DS Audio DS 002 image 1

DS Audio DS 002 Cartridge Review


For the audio market, DS Audio is a new face, and their “pure analog optical cartridge” is a new term unfamiliar to many audiophiles, even vinyl enthusiasts.

If you Google DS Audio, the first results will be Synology’s NAS software, and you won’t find audio or analog cartridge information on the first page. You have to go to the second page to find reports related to DS Audio cartridges.

New Venture from an Old Company

In fact, the DS Audio brand comes from Digital Stream Corporation (DSC), a company with over thirty years of history. Most people have probably used DSC products because their laser optical technology is widely applied in mice, and they have been long-term partners with Microsoft and Sharp.

DS Audio is a new venture of DSC, specializing in the production of “optical cartridges.”

DS Audio DS 002 Turntable Review

The first flagship DS 001 was launched in 2013, followed by the DS-W1 in 2014. Both products received recommendations from Japan’s Analog magazine Grad Prix upon release.

In 2016, they launched the top-tier DS Master1, followed by the more affordable DS 002 in early 2017.

Pioneer Taiwan arranged for me to visit HiFiReport to listen to the DS 002 optical cartridge and phono amplifier combination. However, before reporting on the listening experience, it’s necessary to explain in detail what DS Audio’s pure analog optical cartridge is and why I say it “solves the problems of traditional cartridges.”

Not Laser Reading

Emphasizing “pure analog” means that DS Audio’s cartridge is different from the “laser optical vinyl turntable” we know. Laser vinyl turntables use “light” as a stylus to read the music signal from the vinyl grooves through refraction angles. Since light has no weight, it doesn’t wear the vinyl surface, ensuring no damage to the record. This technology is widely used in audio libraries worldwide, including the Tsao Yung-Kun Memorial Section of the National Concert Hall Library, which uses laser vinyl turntables that don’t scratch the vinyl surface. However, DS Audio’s optical cartridge is completely different from laser vinyl turntables.

From the outside, the DS 002 cartridge looks identical to a regular cartridge, with a cartridge shell, four output contacts, a stylus, a cantilever, and damping, with almost no difference in appearance from traditional cartridges. The biggest difference is that when the DS 002 is working, there is a beautiful light blue LED at the front of the cartridge. Don’t think this is just for looks; it’s a key technology of the optical cartridge.

DS Audio DS 002 Turntable Review

To understand what an “optical cartridge” is, we need to go back to the working principles of MM and MC cartridges, identify the inherent problems of MM and MC cartridges, and then understand what problems the so-called “pure analog optical cartridge” solves.

Solving the Design Challenges of Traditional MM and MC Cartridges

The working principle of MM and MC cartridges is the process of electromagnetic induction. MM is called a moving magnet cartridge, and MC is called a moving coil cartridge. Both look similar, with a long thin cantilever protruding from the cartridge shell, with a stylus mounted at the tip. The stylus contacts the grooves on the vinyl record surface, creating vibrations through friction. These subtle vibrations are transmitted through the cantilever to the “generator” at the back. The MM moving magnet cartridge has a magnet mounted at the back of the cantilever, hence the name moving magnet, with a coil inside the cartridge shell. The MC moving coil cartridge has a coil mounted at the back of the cantilever, hence the name moving coil, with a magnet inside the cartridge shell.

The vibrations transmitted from the stylus create a weak voltage due to the interaction of the coil and magnet, which is the music signal. However, the signal is quite weak and must be amplified by a phono amplifier to become a high-level signal before being further amplified by the preamp.

Whether it’s an MM or MC cartridge, the cantilever’s tail end is either a magnet or a coil. The “combination” of mini magnets and coils becomes a tiny generator, producing subtle music signals. However, to cope with fast musical transient responses, the stylus’s movement flexibility must be as high as possible. Both MM and MC cartridges require the cantilever’s tail end to carry a magnet or coil, which is like asking an athlete to run a hundred meters while carrying cement. How can they run fast? Therefore, to design a high-performance MM or MC cartridge, we must find ways to reduce the weight carried by the cantilever’s tail end so that the stylus can have excellent movement flexibility.

