Harbeth Monitor 40.2 40th Anniversary Edition Speaker Review
The Legendary History of Harbeth
What makes Harbeth hold such a revered status in my heart? The story begins with its founder, Dudley Harwood, who was previously involved in the development of BBC speakers. His contributions, such as the “thin-wall cabinet philosophy” and the use of polypropylene (PP) membranes in drivers, are the fruits of his labor. After retiring from the BBC in 1977, he established Harbeth, continuing to utilize the innovations he developed while at the BBC. As a result, Harbeth became one of the brands recognized for its classic BBC speaker designs.

Even after Dudley Harwood retired from Harbeth in 1988, the company transitioned to ownership under Alan Shaw, who greatly appreciated Harwood’s design philosophy. Shaw improved the polypropylene driver and developed a unique formula, resulting in Harbeth’s exclusive “RADIAL” driver. The official Harbeth website features a user discussion forum where Shaw frequently shares insights about Harbeth’s design concepts and technologies, fostering vibrant discussions among users. This confirms that Harbeth has a dedicated following, with enthusiasts holding it in an irreplaceable position in their audio journey.
The M40.2—Improved Efficiency Over Its Predecessors
The focus of this listening session, the M40.2, is Harbeth’s latest flagship speaker, launched last year. Its design can be traced back to 1998 when Harbeth sought to address issues of sound imbalance and excessive volume in the BBC’s large monitor speakers, LS5/8S. The original M40 replaced the LS5/8S, featuring a bass driver manufactured by VIFA, noted for its pronounced low-frequency presence. However, this made placement in typical home environments challenging. After VIFA ceased production of the M40’s bass driver, Shaw decided to produce his own.

According to Art Dudley’s review of the Harbeth M40.1 in Stereophile, Shaw collaborated with Derek Hughes from the competing brand Spendor to develop a new generation of 12-inch polypropylene bass driver, capable of a frequency response up to 400Hz—one octave higher than the original VIFA driver. The second-generation flagship speaker, the M40.1, was launched in 2008 with this newly developed driver.
The latest M40.2 was introduced mid-2015. While the driver configuration and cabinet design closely resemble the M40.1, it boasts an efficiency of 86dB/W, an improvement of 1dB over its predecessor, and a frequency response that extends down to 35Hz, 3dB deeper than the M40.1. In a newsletter from May 2015, Alan Shaw remarked that the M40.2 is “more sensitive and efficient, capable of being driven by low-power amplifiers, while delivering a more open and transparent listening experience.” The 12-inch polypropylene bass driver in the M40.2 is reportedly a collaboration between Shaw and Hughes.

Classic Design with Exquisite Craftsmanship
This listening session took place in the showroom of Pinle Audio, located at the northern end of Zhonghua Road in Taipei City. Upon entering Pinle’s listening room, the M40.2 was already positioned for evaluation. Like other Harbeth speakers, the M40.2 features a boxy design, devoid of any smooth curves. Although such cabinet designs were prevalent in the 1960s and 1970s, the M40.2’s elegance stands out in today’s market, where curvy and compact speakers are favored, exuding a nostalgic charm.
The M40.2 on display was finished in cherry wood. A closer inspection reveals that, despite its simple shape, the craftsmanship is exceptional. The edges of the front baffle and the joints with the cabinet are meticulously finished. The 45-degree angles between the cabinet panels and the treatment around the screws and speaker terminals show no visible roughness from wood fibers. The fine detailing in the Harbeth M40.2’s cabinet is impeccable, leaving no room for criticism.
It is well-known that rectangular cabinets, with three pairs of parallel panels, are prone to generating significant energy-related standing waves, leading to box coloration. Logically, one might presume that the M40.2 would exhibit strong sonic coloration. However, Harwood identified during his work on BBC speaker designs that the thickness of the cabinet panels significantly affects resonance, and the M40.2 utilizes this principle to minimize cabinet resonance and deliver clear sound.

