BestVox LS 3/6 Loudspeaker Review Review
BestVox loudspeakers are known for having a story to tell with each pair, and each story originates from a legend.
Previously, we reviewed the BestVox LS 3/5a and BestVox LS 5/9 at our editorial office, both of which are based on BBC monitor speakers from the 1970s.
Among them, the LS 3/5a is particularly famous. Even after its production ceased in 1998, well-preserved LS 3/5a models became highly sought-after items in the second-hand market, sometimes fetching prices higher than their original retail price.
Owning LS 3/5a speakers today could be considered almost “free” in a way. You could likely sell them at your purchase price, and if you happen to have the legendary 15-ohm version, you might even sell them for a profit, with the luxury of choosing from numerous eager buyers.
The LS 3/5a is a rare example of a product in the audio market that retains its value, and for some, it’s even considered an investment.
The Motivation Behind Revival: BestVox’s Vision
However, vintage speakers inevitably come with age-related issues.
Components degrade over time; drivers, cabinets, and all parts are subject to aging.
Can aged speakers truly reproduce their original sound? Beyond this concern, if original owners are reluctant to part with their treasures, how can newer enthusiasts experience the allure of these legendary speakers? This is the driving force behind the revival movement.
Some reissued products originate from the original BBC-licensed manufacturers, while others come from brands specializing in recreations.
BestVox falls into the latter category.
Li Ping, the person in charge, has been working in the audio industry for many years and is deeply fascinated by classic British loudspeakers. He collects, listens to, and appreciates these speakers, and is eager to share them with others.
To allow more enthusiasts to access these legendary speakers without the risks associated with aging components, he founded BestVox, dedicated to recreating these classics and continuing their legacy.
The most talked-about speaker, the LS 3/5a, is undoubtedly a key product for Bestvox. The larger, more powerful LS 5/9, which served as an important BBC monitor in the 1980s, is also one of their initial flagship offerings.
Now, a new member has joined the family: the BestVox LS 3/6.
The Story of the LS 3/6
The LS 3/6 loudspeaker also has a story, and it’s quite a fascinating one.
The original designer of the LS 3/6 was none other than the renowned Spencer Hughes, the founder of Spendor.
In the mid-1960s, he was employed by the BBC’s research department as an engineer.
At the time, the BBC was researching plastic diaphragms to create better loudspeakers for monitoring purposes.
BBC engineers hypothesized that plastic diaphragms would outperform the then-prevalent paper cone diaphragms.
Spencer Hughes was one of the engineers responsible for this research, along with another notable figure, Hugh Dudley Harwood, the founder of Harbeth.
After two years of continuous prototyping and experimentation, they finally used the then-famous Bextrene polymer material to create an ideal 12-inch bass diaphragm and designed the LS 5/5 indoor monitor speaker (the first digit after LS indicates the intended use: 5 for indoor monitoring, 3 for outdoor monitoring).
The development of vacuum die-casting equipment significantly improved the production yield of plastic diaphragms and enabled the creation of smaller, high-quality diaphragms. The first successful result was an 8-inch diaphragm.
Spencer Hughes, as an engineer, was constantly thinking about how to bring these top-performing monitor speakers into homes.
He combined the newly developed 8-inch Bextrene diaphragm with a Celestion HF1300 tweeter to create the BC-1, which was the predecessor to the LS 3/6.
He made three pairs of BC-1s and sold them to two professional recording studios, thus establishing the reputation of his “garage” company—Spendor.
However, things didn’t proceed as smoothly afterward.
He proposed the BC-1 to the BBC, but unexpectedly, it was not approved for mass production by the corporation.
Because the late 1960s was the burgeoning era of rock music, the BBC felt that the BC-1’s dynamics and bandwidth were insufficient for the monitoring demands of rock music production.
Therefore, the BC-1 project was shelved.
But Hughes was a proactive person. On one occasion, when the BBC happened to need a pair of speakers of similar size to the BC-1, Hughes seized the opportunity to re-introduce the BC-1, and this time, the BBC agreed.
Hughes was delighted that his design was recognized by the BBC. He specially modified the crossover according to BBC’s requirements and added a multi-tap transformer to ensure smoother integration between the two drivers.
