low frequencies become apparent. The multi-track recording technique also contributes to a heightened sense of soundstage vibrancy. While I was previously aware of the post-production direction of this recording, the Reference Transport/DAC makes these studio-crafted sonic effects even more pronounced.
Vivid Musical Imagery and Soundstage
Switching to a more traditional classical recording—Lahav Shani and the Rotterdam Philharmonic Orchestra’s new recording of Beethoven’s Piano Concerto No. 4—the low frequencies are less emphasized, resulting in a less sensational, more authentic classical presentation. Listening to the Allegro vivace third movement, the orchestra’s soft opening theme welcomes the piano’s response. During the piano solo, the cello engages in a dialogue. The Reference Transport/DAC presents the layers of piano, cello, and orchestra with clarity and realism. The young pianist, conducting from the keyboard, imbues the performance with youthful energy and brisk tempos. Listening through the Reference Transport/DAC conjures a vivid image of the recording session. The pianist, after playing rapid passages, looks up and gestures to the orchestra for their response, then returns to the keyboard, driving the orchestra with his playing. The new recording through the Reference Transport/DAC is full of musical imagery.
Moving to another familiar cello recording, Wang Jian’s “HiFiReport Period Cello Concertos,” the first track, Boccherini’s Concerto in B-Flat, first movement, begins with a grand orchestral introduction. The Reference Transport/DAC renders the string section with vibrant brilliance and appropriate warmth. The orchestral scale feels fitting for a HiFiReport-era concerto. Wang Jian’s cello solo, repeating the theme, exhibits rich dynamic shading from forte to piano, with detailed expressive nuances. Subtle breathing sounds accompany his playing, particularly noticeable during phrase breaks, making it seem as if Wang Jian is performing live in the room.
Drawing Closer to the Live Performance
Isn’t this realistic recreation of the recording venue what we ultimately seek in high-fidelity audio? We cannot attend every concert (especially difficult now), but through recordings (increasingly in digital file format), we can bridge the distance to the live performance. The more refined the equipment, the stronger the sense of realism. The Reference Transport/DAC excels at creating this powerful sense of musical realism.
Finally, I concluded with Leonard Bernstein conducting the New York Philharmonic in Mahler’s Symphony No. 2. This large-scale orchestral recording, incorporating vocal elements, reaches its climax in the fifth movement finale. The Reference Transport/DAC expands the soundstage to accommodate the two-hundred-member ensemble. The mezzo-soprano and soprano voices intertwine, singing: “O pain! Thou piercer of all things, From thee I am wrested! O Death! Thou conqueror of all things, Now art thou conquered!” This is a familiar recording, but through the Reference Transport/DAC, the soprano and mezzo-soprano voices sound even more lifelike, with richer vocal nuances and enhanced layering. The chorus enters with the male bass section, gradually building in volume and density. As the music reaches its peak, the chorus powerfully sings, “Rise again, yes, thou shalt rise again.” The brass section erupts with full-bodied brilliance, underpinned by the weighty organ, creating a massive sonic foundation. The Reference Transport/DAC handles the dynamic contrasts with beautiful gradation, rendering the music’s crescendo from soft to loud with remarkable clarity, conveying the vast orchestral soundscape built layer upon layer.
For the True Audiophile: MSB is the Choice
Although the Reference Transport/DAC has been returned as I write this review, the realism it delivered remains vivid in my mind, fueled by my listening notes. I recognize this digital source system is undeniably expensive. However, the realism offered by the Reference Transport/DAC is arguably the best I have experienced among digital sources. It is difficult to describe the sonic personality of the Reference Transport/DAC. Its tonality is neither warm nor cold, feeling remarkably neutral, with a transparent and expansive soundstage. Yet, its ability to reproduce musical realism is truly exceptional. If the pursuit of sonic truth is your primary goal in audio performance, then MSB is undoubtedly a brand that will resonate with you.
Specifications
**MSB Reference Transport**
* Playable Formats: UHD Blu-ray, Blu-ray, Blu-ray 3D, DVD-Video, DVD-Audio, AVCHD, SACD, CD, Kodak Picture CD, CD-R/RW, DVD±R/RW, DVD±R DL, BD-R/RE
* Output Formats: Up to 8ch 192kHz PCM, DSD with “Surround Only” output; Coaxial output 2ch 192kHz PCM, Dolby Digital, DTS
* HDMI Audio Output: Up to 7.1ch / 192kHz PCM, 5.1ch DSD, Bitstream
* HDMI Video Output: UHD / 1080p24 / 1080p / 1080i / 720p / 576p / 576i / 480p / 480i, 3D frame-packing 720p / 1080p24
* Dimensions (W x H x D): 444 × 92 × 444 mm
* Weight: 12.7 kg
**MSB Reference DAC**
* Type: DAC
* Maximum Supported Formats: 32 bit / 3,072 kHz PCM, 8 × DSD
* Digital Inputs: Toslink × 2, RCA Coaxial × 1, XLR × 1, word-sync × 1, Module Slots × 4
* Analog Input: XLR (100 k ohms)
* Analog Output: XLR × 1 / Maximum 3.57 Vrms
* Dynamic Range: 145 dBAFS
* Dimensions (W x H x D): 444 × 92 × 444 mm
* Weight: 8.2 kg
**Reference Powerbase**
* Power Input: 100V (Fixed) 120/240V (Auto-Switching)
* Power Consumption: 50W
* Dimensions (W x H x D): 444 × 92 × 444 mm
* Weight: 20 kg