Melco D100 E100 Review
Melco D100 USB CD Transport/E100 USB HDD
An increasing number of audiophiles are now accustomed to file playback as their primary listening method. However, a simple, easy, and high-quality solution for ripping CDs and storing files seems to be lacking. To address this need, Melco, a high-end NAS brand from Japan, has launched the D100 USB transport and E100 USB external hard drive, helping you effortlessly manage your treasured music collection.
Exceptionally Solid Chassis Structure
The D100 can almost be considered an external USB transport designed specifically for Melco music servers. This is because while Melco music servers feature CD ripping capabilities, they lacked a corresponding dedicated product, requiring users to find their own optical drives.
I recall when I reviewed the Melco N1A music server, a NAS with audiophile sensibilities, I used a very basic Imation slim USB optical drive to rip CDs. The extraction quality was quite ordinary. Later, when writing about the Melco N1ZH/2, a top choice for high-end streaming enthusiasts, Sound Art (the distributor) provided an I/O Magic optical drive they had sourced from Japan. This drive had a standard optical drive size, not a slim mechanism, along with a robust chassis and power supply. The ripping quality subsequently improved.
Now, with the introduction of the Melco D100, Melco users finally have a top-quality optical drive option to choose from.
Even better, the D100 is compatible not only with Melco’s own N1 series products but also with Windows 10 or Mac computers. This means if you prefer to rip CDs using your computer, the D100 is also an excellent choice, offering superior ripping quality compared to typical optical drives.
The internal structure of the Melco D100 USB transport features a thick iron plate that firmly secures the optical drive to the base, minimizing vibrations during operation.
The chassis structure of the D100 is exceptionally solid, with an overall weight of 3.5 kg.
Using the D100 is straightforward. Simply connect it to a compatible music server or computer via the USB 3.0 Type B port on the rear panel.
The D100’s chassis is meticulously crafted. The aluminum alloy top cover and front/rear panels are just the outer shell; inside, there is another layer of aluminum casing, creating an extremely rigid structure.
Internally, it houses a Pioneer BDR-209MBK Blu-ray drive, firmly mounted to the base plate with a thick iron plate to minimize vibrations during operation.
The D100 operates with very low noise, and the disc tray moves smoothly and quietly, which is quite impressive.
Operation is simple: connect the D100 to a compatible music server or computer via the rear USB 3.0 Type-B port. Press the power switch on the bottom left of the D100’s front panel, and the power indicator will light up, indicating a USB connection. You can then proceed to rip or play CDs.
If the USB cable is not connected, the power indicator will not illuminate even if the power switch is pressed.
Furthermore, Melco has tested the compatibility with other music servers, such as Sony HAP-Z1ES and Fidata HFAS1-X20, all of which are compatible with the D100.
This is the E100, containing a 3.5-inch HDD. This hard drive is also secured inside the chassis with a very thick iron plate, with damping material between the plate and the drive to absorb vibrations.
Damping material is also placed between the hard drive and the iron plate for further vibration absorption.
Compatible with Other Brands’ Products
Next, let’s examine the E100 USB external hard drive.
The E100 contains a 3TB traditional hard drive, the same type used in the N1 series.
Similar to the optical drive in the D100, this hard drive is also firmly mounted inside the chassis with a thick iron plate, and damping material is placed between the plate and the drive to absorb vibrations.
The external casing is also identical to the D100, equally heavy, solid, and exquisitely crafted, far surpassing ordinary 3C external hard drive enclosures.
The rear panel of the E100 has one USB 3.0 Type B port and one USB 3.0 Type A port. The Type B port is used to connect to a music server or computer for reading data stored within. The E100’s internal hard drive is pre-formatted to exFAT, which is compatible with both Windows and Mac systems. Of course, you can reformat the drive to FAT32 or NTFS as needed.
The Type A port can connect to compatible players or DACs for direct playback of music files stored on the E100.
According to Melco’s factory testing, the E100 is also directly compatible with devices such as OPPO BDP-105D, OPPO Sonica, Sony HAP-Z1ES, Esoteric N-01, Teac NT-505, Teac NR-7CD, Merging NADAC, and others, demonstrating broad compatibility.
The Melco N1ZS20 music server was also provided for this review, allowing me to directly test its CD ripping capabilities.
The N1ZS20 has several USB 3.0 ports on the rear panel. The D100 must be connected to the port labeled “USB 3.0”.
The following is a photo-illustrated explanation of the ripping process.
I inserted Alanis Morissette’s “Jagged Little Pill” CD and pressed the round button below the disc tray to close it.
