Graham LS 5/9 Bookshelf Loudspeakers Review
When discussing British loudspeakers, the most prominent names in the 1980s were undoubtedly the BBC-certified monitor speakers. Rogers, Spendor, and Harbeth were the undisputed titans of that era. The Graham LS 5/9, which I had the pleasure of auditioning, stands as a true testament to that legacy, a meticulously crafted reissue of a genuinely classic BBC-certified monitor.
Speaking of Graham, the editor here is an owner himself. Currently, the loudspeakers gracing his home system are Chartwell LS 3/5s. While the brand names may differ, they are both speakers produced by Graham.
I first encountered Graham at the 2015 Munich High End Show. At that time, Graham had already introduced their reissue LS 5/9 and LS 5/8, and announced the upcoming LS 3/5. It’s important to note that they produced the LS 3/5, not the familiar LS 3/5a, meaning the LS 3/5 itself was not a BBC-certified monitor loudspeaker.
A Reissue with Provenance: The BBC Classic
How did this distinction arise? The story begins with Graham Audio’s founder, Paul Graham, an audio engineer with a profound passion for traditional BBC monitor loudspeakers. This passion led him to establish Graham Audio in 2006, where he handcrafts “reissued” BBC monitor speakers in the small English town of Newton Abbot.
To faithfully recreate BBC monitor speakers, aiming for an authentic sound, Paul Graham wasn’t working alone. He enlisted the help of Derek Hughes. For those with a keen eye, the surname Hughes might evoke thoughts of Spencer Hughes, the owner of Spendor. Indeed, Derek is Spencer’s son, and Spendor was one of the earliest brands involved in the production of BBC monitor speakers. The “big three” of the original LS 3/5a era were Rogers, Harbeth, and Spendor. If you happen to own a vintage LS 3/5a from forty years ago, congratulations – its resale value has likely increased five to sixfold, and such units are exceptionally rare.
The Risks of Buying Vintage Speakers
It’s not just the LS 3/5a; nearly all vintage BBC monitor speakers have seen their value skyrocket if purchased new decades ago. However, if you’re contemplating buying an older BBC speaker, there’s always the possibility of acquiring a unit that has suffered from age and disrepair. After decades of use, the surrounds of the drive units likely become hardened, potentially requiring replacement upon acquisition. And once replaced, who can say for certain how the sonic character will change?
Consequently, many have entered the realm of BBC speaker reissues, breathing new life into classic designs. Brands like Rogers have been resurrected, Harbeth offers reissues, and Harwood, Falcon, and Musical Fidelity have also joined the fray.
So, why not just get a more affordable Bestvox and enjoy the experience? Why opt for the comparatively more expensive Graham LS 5/9? There’s only one answer: Graham claims to be the *only* manufacturer currently licensed by the BBC to produce certified monitor loudspeakers!
Custom-Ordered Drivers from Specialized Manufacturers
The essence of a classic reissue lies in meticulously recreating components that perform as closely as possible to the original specifications. While some manufacturers boast about using stock parts, drive units are mechanical components. The usability of decades-old stock parts remains questionable. Therefore, Graham chose to collaborate with drive unit manufacturers, commissioning custom-made drivers that adhere as closely as possible to the original specifications.
For the tweeter, Graham employs the Audax HD13D34H, a 34mm silk soft-dome tweeter with a long production history that continues to this day. However, the newly manufactured units feature improvements, theoretically offering superior performance compared to their predecessors. A distinctive feature is the metal grille protecting the silk dome, and the 34mm diaphragm is larger than that found in most tweeter designs.
Regarding the mid-woofer, early LS 5/9 models utilized a 200mm polypropylene cone mid-woofer from British Volt, paired with a PVC surround. However, Volt no longer produces these units. Consequently, the mid-woofer used in the Graham LS 5/9 is built under the supervision of Derek Hughes, adhering as closely as possible to the original specifications.
The Classic Appeal of Thin Wall Cabinetry
Beyond the drive units, let’s examine the cabinet of the Graham LS 5/9. As a classic reissue, it naturally adopts the “thin wall” design. The cabinet is constructed from 9mm birch plywood, with numerous screws visible on the front baffle, securing both the cabinet and the drive units. This aesthetic lends it a charmingly vintage appearance.
The grille design has also seen some improvements. While older versions featured fixed mounting holes, the new LS 5/9 utilizes a magnetic grille system, reducing visible openings and making removal and attachment considerably more convenient.
On the upper left of the LS 5/9’s front baffle, there’s a tweeter level adjustment. However, Graham has directly soldered this to the “0” position, with “+1” and “-1” terminals. Any adjustment would require a soldering iron. I recall earlier models having plug-in terminals, suggesting Graham’s confidence in the LS 5/9’s inherent voicing, hence the decision to solder the terminals and discourage tampering with the settings.