Later, the BBC added a “super-tweeter” and mounted an amplifier on the back panel to create an active version, indicating a change in the BBC’s perception of this speaker.
Everything seemed to be going smoothly, and it appeared that Spencer Hughes could secure a major deal for his newly founded company, Spendor. However, things did not turn out as expected.
Although the BBC included the BC-1 in their LS series of speakers, naming it LS 3/6, they granted the manufacturing license to Rogers.
Hughes could only lament his misfortune. His employment contract with the BBC clearly stated that all inventions and designs created during his employment period belonged to the BBC.
He designed it, but didn’t own the rights, and not only did he not benefit financially, but he wasn’t even granted the manufacturing license.
Could you swallow such a pill? Spencer Hughes did.
He understood the principle of taking a step back to see a broader perspective. He didn’t argue with the BBC and paid them royalties for every pair of BC-1s sold under the Spendor company name, as per the agreement.
In this way, Spendor BC-1s quietly sold in considerable numbers, with over two thousand pairs sold to professional recording studios alone, and the BBC themselves purchased over 600 pairs in total.
Now you understand why Spencer Hughes could become a successful business owner in that dynamic era. He was adaptable and resilient, truly a great man!
Renowned Relatives, All Priced Higher
The story of the LS 3/6 is mostly told here.
However, I want to add a postscript to this story.
Although the BBC LS 3/6 model number may not be as widely recognized, it actually has a large and prestigious family lineage.
You might not be familiar with the LS 3/6, but have you heard of Rogers Studio 1? If you still haven’t, I’m about to mention something you definitely know: the Harbeth Super HL5.
The HL5 has been around for over 40 years, through seven generations of updates, and its price has steadily increased. It has numerous followers worldwide.
From the Super HL5 generation onwards, it transitioned from a two-driver, two-way system to a three-driver, three-way system. Initially, it emulated the original BC-1 form of the LS 3/6, but later fully returned to the LS 3/6 configuration.
Over the years, fueled by media promotion, owning a pair of HL5s seems to have become synonymous with “I am an audiophile” or even “I am an audiophile with taste.”
However, both the Rogers Studio 1 and the Harbeth HL5 (now the Super HL5 Plus) are essentially siblings of the BBC LS 3/6.
Now, do you understand the value of this BestVox LS 3/6? Venture into the second-hand market for vintage BBC LS 3/6s, and it can be an interesting pursuit.
However, wouldn’t it be ideal to acquire a brand new pair and eliminate the risks? When you compare prices, the BestVox LS 3/6 becomes even more appealing.
Currently, Stirling Broadcast still sells the BBC LS 3/6 model, priced at $6,500 USD per pair. Its main attraction is that Derek Hughes, Spencer Hughes’s son, is the driving force behind it.
If you opt for the more famous Harbeth Super HL5 Plus, the US retail price is $6,800 USD. In today’s high-end audio market, both are reasonably priced.
But the BestVox LS 3/6 has a suggested retail price of only NTD 59,800 in Taiwan, which converts to approximately $2,000 USD including tax.
Comparing these prices, the BestVox LS 3/6, a recreation of the classic BBC speaker, is simply exceptional value.
Meticulous and Refined Reproduction
BestVox’s skill in recreating these speakers is profound. If it weren’t for the grille and the badge on the back, it would be difficult to distinguish them from the original products.
The cabinet dimensions are nearly identical, and the cabinets are also made of thin panels. Gently tapping the cabinet with your knuckles produces a solid, not loose, sound.
The grille is fixed with metal pins, and there’s a gold BestVox logo on the upper right of the grille. Below it, a rope loop is designed for easy grille removal.
The rear panel has only one set of binding posts, keeping things simple and avoiding the complexity of bi-wiring. The speaker terminals, with their subtle rose gold hue, inspire confidence in their quality.
The bass reflex port is located in the center, a design detail that differs from the Harbeth HL5.
In-House Replicated Three-Way Drivers
The driver configuration also follows the original design, employing a three-way, three-driver arrangement.
However, the LS 3/6’s three-way design is slightly different from typical three-way systems.
A conventional three-way configuration is “woofer, midrange, tweeter,” but the LS 3/6’s three-way setup is “mid-bass, tweeter, super-tweeter.”
