Spendor D1 Bookshelf Speaker Review
|

Spendor D1 Bookshelf Speaker Review


In the UK, several brands gained prominence due to their ties with the BBC, particularly those that emerged alongside the LS 3/5a. Spencer Hughes, the mastermind behind Spendor, was the original designer of the first version of the LS 3/5, before modifying it to LS 3/5a, which was then licensed for production by companies like Rogers, Spendor, Harbeth, KEF, and others.

When I placed the Spendor D1 bookshelf speakers beside the Chartwell LS 3/5 replica, I noticed their sizes are strikingly similar. However, D1 appears as a modernized and refined version. I began to wonder if Spendor aimed to establish a new standard for British bookshelf speakers with the D1. Perhaps my fresh purchase of the Chartwell LS 3/5 replica and the simultaneous listening experience made me particularly attuned to the design similarities between the two.

Spendor D1 Bookshelf Speaker Review

Design Comparison

What do they have in common? Their dimensions! The D1 has a slightly narrower front panel and a marginally deeper cabinet, with an internal volume nearly the same as the 3/5, and both utilize a sealed box design. This choice of a sealed enclosure is intriguing; today, many bookshelf speakers favor bass-reflex designs to enhance low-frequency presence and extension while improving efficiency. However, the D1 defies this trend, opting for a sealed cabinet that seems to pay homage to the classic BBC listening monitors.

Sealed speakers, while generally less efficient compared to bass-reflex designs and with slightly reduced low-frequency output, provide a cleaner bass quality. If you push the amplifier’s power, and provided the drivers can handle it, sealed cabinets can offer substantial low-frequency response.

Benefits of Sealed Enclosures

The advantage of cleaner low frequencies comes from the lack of airflow noise associated with bass ports. No bass-reflex speaker entirely escapes this issue—even with various designs aimed at minimizing airflow noise, it can only be reduced, not totally eliminated. In contrast, sealed enclosures completely avoid air turbulence noise issues, requiring slightly more power to match the sound pressure levels of bass-reflex speakers, but without the drawbacks of airflow noise.

Spendor D1 Bookshelf Speaker Review

This leads to the notion that, generally speaking, sealed box low frequencies should be cleaner, but this is not an absolute rule. Speaker design is complex; while it may seem straightforward with simple passive components, the calibration of each part is challenging and lacks precise measurement methods.

Internal Components and Quality

The D1 also includes new components throughout, particularly in the drivers. The 15 cm mid-bass driver features a newly designed polymer diaphragm, referred to by Spendor as “Advanced Polymer.” While the material seems promising, Spendor does not elaborate on its specific advantages.

The high-frequency driver is a silk dome with a new design known as LPZ phase correction. This design echoes traditional BBC monitor characteristics, enhancing the dispersion of high frequencies through strategically designed grille openings. Spendor emphasizes the importance of phase correction in the D1, suggesting there are nuances beneath the surface.

Spendor D1 Bookshelf Speaker Review

Additionally, the internal wiring of the D1 incorporates silver-plated copper wiring, and the speaker terminals appear to be high-end WBT-style connectors. The damping material inside the cabinet is labeled “dynamic damping,” intended to minimize cabinet resonance, yet details about implementation remain undisclosed, hinting at a well-guarded trade secret.

Aesthetic Appeal and Finish

One tangible aesthetic appeal of the D1 is its beautiful piano lacquer finish. When placed alongside the LS 3/5 replica, the D1’s glossy finish vastly outshines the matte wood of the LS 3/5. The magnetic grille design allows for a clean look when removed, exposing a flawless surface that resembles high-end furniture.

I must admit, the LS 3/5 replica strikes a natural beauty while the D1 is like a meticulously styled model, exuding both elegance and sophistication.

Spendor D1 Bookshelf Speaker Review

Pairing with Amplifiers

In my setup, I usually employ the Electrocompaniet EC 4.8 preamp and NuForce Reference 18 power amplifier, with sources from the North Star Design Model 192 turntable and the recently upgraded Merging NADAC DAC. This entire setup costs several times the price of the D1, creating a mismatch in value, so I sought out an Audionote IZero integrated amplifier as a more equitable pairing.

As a small, sealed bookshelf speaker, the D1’s efficiency is somewhat modest, rated at 85 dB—better than the 83 dB of the LS 3/5. Still, it is surprisingly easy to drive. The 175 watts of the NuForce R18 pushes effortlessly, but even the 8 watts from the IZero managed quite well. I anticipated struggles when using 8 watts to power the LS 3/5, but with the D1, it was comparatively easier.

Although the efficiency figures differ by only 2 dB, in real-world applications, the D1 proves to be friendlier on amplifiers. With the IZero, the sound was rich and textured. Listening to Haeckel’s complete Mozart Piano Concertos, every note had a sugary brightness, and D1’s clear soundstage effectively conveyed the recording’s ambiance.

In comparison to the pairing of the EC and NuForce amplifiers, while they provided more weight and impact, the IZero offered a charming sweetness in the trailing notes.

Spendor D1 Bookshelf Speaker Review

Conclusion: A Modern Classic

When I played orchestral or concerto pieces, the IZero felt strained, indicating that larger power amplifiers would yield better control. However, during quiet nights, the delightful warmth of the IZero at low volumes offered a captivating listening experience.

The D1’s sonic signature is a blend of classic British warmth combined with modern clarity and openness. Compared to the LS 3/5, which delivers a softer sound, the D1 maintains a brilliant, transparent personality, showcasing an extended low frequency without compromising clarity.

In essence, while the D1 comes at a premium price, it justifies its cost through its comprehensive design and exquisite finish. Beyond being a mere bookshelf speaker, the D1 represents a new era in British audio, illustrating that it can deliver warmth while embracing a broader frequency range and refined dynamics.

Specifications

  • Model: Spendor D1
  • Type: 2-way, 2-driver bookshelf speaker
  • Drivers: 22mm LPZ tweeter, 150mm Spendor ep77 mid-bass
  • Frequency Response: 55Hz – 25kHz
  • Efficiency: 85dB/1Watt/1metre
  • Impedance: 8 ohms
  • Crossover Point: 4.8 kHz
  • Power Handling: 125W
  • Dimensions: 305 × 165 × 190 mm (H × W × D)
  • Weight: 5.8 kg (each channel)