Addressing Cabinet Resonance Through Thickness and Joints
Many believe that thicker cabinet panels equate to a heavier cabinet and better vibration damping. The BBC, in the 1950s, discovered that cabinets made from 18mm thick panels exhibited a peak in frequency at 500Hz when measured on the sides. In contrast, cabinets made from 6mm thick panels displayed their highest peak below 100Hz, with another peak at 500Hz but with lower energy levels than the 18mm version. Cabinets constructed from 12mm thick panels peaked at 100Hz, with almost no resonant peaks in the midrange; any 100Hz peaks were managed through internal bracing and damping materials.
The BBC applied this knowledge in their LS3/1 design, and Dudley Harwood naturally incorporated thin-wall cabinet techniques in Harbeth speakers. The latest M40.2 continues this thin-wall philosophy.
Beyond utilizing thin wood panels to minimize resonance, the M40.2’s front baffle is not glued or attached through traditional woodworking methods; instead, it is secured with screws. The tension of these screws was meticulously determined through extensive research by Harbeth, effectively minimizing the influence of cabinet resonance.
Upon closer inspection of the drivers, one can observe a deliberate gap between the front baffle and the cabinet. This is not an oversight but serves a crucial purpose. As Shaw noted in the Harbeth user discussion forum, a bell can produce a powerful sound, but any crack on its surface silences it. Similarly, if a speaker’s front baffle is glued to the cabinet, it can easily produce resonance. Conversely, by using screws to secure the front baffle while maintaining an appropriate gap, resonance can be effectively reduced. Harbeth uses thin wood panels for both the front baffle and the cabinet, retaining a gap and using screws with specific torque settings to minimize cabinet resonance.

The RADIAL-2 Midrange Driver—The Soul of the Speaker
In addition to its unique cabinet philosophy, the M40.2 features the “RADIAL-2” midrange driver, which is a hallmark of Harbeth technology. Traditionally, drivers were primarily made from natural materials like paper pulp, which are costly and difficult to control in quality. During his time at the BBC, Dudley Harwood discovered that polypropylene, being highly moldable and economical, was an excellent choice for mass production of driver cones. After leaving the BBC and founding Harbeth, he naturally continued to use polypropylene for the drivers.
Although Harwood later abandoned polypropylene in favor of other polymer materials, Alan Shaw, upon acquiring Harbeth in 1986, recognized the unique advantages of polypropylene drivers. He consequently sought funding from the UK government, dedicating five years to developing the optimal formulation for sound quality. This resulted in the creation of the RADIAL driver—an acronym for “Research And Development Into Advanced Loudspeaker”—which boasts a captivating glossy finish and distinct Harbeth sound signature.
The M40.2 utilizes the “RADIAL-2” midrange driver, which is essential to Harbeth’s identity. Its unique polypropylene formula not only provides a lustrous sheen but also prevents vibrational energy from being converted into heat, preserving more musical detail. Today, polypropylene has become a common membrane material, but how does Harbeth’s RADIAL driver differ from other standard polypropylene drivers?
Alan Shaw emphasizes that the key distinction lies in the reproduction of decay. Other polypropylene drivers convert some kinetic energy into heat during operation, which obscures details in the decay. Consequently, music played through these standard drivers often sounds dry and lacks vitality. The RADIAL driver avoids converting subtle vibrations into heat, retaining the intricate details present in the decay. Shaw believes that the RADIAL driver’s superior decay reproduction is a significant reason for Harbeth’s unique charm. The midrange driver used in the M40.2 is a new generation “RADIAL-2” driver, featuring an improved suspension for even better detail reproduction.

The high-frequency driver employed in the M40.2 is the Seas Excel T25CF001, a 1-inch silk-dome tweeter, which features a complex rear chamber that mitigates unnecessary resonance and reflection for clear sound.