The reasons for this configuration were explained in the story earlier. Interestingly, BestVox’s recreation faithfully mirrors this design.
The topmost tweeter in the BestVox LS 3/6 is a 20mm ferrite magnet dome tweeter, which the manufacturer identifies as a T27 tweeter.
This is significant, as it’s the classic KEF driver famously used in the LS 3/5A.
However, even with BestVox’s extensive resources, finding a sufficient quantity of NOS (New Old Stock) components for production is impossible. This T27 is a newly manufactured replica.
What about the tweeter below it? That’s a 25mm soft dome tweeter with a fan-shaped waveguide in front, featuring a phase-cone-like protrusion in the center and fan blades radiating outwards.
It may look unusual, but it’s a faithful replica of the classic Celestion HF1300, staying true to the original design.
These two tweeters, the HF1300 and the T27, handle different frequency ranges. The HF1300 covers 3,000Hz–13,000Hz, while the T27 handles frequencies above 13,000Hz.
Therefore, calling the T27 tweeter a “super-tweeter” is slightly different from our usual understanding, as it merely shares the upper range of the treble frequencies.
As for the bass driver, it continues to use an 8-inch PP cone woofer. A notable feature is its color.
While most PP drivers are black, this woofer is white, and it appears that the cone diaphragm and concave surround are integrally molded.
We learned that earlier versions of the BestVox LS 3/6 also had black woofers, but the latest version has switched to white woofers, just like the 8-inch woofer in the BestVox LS 5/9.
Where do these drivers come from? Of course, they are also manufactured in-house by BestVox.
How do they replicate these drivers? Simply disassembling old drivers for reverse engineering isn’t enough. They aim for complete authenticity, including the sound characteristics.
BestVox uses FINECone simulation software to perform finite element analysis on the vintage drivers, establishing parameters, setting frequency response, and impedance, ensuring that the replicated drivers’ characteristics match the original drivers.
Therefore, BestVox speakers replicate more than just the appearance.
Matching Stands for Optimal Performance
The BestVox LS 3/6 is a large bookshelf speaker. This size is somewhat awkward; typical speaker stands are often too tall, while placing them directly on the floor is too low. Dedicated stands are essential.
HiFiReport provided a pair of Spotless steel stands along with the BestVox LS 3/6 review samples. The stands perfectly matched the size of the BestVox LS 3/6’s base, and the height was also ideal. It seems these stands are specifically designed for the LS 3/6 and its sibling speakers.
88dB Efficiency: Amplifier Friendly
I mentioned earlier that it’s exceptional value, but to truly warrant the “exceptional value” praise, we need to assess its sound performance.
During the review period, I experimented with different amplifiers. The compact and affordable NuPrime A200 Class-D integrated amplifier, a small unit priced at just over NTD 30,000, drove them quite impressively. It handled rock and orchestral music at high volumes with ease. It even has built-in streaming capabilities, eliminating the need for a separate front-end source.
The BestVox LS 3/6 has an 88dB efficiency rating, higher than its sibling speakers, making it relatively easy to drive.
Users only need to consider their budget and choose an amplifier they like.
Clear Musical Layering
Switching to the Linear Acoustic LAV-60 MK2, the sound gained even more thickness and power. Combined with a denser sonic texture, the music became more three-dimensional.
Driven by a powerful solid-state integrated amplifier (the LAV-60 MK2 delivers up to 100W into 8 ohms), Anne-Sophie Mutter’s rendition of “Rey’s Theme” from the movie “Star Wars: The Force Awakens” sounded with richer and more solid violin tones, further emphasizing the protagonist’s resolute and determined character.
The orchestral sections were clearly layered. When the low strings swelled, the BestVox LS 3/6’s bass, while somewhat conservative in extension and quantity, proved just right for this bass-rich recording, resulting in a more balanced musical presentation.
Easy Placement, Effortless Sound
Listening to Lou Reed’s “Walk on the Wild Side,” the opening bass plucks, with their dynamic variations, revealed the subtle vibrations of the strings being plucked.
Gentle guitar strums played in the background, and when Lou Reed’s vocals entered, a full and solid voice emerged in front of me.
I didn’t spend much time on speaker placement, yet after listening to several tracks and even switching amplifiers, I didn’t feel anything was lacking.