The N1ZS20 immediately connected to the music database and began searching for track information and album art for the CD.
The N1ZS20 has found the “Jagged Little Pill” album and is asking if I want to import it. To confirm, press the OK button on the right side of the front panel.
The N1ZS20 starts ripping, and the front panel displays the progress.
Once completed, the disc tray automatically ejects, and you can continue ripping the next CD.
[Image: Left – BubbleUPnP app showing ripped files in N1ZS20. Right – Folder structure showing Alanis Morissette folder.]
Left image caption: Next, I used the BubbleUPnP app on my phone to check if the CD had been ripped into the N1ZS20.
All ripped music is stored in the “import_CD” folder. Select it.
Right image caption: You can see that the N1ZS20 has automatically created an “Alanis Morissette” folder, and the ripped CD is located within that folder.
The N1ZS20 can also play CDs directly using the D100, but this function is only available when the N1ZS20 is connected to a USB DAC.
I connected the N1ZS20 to my Audiobyte Black Dragon. When a CD is inserted, the N1ZS20 will ask if you want to “Import” CD or “Play” CD.
You can use the up and down buttons on the right side of the front panel to select.
After selecting “Play,” the N1ZS20 starts playing the CD.
Ripping Tracks with Ease and Efficiency
If you are not an N1ZS20 user and want to use a computer with the D100 to rip CDs, is it possible? The answer is yes.
I usually use a desktop computer with a built-in optical drive and EAC software to rip CDs. Now with the D100, I couldn’t miss this opportunity.
The process is simple: just connect the D100 to your computer using the included USB cable. Then, in the EAC software, select the Pioneer BDR-S11J-X optical drive in the drive options in the top left corner.
During the ripping process, I noticed that the D100 remained very quiet even at high speeds, demonstrating the effectiveness of its solid mechanical structure.
What about the quality of the ripped tracks? I conducted a comparison to evaluate this aspect.
I ripped Mariah Carey’s “The Ballads” compilation album using both “N1ZS20 + D100” and “Desktop Computer + D100”. The files were all stored on the N1ZS20 for listening comparison. The files ripped by the computer sounded better, with the difference lying in detail retrieval and vibrancy.
This result was not surprising to me. I believe it’s not that the computer is superior to the N1ZS20, but rather that the computer utilizes EAC, a highly professional audio track extraction software, resulting in better ripping quality.
Therefore, I then used the computer with its built-in ordinary optical drive to rip “The Ballads” again. These files were also imported into the N1ZS20 to compare with the files ripped by “Desktop Computer + D100”. What were the results? “Desktop Computer + D100” still won, excelling in the lingering sense of reverb and decay, a better sense of airiness, richer vocal tremors and subtle nuances, and a more vivid musical expression and natural, lively musical atmosphere. Simply put, it won in detail, and detail is fundamental to high-fidelity audio reproduction. Starting with a fundamental advantage makes subsequent sound improvements even more effective.
Excellent Partners for File Playback
For a long-term EAC user like myself, the D100’s ability to bring better results to audio track extraction is indeed surprising. For those who intend to preserve their CD collection, it is a worthwhile solution to consider. Especially if you own a large number of CDs, the average cost of ripping each CD decreases, making the D100 even more valuable.
If you are already a Melco NAS user and prefer to avoid using a computer, desiring a simple and convenient way to play CDs or rip tracks, the D100 can certainly assist you.
The E100 is a very reliable and straightforward storage solution. Unlike typical NAS devices that require network connections and complex configurations, it is plug-and-play and extremely convenient.
In addition to expanding the storage capacity of Melco NAS, it can also be used with other players or USB DACs, such as the popular Roon Nucleus. The Nucleus can only accommodate 2.5-inch hard drives with limited capacity, requiring external hard drives or NAS for economical storage expansion. In this scenario, the E100 can be very useful.
Specifications
**Melco D100**
* Type: USB Optical Disc Drive
* Supported Discs: CD, DVD, BD (Read-only)
* Ports: USB 3.0 Type A × 1, USB 3.0 Type B × 1
* Power Supply: DC 12V (48W AC Adapter)
* Dimensions: 215 × 61 × 269 mm (W × H × D)
* Weight: 3.5 kg
* Price: $837 USD (Original price: 27000 NTD)
**Melco E100**
* Type: USB External Hard Drive
* Capacity: 3.5-inch 3TB HDD × 1
* Ports: USB 3.0 Type A × 1, USB 3.0 Type B × 1
* Power Supply: DC 12V (48W AC Adapter)
* Dimensions: 215 × 61 × 269 mm (W × H × D)
* Weight: 3.6 kg