Pairing with Rega Equipment and Spec Tuning Tools
For this listening test, Mr. Jian Shengyi, the manager of Pinle Audio, chose to pair the M40.2 with the flagship Rega CD player, ISIS, and the Osiris integrated amplifier. The ISIS employs a dual mono design with a PCM1794 chip and Class A differential amplification. It features a buffering memory to minimize reading errors. The Osiris integrated amplifier also follows a dual mono design, featuring a robust 400VA toroidal transformer and 40,000 microfarads of filter capacitance for each power stage. The preamp circuit is passive, while the power stage employs a single-stage amplification, ensuring signal integrity through a minimalist design.
“Since the Harbeth M40.2 comes from the UK, it seems fitting to use Rega—also from the UK—to drive it, creating a pure British sound,” Mr. Jian explained regarding the equipment pairing. Furthermore, I observed that each M40.2 was equipped with a SPEC RSP-901EX audio quality enhancer. This device features two speaker terminals, connecting the speaker cables to the M40.2’s terminals, and its wooden exterior complements the M40.2 aesthetically. Mr. Jian mentioned that the SPEC RSP-901EX “can absorb reactive power from the speakers, leading to a cleaner sound quality.” With this tuning tool, the true potential of the M40.2 can be fully realized.
Clear Highs and Rich Lows
Many people assume that traditional English speakers like the M40.2 are best suited for lyrical jazz or classical strings. However, at the beginning of the listening session, I took a different approach and played the first four keyboard sonatas (K212, K247, K144, K133) from Pierre Hantaï’s album Scarlatti 4 (Mirare MIR285).
The K212 and K247 sonatas are characterized by brisk tempos, energetic rhythms, and intricate embellishments. Through this system, the harpsichord’s sound had a balanced character, neither too thin nor overly robust, while the tonal clarity presented just the right amount of sheen—neither glare nor dullness. Importantly, every key strike revealed clear transient details, presenting the embellishments with clarity.
Initially, I perceived that this vintage British speaker prioritized warmth over detail, but after hearing these two sonatas, I found my preconceptions were overturned. Despite the unique metallic timbre of the harpsichord, the M40.2 distinctly showcased the character of both the high and low frequencies. At the conclusion of K144, slow high notes resonated with a delicate elegance, and the lingering decay was profound. In K133, with its heavy accents delivered using chords, the M40.2 portrayed the low frequencies with a rich, painterly texture.
To further explore the M40.2’s sound characteristics, I decided to listen to George Crumb’s String Quartet in B Major, performed by the “Diotima String Quartet” from their album American Music (Naive V5272). This work allowed me to observe how the M40.2 rendered the four instruments, which, despite being similar in design, varied in tonal range and voice. The M40.2 revealed incredible detail in the bowing techniques of all four violins, enhancing the textures of the melodies.
When reproducing the sound of the first violin on the left, the M40.2 rendered a fine, flowing line with a silky sheen, while the cello’s tone resembled broad strokes of watercolors, with bold tonal shifts contributing to a full-bodied texture.
One might question whether the disparity in tonal characteristics between the violin and cello leads to an imbalance. Quite the opposite! What I experienced was a delightful blend of these distinct colors, with rich low frequencies not overshadowing the mid and high melodies, maintaining a sense of transparency.
The Sensory Experience of M40.2
I was pleasantly surprised by the M40.2’s robust low end, prompting me to play the first movement of Shostakovich’s Violin Concerto No. 1, conducted by Yakov Kreizberg with the Bavarian Radio Symphony Orchestra and featuring German cellist Müller-Schott (Orfeo C 659 081 A). The piece begins with a cello solo, whose rich, full-bodied sound exuded a savory aroma, reminiscent of a freshly made beef burger, with juicy meat patties nestled within whole grain bread, creating a mouthwatering experience.
At 1:47, the cello shifts to plucking; through the M40.2, it displayed both fullness and a throbbing vigor. In terms of soundstage, Pinle’s listening room allowed the M40.2 to recreate a deep soundstage, providing clear layers between the cello solo and the orchestra. The orchestra’s string instruments showcased a broad, supple quality, with powerful strokes lending ample energy to the music. Additionally, the brass instruments that emerged at 2:16 shone brightly and energetically, contrasting beautifully with the softer qualities of the low strings.
