YAMAHA True X BAR 50A + True X 1A___ Review_1
|

Yamaha True X BAR 50A + True X 1A Review


As soundbars become more compact and affordable, a common issue has emerged: their small driver sizes and limited internal volume make it difficult for them to reproduce powerful ultra-low frequencies. Furthermore, regardless of the surround technology employed, soundbars face considerable challenges in creating a convincing sense of “rear surround immersion” around the listener.

The Challenge of Compact Soundbars

This is why the design trend for the new generation of soundbars involves pairing them with *physical* surround speakers and a *physical* subwoofer to achieve a more comprehensive surround sound experience.

Introducing the Yamaha True X Family

As a leader in the soundbar market, Yamaha deeply understands this principle. Therefore, when developing its new generation of soundbars for 2023, it didn’t just create standalone soundbar products. Instead, it developed an entire “family” called True X. The True X family includes two soundbar products, the BAR 50A and BAR 40A, as well as the True X 1A wireless compact speaker. Together, these components can satisfy the vast majority of consumer needs.

Flexible System Building

For example, if you prefer a single soundbar unit, the BAR 40A is the product for you. If you desire a soundbar paired with a physical subwoofer, you can opt for the BAR 50A, which includes a wireless subwoofer right in the box.

If you wish to add physical surround speakers, you can purchase the True X 1A wireless compact speakers separately. These can function as surround speakers for the True X soundbars. You can use one as a rear surround or two as left and right surrounds to create a distinct sense of surround immersion, allowing sound effects to smoothly travel to the area behind your listening position.

The Versatile True X 1A

Is it cost-effective to buy speakers solely for surround sound? Yamaha considered this as well. Their True X 1A surround speakers are designed with a clever twist: when paired with the soundbar, they serve as surround speakers, but when you’re not watching movies, the True X 1A can transform into a standard Bluetooth wireless speaker, perfect for listening to music.

The True X 1A is very small and contains a built-in battery, allowing you to use it in any space – the kitchen, bathroom, or even take it with you for camping or picnics.

In-Depth Look: BAR 50A System

Let’s delve into the acoustic design of this system, starting with the BAR 50A. This is a two-piece system comprising a soundbar and an active subwoofer. The soundbar section features two 4.6×6.6cm oval drivers on the front left and right sides. On the top, it includes two 5.2cm drivers firing upwards to create a sense of height for sound effects. Additionally, there are two 7.5cm drivers on top responsible for reproducing the ultra-low frequencies.

All these drivers are powered by a 180-watt amplifier.

The active subwoofer is equipped with a 16cm bass driver, driven by a 100-watt amplifier. This gives the BAR 50A system a broader frequency response and stronger low-frequency output. The subwoofer receives its signal wirelessly, allowing for flexible placement without needing to worry about signal cable connections.

Connectivity and Features: BAR 50A

The BAR 50A soundbar features one HDMI input and one HDMI output. The output supports HDMI eARC technology and Dolby Atmos decoding. Therefore, by connecting to a smart TV that also supports eARC, it can replace the TV’s built-in speakers and deliver Dolby Atmos surround immersion. The BAR 50A also supports Clear Voice mode, which enhances the mid-range frequencies of dialogue, providing clearer speech when watching content like news or sports broadcasts that are primarily dialogue-driven.

Furthermore, the BAR 50A supports four sound modes: Movie, Stereo, Standard, and Game, allowing you to tailor the sound to different types of content.

When you’re not watching movies, the BAR 50A is also an excellent tool for streaming music. It directly supports Spotify Connect, Tidal Connect, and AirPlay 2, as well as Bluetooth and optical connections, offering multiple ways to enjoy your music. The inclusion of Tidal Connect is noteworthy, as even some dedicated two-channel streaming players don’t support it, yet the BAR 50A does. You can simply switch playback directly within the Tidal app.

In-Depth Look: True X 1A Speaker

Next, let’s examine the True X 1A wireless speaker. It’s compact, standing only about 10 centimeters tall. Inside, it houses a 55mm full-range driver driven by a 10-watt amplifier, complemented by two passive radiators to enhance the ultra-low frequencies. The True X 1A is covered in an acoustically transparent fabric. Yamaha offers three color options: Dark Grey, Carbon Grey, and Light Grey, allowing you to match your room’s aesthetic.

The top of the True X 1A features a button area for power, volume control, and function switching, making operation easy.

True Wireless Convenience: True X 1A

Switching the function of the True X 1A is very straightforward. It has two modes: Surround and Solo. In Surround mode, it acts as a wireless surround speaker for the soundbar. In Solo mode, it functions as an independent wireless speaker, allowing you to play music from your smartphone, tablet, or other mobile devices via Bluetooth. You can toggle between these modes using the buttons on top.