Finding the sweet spot between the room and speakers is a much-discussed pleasure among audiophiles. Some are meticulous, tweaking positions by millimeters. Such dedication is admirable.
But for most users, audio equipment is for enjoying music. If speakers can be this easy to place, freeing listeners from obsessive positioning worries, aren’t such user-friendly speakers highly recommendable?
Lively, Clear, Transparent, and Open
How about tube amplifiers? Can they drive them well? I can tell you, they sound fantastic! The BestVox LS 3/6’s sonic character is very similar to my past experiences with the Harbeth Super HL5 Plus. The latter might be slightly brighter, more transparent, and livelier, but they are fundamentally in the same vein. In audiophile terms, they are lively, clear, transparent, and open, with excellent imaging and soundstage.
This sonic signature pairs beautifully with a good tube amplifier.
Recreating the Live Atmosphere
I paired them with the EAR Yoshino 868 preamplifier and 509 MK2 monoblock power amplifiers. The EAR 509 power amplifiers, with 100W output each, are more than capable of driving the BestVox LS 3/6.
Using Riccardo Muti’s 2021 New Year’s Concert recording with the Vienna Philharmonic as an example, the first track, Franz von Suppe’s march, features two themes, A and B, in a standard ABA ternary form. The music’s tempo is brisk, and the almost constant percussion keeps the rhythm clear, filled with a cheerful and joyful atmosphere.
The soundstage presented by the BestVox LS 3/6 is open, clear, transparent, and well-layered.
The strong rhythm provides a sense of impact, making the listening experience invigorating.
The same atmosphere is also evident in the concert’s closing piece, the “Radetzky March.” These aren’t exactly “audiophile test tracks,” but they are relatable and filled with joyful energy. The BestVox LS 3/6 captured the live atmosphere exceptionally well. I repeatedly increased the volume, and the music remained composed.
These are not speakers designed for overwhelming power; high-volume torture tests are not particularly meaningful for them.
However, the musical atmosphere they create and their ability to convey musical expression are first-rate in this price range.
Refined and Sweet Music at Moderate Volumes
For around $2,000 USD, what kind of refined-sounding speakers can you buy? You can list examples and imagine possibilities, but here’s my suggestion: listen to the BestVox LS 3/6.
As a classical music enthusiast, I spend about 80% of my listening time with classical music.
Classical music demands high sonic quality; the sound must be delicate, and the timbre rich for the music to be beautiful.
The BestVox LS 3/6 is not top-tier, of course, but its performance in its price range is exceptional.
In “Shenandoah,” a collaboration between Yo-Yo Ma and Kathryn Stott, I heard a rich and full-bodied piano, and the cello’s sound chamber had a unique resonance characteristic of thin-walled cabinets. The nasal quality from this resonance added a touch of brightness to the cello’s inherently rich tone.
In “Goin’ Home,” an adaptation of the second movement of Dvořák’s Symphony No. 9, Yo-Yo Ma’s cello lines were clear and robust, warm but not overly lush, gentle and deeply expressive.
The piano’s single notes were crisp and firm, while chords were full and resonant. The subtle textural vibrations were clearly audible yet not exaggerated.
I believe that when listening to chamber music with the BestVox LS 3/6, keeping the volume in the low to moderate range allows you to easily obtain delicate and sweet sounds. Pushing the volume too high might be counterproductive.
Musicality that Melts the Heart
The same principle applies to large-scale orchestral music.
If I were listening with Wilson Audio Alexia 2s, I would crank up the volume. But with small bookshelf speakers, if you turn it up too loud, it’s not just a matter of whether they can handle it, but whether it will sound good at all. Once you grasp this principle, the BestVox LS 3/6 playing Saint-Saëns’ Symphony No. 3 “Organ Symphony” is still wonderfully enjoyable.
I listened to the version conducted by Myung-Whun Chung with the Orchestre de l’Opéra Bastille, one of the most transparent, refined, and balanced recordings of this work.
The BestVox LS 3/6, in reproducing this piece, brought a level of enjoyment comparable to speakers priced significantly higher.
In the first movement’s Allegro moderato section, even with the complex ensemble of various orchestral sections, it could still delineate the layers within, not perfectly, but enough to allow you to appreciate the music.