After savoring so much classical music, I decided to switch to jazz to see how well the M40.2 could perform. I played the final track, “Les Papillons Noirs,” from the album Sine Qua Non (Coup Perdu CPCD001). The piece begins with vibraphone sounds resembling a music box, and through the M40.2, the tonality was warm and sweet, akin to amber-colored honey. Following that, when the saxophone joined, it sounded like a freshly baked sponge cake, soft and fluffy, radiating warmth, without any harsh sensations that might traditionally accompany jazz music.
At the end of this album, there are two hidden tracks—a solo guitar piece and a female vocal track. When the guitar solo is played through the M40.2, it seems to take on a colossal size, as if viewed on a big-screen movie. However, the sound of the low bass strings resonates with the chewy texture of handmade udon noodles, while the high strings exhibit a delicacy that enhances the overall listening experience, evoking the curves of a female figure, reminiscent of the works of the painter Chang Yu.
The final track features a female vocalist whose sound, delivered through the M40.2, is light and airy, offering youthful tones and a relaxed vibe. The accompanying high-pitched instrumentation floats serenely, while the rhythmic drums provide a robust support, akin to comfort and buoyancy.
Lifelike Vocals and Powerful Drums
When the M40.2 performs classical and jazz music, it exhibits a remarkable comfort. But how would it handle rock music? I played “Ten Thousand Hippies” from the self-titled album by the rock band “Universal Youth Hostel” from Shijiazhuang, Hebei (Youliao Music uloud032).
The song begins with the lead singer’s voice sounding as if emerging from a traditional radio speaker, with a constricted soundstage and filled with noise. However, after 0:35, the sonic palette expands, as electric guitar, bass, drums, and trumpet explode into a powerful performance, like a wild beast unleashed, with energy building to a crescendo. The changes in soundstage and volume bring forth an extraordinary impact.
Subsequently, the singer’s voice is presented in an unprocessed manner; through the M40.2, it sounds transparent, devoid of colorations, and exhibits a softness and corporeality in texture that is richer than the accompanying instruments. The unexpected turns in the singer’s vocal inflections convey an engaging and vivid quality.
A Blend of Comfort, Speed, and Power
Initially, I assumed the M40.2 would embody the characteristics of a standard British gentleman’s speaker—measured, warm, and polite. However, after an extensive listening session, I discovered that the M40.2 offers vibrant, expressive vocals, while its highs are clear and lows are rich and juicy. Although each element diverges, together they create a harmonious musical landscape without any sense of discord.
Even more impressively, the M40.2 delivers quick and powerful responses, with particularly decisive low-end performance that adds a rich, healthy, and vibrant texture to the music. Having never heard the previous M40 or M40.1 models, I was curious to see how the M40.2 compared to the Spendor SP100R², which shares similar British heritage, appearance, and design ethos.
When I asked Mr. Jian about the differences between the M40.2 and the other two models, he mentioned that he had not heard the M40 or M40.1 or the Spendor SP100R². However, he pointed to the Harbeth Super HL5 Plus outside the listening room and indicated that the M40.2 reacts much faster, defying expectations of a typical British speaker.
The M40.2 has its own approach to interpreting music; it is rich in tonal quality with a pronounced physicality, yet it remains brisk and powerful. In truth, apart from needing custom stands due to its unique size, there is little to criticize.
After reading this review, you might find yourself intrigued by the M40.2. Why not visit Pinle Audio and experience the dynamic British sound of the M40.2 driven by Rega equipment for yourself?
Specifications
- Type: 3-way, 3-driver sealed speaker
- Drivers: 25mm soft dome tweeter x1; 200mm RADIAL-2 polymer midrange x1; 300mm bass x1
- Frequency response: 35Hz – 20kHz ±3dB
- Impedance: 6 Ohms
- Sensitivity: 86dB (1W/m)
- Recommended amplifier power: 35W or greater
- Maximum power handling: 650W
- Dimensions: 750 x 432 x 388 mm (H x W x D)
- Weight: 38 kg