The rear of the newly manufactured Graham LS 5/9 features single-wire speaker terminals. These have been updated with modern components encased in carbon fiber, giving them a distinctly contemporary look. This indicates that Graham is not solely focused on reproduction but judiciously incorporates modern materials to enhance the loudspeaker’s performance.
Positioned as a Medium-Sized Monitor
Designed in 1983, the LS 5/9 was conceived to fill the gap between the LS 3/5a and the larger LS 5/8, providing a suitable mid-sized monitor loudspeaker. The LS 3/5a, with its compact volume, was ideal for nearfield listening. The substantial LS 5/8, boasting a 109-liter cabinet, met the demands for bandwidth and musical energy but its sheer size limited its application. Thus, the LS 5/9 was born.
The LS 5/9’s cabinet volume is more than double that of the LS 3/5, offering significantly improved bass extension. It can achieve reproduction sound pressure levels of up to 100 dB, broadening its application range for monitoring, suitable for both nearfield and mid-distance listening.
Therefore, if you find the musical energy of the LS 3/5a insufficient and the LS 5/8 too imposing, the LS 5/9 is an excellent choice.
The Same Individual Responsible for Assembly to Testing
Graham’s LS 5/9 is not only designed and manufactured in Britain but also emphasizes that each unit is assembled and tested by the same individual from start to finish. This ethos mirrors the “one man, one engine” philosophy found in AMG’s high-performance vehicles. A sticker on the back of the Graham LS 5/9 loudspeaker displays the assembler’s signature alongside a handwritten serial number.
Easier to Drive Than Expected
With an efficiency of 87 dB, the Graham LS 5/9 can be considered moderately efficient. During my audition at HiFiReport, I paired them with a Linear Acoustic LAV 60 II integrated amplifier, delivering around 100 watts. Another setup involved an EAR 868P preamplifier and 509 MK II power amplifier, also around 100 watts. Both systems drove the Graham LS 5/9 with relative ease. Just as I thought I had my conclusions drawn, a Ray Audio 300B PP integrated amplifier arrived for review. This 25-watt integrated amplifier also managed to drive the Graham LS 5/9 commendably, proving the speakers to be easier to drive than I had anticipated.
The Graham LS 5/9, being a modern rendition of a classic, possesses a decidedly vintage charm. For an even more evocative experience, tube amplifiers are a natural fit. While the LAV 60 MK II provided superior soundstage transparency, it felt somewhat lacking in character. The EAR pre/power combination proved more suitable for the Graham LS 5/9, though its price far exceeded that of the speakers themselves. Upon switching to the Waku’s 300B PP, the richness of the mid-range was particularly engaging, eschewing a clear, watery subtlety for an effervescent intensity.
A Balance of Richness and Transparency
Listening to Chris Stapleton’s “Tennessee Whisky,” the opening electric guitar solo, with its subtle overdrive, blossomed into full-bodied notes. As Chris Stapleton began to sing, his voice carried the depth of country music, tinged with a slight nasal quality that lent it a distinct Southern charm. The acoustic guitar strumming in the background was gentle and soft. The Graham LS 5/9 expertly conveyed the layered textures created by multi-track recording, placing the vocals forward while the guitars and bass receded slightly, punctuated by occasional electric guitar chords that heightened the musical intensity.
If the rich country ambiance of “Tennessee Whisky” wasn’t enough to captivate you, try the Beatles. This is where they truly shine. Listening to “Here Comes The Sun,” a deliberate choice in the original studio recording placed the intro solely in the left channel, with the right channel activating only when the vocals began. This highlighted the stereo recording’s spatial playfulness. The vocals, positioned slightly to the right of center, contrasted with the acoustic guitar confined to the left. The Graham LS 5/9 brought the vibrant recording scene to life, with a tonal quality that retained a distinct 1980s flavor, making it a fascinating listening experience.
The Captivating Charm of Jazz Vocals
Moving to some swing jazz, listening to Ella Fitzgerald and Louis Armstrong’s duet on “Can’t Take That Away From Me,” the piano intro possessed a suitable thickness, its keys struck with gentle precision, welcoming Ella’s velvety voice. The Graham LS 5/9’s mid-to-high frequencies exhibited a delicate sheen, with a slightly subdued tone that brought out the nuanced character of Ella’s vocal decay. The subtle embellishments from the backing horns were well-supported by the Graham LS 5/9’s substantial low-end, complementing Ella’s vocals and filling the sonic space.
Louis Armstrong’s subsequent vocal entry, accompanied by his trumpet playing, revealed his famously gravelly voice. Through the Graham LS 5/9, this distinctive throatiness, akin to sandpaper, sounded remarkably flavorful.
Powerful Emotional Resonance with Vocals
If your preference is for a pristine, crystal-clear sound, then the Graham LS 5/9 is likely not for you. These are not modern speakers built for speed or raw power. Instead, they embody the pursuit of the sonic glory of last century’s BBC monitor loudspeakers. Their strength lies in conveying the character of a recording and revealing its classic essence.