While its bass is not its strongest point, its clean and crisp bass, though limited in extension, still provided ample foundation for the first movement’s Adagio section.
It’s not subterranean bass, but it’s bass that supports the musical architecture.
Here, you can also hear the mellow strings, dense and radiant.
This is interesting. The BestVox LS 3/6’s high-frequency extension specifications aren’t outstanding, but in musical playback, there’s no lack of radiance, spaciousness, or airiness.
In the second movement’s Allegro moderato and Presto sections, the music is lively and vibrant, bursting with colorful hues.
The BestVox LS 3/6, at appropriate volumes, consistently maintained a clear and well-defined soundstage.
And like the Harbeth Super HL5 Plus I’ve heard, once placed roughly correctly, the speakers easily disappear.
As I sat there listening and writing, my mind was consistently drawn into the world of Saint-Saëns’ music.
Especially in the second movement’s latter half, when the majestic organ enters, and the strings build layer upon layer in a fugue-like manner, although I could nitpick about the organ’s lack of overwhelming grandeur, I was melted by the strings and brass in the fugue.
Following were the light and agile responses of the woodwinds. The sonic picture was beautiful.
I’ve heard better, but I’ve never heard better from speakers in the $2,000 USD price range.
Lively Guitars, Vivid Vocals with Clear Imaging
Finally, to maintain journalistic integrity, I must provide a balanced perspective.
Although I mentioned the limited low-frequency extension when listening to Saint-Saëns’ “Organ Symphony,” it doesn’t mean the BestVox LS 3/6’s bass is truly deficient.
During the listening session, my colleague Cai Chengrong came downstairs to ask what I was listening to. “Oh, it’s these speakers. The bass is pretty good.” Really? I was upstairs and wasn’t sure what it sounded like downstairs. At the time, I was listening to “Shallow” from the “A Star Is Born” soundtrack.
This song builds in intensity towards the end, accompanied by Lady Gaga’s soaring vocals and a barrage of drums. It was probably the drums that drew Chengrong downstairs.
But what impressed me upstairs were the guitar and vocals. I’ve mentioned the vocals before. The BestVox LS 3/6 provides clear imaging and solid body, with rich vocal details and a slightly warm timbre.
Lady Gaga’s powerful singing in the chorus demands dynamic range, and the BestVox LS 3/6 handles it! The guitar sound is lively and crisp, with distinct metallic texture, clearly conveying the close-mic’d details.
Controlled Bass, Not Hollow or Lacking Foundation
Two other tracks that redeem the BestVox LS 3/6’s bass performance are Chris Jones’s “Sanctuary Here” and Jennifer Warnes’s “Way Down Deep.”
The former features both electric bass and male vocals. This recording is consistently favored by audiophiles for its full and solid vocals, lively and rich guitar, and expansive soundstage.
These are precisely the strengths of the BestVox LS 3/6.
The latter track features percussion that is both full and deep, and very lively.
The bass drum sound has large and full impact, with exaggerated effects to create the song’s atmosphere.
Additionally, the shaker-like percussion and occasional guitar accents add a touch of vibrancy to the song.
Jennifer Warnes’s vocals here are not only warm but also very substantial, making for a truly satisfying listening experience.
Based on the bass performance of these two tracks alone, the BestVox LS 3/6 can hold its head high.
A Star Performer in Its Price Range
BestVox’s recreations provide enthusiasts who missed the golden era of BBC loudspeakers in the last century with an easy and accessible path to step into the world that veteran audiophiles cherish.
Just as the LS 3/5a is a legend, the LS 3/6 is undoubtedly a legend as well.
The BestVox LS 3/6 is priced affordably and delivers impressive sound performance. In its price range, it is a star performer, and one of the brightest.
Specifications
* Type: Three-way, three-driver bass-reflex bookshelf speaker
* Drivers: 20mm T27 tweeter x1, 25mm tweeter x1, 200mm Radial woofer x1
* Frequency Response: 42Hz-20,000Hz
* Sensitivity: 88dB
* Impedance: 8 ohms
* Crossover Frequencies: 3kHz, 13kHz
* Maximum Power Handling: 60W
* Dimensions: 630 x 310 x 305 mm (H x W x D)
* Weight: 17 kg