The True X 1A has a built-in battery, meaning it requires neither a signal cable nor a power cable. This makes it a truly “wireless” speaker, eliminating connection concerns whether you use it as a surround speaker or carry it to another room for music listening. The True X 1A charges via USB Type-C. A roughly three-hour charge provides about 12 hours of playback, more than sufficient for watching movies.

Yamaha also offers a dedicated charging cradle (sold separately); simply place the speaker on it, and it begins charging automatically. Additionally, the True X 1A boasts high water and dust resistance with an IP67 rating, so taking it onto a balcony or even near a pool is not an issue.

Performance Analysis

Regarding the user experience, I first tested the BAR 50A system, the two-piece soundbar plus subwoofer setup. The results were impressive, especially concerning the wireless subwoofer. While soundbars with subwoofers are not uncommon today, many use bulky square designs that take up more space. The BAR 50A’s subwoofer features a slim profile, requiring a smaller footprint and looking more aesthetically pleasing.

Crucially, its ultra-low frequency performance is excellent. It not only reproduces substantial bass but also offers significant adjustment flexibility. You can independently increase the ultra-low frequency level via the app. There’s also a Bass Boost mode to further enhance the low-frequency extension. Especially when watching movies, you can feel the energy and impact of the bass.

If you’re not strictly pursuing physical surround channels, the performance of this two-piece system is already commendable.

Adding True X 1A for Full Surround

Next, I tested the system with two True X 1A physical surround speakers using Dolby Atmos test clips. The results were truly outstanding; having physical surround speakers makes a palpable difference. For instance, in the “Leaf” clip, you could clearly hear the sound of the insect flying distinctly behind the listening position. As the camera passed through the leaves and branches, the sounds of foliage swept past from around the seating area.

When the leaves began to swirl and fly upwards, the sound of the leaves traced a clear, beautiful arc behind my seat. In the “Horizon” clip, the spaceship’s sound precisely moved from behind the listening position to the front. This kind of effect is simply not possible with a soundbar alone without physical surround speakers.

Musicality

I must also mention that Yamaha is fundamentally a music-oriented brand. So, while this system emphasizes home theater surround immersion, it still values musicality. Coupled with its support for Tidal Connect, I could directly play high-quality music from Tidal. I found that even with content like violin or piano pieces, the system could render the instruments with a graceful and beautiful texture.

While we generally don’t recommend using a soundbar for two-channel music, the BAR 50A is a rare exception. When playing music, you can also switch modes to the surround setting (with all speakers active) for a fuller sound, which is perfect for home parties.

Conclusion and Recommendation

In summary, the biggest selling point of this system is its ability to provide a complete multi-channel audio experience. It includes a dedicated active subwoofer and physical surround speakers, delivering palpable low-frequency impact and surround immersion behind the listening position. Although the product dimensions are modest, it provides all the enjoyment one could desire. The True X 1A’s ability to transform into a Bluetooth wireless speaker is truly ingenious.

Owning this system simultaneously fulfills the needs for home theater and listening to music in other spaces, and you can even take it outdoors. It’s truly a multi-purpose solution. Given its highly mature design in all aspects, we have decided to give it our highest recommendation.

Setting Up Your True X 1A Surround Speakers

The True X 1A wireless compact speaker supports Bluetooth and can play music content from mobile devices. It can also “transform” into a surround speaker for the True X Soundbar. To do this, you first need to pair it with the soundbar. The process is simple: after powering it on, press and hold the Mode button for three seconds. This allows you to set whether it will be the left or right surround speaker.

Indicators for L and R are on the rear panel of the speaker; simply switch to the correct indicator. Press and hold the Mode button again for three seconds to enter pairing mode. The indicator on top of the speaker will flash. At this point, press the Setup button on the soundbar (also available on the remote control) for three seconds. The two devices will then pair. You’ll hear a confirmation tone from the speaker when pairing is complete.

If you have two surround speakers, pair the second one using the same method.

Specifications

* **Drivers:** Soundbar: 2 x 4.6×6.6cm oval front drivers, 2 x 5.2cm up-firing drivers, 2 x 7.5cm built-in bass drivers. Wireless Subwoofer: 1 x 16cm bass driver.
* **Output Power:** Soundbar: 280W (Front L/R 30W×2, Up-firing L/R 30W×2, Built-in Bass 30W×2). Wireless Subwoofer: 100W.
* **Inputs/Outputs:** HDMI in, HDMI out (eARC), Digital Optical.
* **Surround Modes:** Stereo, Standard, Movie, Game.
* **Power Consumption:** Soundbar: 36W. Wireless Subwoofer: 18W.

* **Dimensions (W×H×D):** Soundbar: 1,015×63×112mm. Wireless Subwoofer: 187×407×409mm.
* **Weight:** Soundbar: 3.9kg. Wireless Subwoofer: 9.4 kg.