For audiophiles who cherish vocal performances, the Graham LS 5/9 warrants significant attention. Its key strength is its ability to convey the emotion embedded within a recording. The Graham LS 5/9 excels in this regard. Listening to Lady Gaga’s “I’ll Never Love Again,” the richness in the mid-range effectively conveyed the emotional shifts in Lady Gaga’s vocalization. A touch more breathiness and a subtler vocal rasp conveyed her lament at the prospect of losing a loved one. As her vocal phrasing tightened, it spoke of the courage to face reality, yet the ultimate loss meant she never wished to fall in love again, never to love a stranger. The Graham LS 5/9 presented the full spectrum of emotional changes within the recording, laying them bare. Does speaker performance truly matter? The ability to evoke feeling is where the Graham LS 5/9 truly shines.
Essential Listening for Chamber Music Enthusiasts
If you have a penchant for chamber music, the Graham LS 5/9 is an excellent choice. Listening to Mitsuko Uchida’s 2023 rendition of “Mozart Piano Sonata No. 1, K. 279,” the cheerful Allegro of the first movement reveals bright and spirited piano notes, with the right hand’s melody harmoniously echoing the left. In Uchida’s masterful hands, this newly performed Mozart possessed a childlike charm even more pronounced than in her younger recordings. The Graham LS 5/9 projected the piano notes with a sense of ease and spaciousness, completely free from any tightness, comfortably conveying Mozart’s inherent innocence and liveliness.
Switching to the “Mozart Piano Trio K. 502” performed by Pierre Amoyal, Gérard Caussé, and Jian Wang, the sustained cello notes form a foundation, while the piano’s cheerful melody interacts with the violin. Subsequently, the cello takes over the theme, with the three instruments engaging in a delightful call and response. The allegro movement brought forth the childlike joy and merriment of Mozart’s music. As the piano reached its higher registers, the Graham LS 5/9 presented exquisite notes, akin to scattered pearls, filling the room with a warm luminescence. This comfortable extension into the mid-high frequencies, even during playful staccato violin passages, remained entirely free from harshness. The Graham LS 5/9’s warm and non-aggressive mid-high frequencies are ideally suited for those who enjoy immersing themselves in music all day long, offering fatigue-free listening.
Zimerman’s Chopin: The Epitome of Romance
Scaling up the ensemble, listening to the slow second movement of “Chopin’s Piano Concerto No. 2” with Krystian Zimerman as soloist, and conducting the Polish Festival Orchestra for this DG recording. Zimerman’s interpretation of this slow movement is noticeably slower than most renditions. For a pianist, playing a slow movement even slower presents the challenge of seamless note transitions. At an already languid tempo, executing legato passages without any perceptible break in sound, which could disrupt the flow of air, is incredibly difficult.
Hearing Zimerman’s Chopin slow movement for the first time, I harbored concerns as the first theme began. However, he performed with an almost meditative stillness, executing the legato passages flawlessly at an even more deliberate pace, making the rapid notes shimmer like a sky full of stars. The slowness instilled a sense of calm in the listener, with decorated, luminous notes within the deliberate tempo, polishing the subtle interplay of light and shadow in the sound.
Revisiting this piece through the Graham LS 5/9, Zimerman’s expression became even more tender and romantic. The dramatic crescendo in the middle section, the dialogue between the string section and the piano, the transition from soft to loud, and the piano’s descent from high to low, returning to the romantic theme – the Graham LS 5/9 rendered these with rich musical expressiveness. Zimerman’s Chopin reached its absolute peak of romanticism.
The Quintessential BBC Classic Sound
If your pursuit is performance, the editor would suggest bypassing the Graham LS 5/9. Modern loudspeakers often surpass it in sheer performance metrics. However, if your desire is for the authentic sound of a classic BBC monitor loudspeaker, then the Graham LS 5/9 is unequivocally a model worth auditioning and comparing amongst the LS 5/9 reissues. Of course, for the distinction of being the sole officially BBC-certified model, you will incur a brand premium. However, if you experience the sound of the Graham LS 5/9 and fall in love with its tonal character, it will all be worth it.
Equipment Specifications
Graham Audio LS5/9
Type: 2-way, 2-driver, bass-reflex bookshelf loudspeaker
Drivers:
* Audax HD13D34H 34mm silk soft-dome tweeter × 1
* Diaphnatone polypropylene 200mm cone mid-woofer × 1
Frequency Response: 50 Hz – 16 kHz, ±3dB
Impedance: 8Ω
Sensitivity: 87 dB SPL (2.83V, 1m)
Recommended Amplifier Power: 50 – 200 Watts
Dimensions: 460 × 280 × 275 mm (H×W×D)
Weight: 14 kg