MM cartridges are more challenging. We can increase the coil size (fixed inside the cartridge shell) and reduce the magnet’s mass to achieve sufficient output voltage, but the magnet is still not light, no matter how small it is.

As for MC cartridges, since the magnet is inside the cartridge shell, we can increase the magnet’s mass to enhance the magnetic force, reducing the coil windings. However, this ratio also has a specific calculation formula. But with the coil on the MC cartridge, the cantilever’s burden is lighter, and the movement is faster. Well-designed MC cartridges generally perform better in the mid-high frequencies than MM cartridges.

DS Audio DS 002 Turntable Review

Using Optical Sensing to Solve Electromagnetic Induction

By now, you understand the inherent dilemma of MM and MC cartridges: the cantilever’s back needs to carry a magnet or coil, and the extra mass affects the stylus’s movement flexibility in the vinyl grooves.

How does the “pure analog optical cartridge” work? DS Audio calls it the Advanced Optical-mechanical system. It uses the traditional stylus and cantilever, but the cantilever’s tail end has no coil or magnet, only a “light-blocking plate.” A light source is placed in front of the light-blocking plate. When the stylus vibrates, the light-blocking plate vibrates, casting a shadow on a micro photosensitive element. The photosensitive element senses the shadow’s vibration changes, converting them into analog signal modulation, which is amplified by DS Audio’s proprietary phono amplifier and sent to the preamp as a music signal.

This process is purely “analog,” with no digital components involved.

DS Audio calls it the Advanced Optical-mechanical system. It uses the traditional stylus and cantilever, but the cantilever’s tail end has no coil or magnet, only a “light-blocking plate.” A light source is placed in front of the light-blocking plate. When the stylus vibrates, the light-blocking plate vibrates, casting a shadow on a micro photosensitive element. The photosensitive element senses the shadow’s vibration changes, converting them into analog signal modulation, which is amplified by DS Audio’s proprietary phono amplifier and sent to the preamp as a music signal.

In fact, the optical cartridge solves two major problems of traditional MM and MC cartridges at once. First, the cantilever’s tail end has no magnet or coil, only a super-light light-blocking plate, giving the stylus the most flexible movement freedom.

DS Audio DS 002 Turntable Review

Second, because the photosensitive element needs power to generate analog signal modulation, the gain is much higher than traditional MM or MC cartridges.

What are the benefits of higher output gain? The rear phono amplifier doesn’t need such a high amplification factor to achieve sufficient high-level output. However, because the cartridge itself needs power, the DS 002 cartridge or any DS Audio optical cartridge must be used with their proprietary phono amplifier.

NHK Interview Video

New Materials Solve Past Challenges

Optical cartridges are not a new invention by DS Audio; they appeared in the 1970s. At that time, the innovative design theory made the audio world believe that optical cartridges would dominate because the design principle of optical cartridges had already removed the shortcomings of MM and MC cartridges. They not only significantly increased the gain of the cartridge’s music signal pickup but also minimized the mass burden on the cantilever’s back, giving the stylus the highest movement flexibility.

However, things didn’t go as planned. Optical cartridges disappeared shortly after appearing in the 1970s.

DS Audio DS 002 Turntable Review

Why did the nearly perfect design theory of optical cartridges vanish soon after their launch? The reason was the technological limitations of the time.

First was the issue of the light source. Early on, incandescent bulbs were used, which generated heat. If the light source was placed close to the light-blocking plate behind the cantilever, the heat would transfer to the cantilever, softening the damping material that fixed the cantilever. So, after listening to music for less than thirty minutes, the damping material would soften due to the heat.

To solve the heat dissipation problem, the bulb had to be moved away from the light-blocking plate. This resulted in a “shadow” projected onto the sensing element with less sharp edges and insufficient contrast, creating noise and increasing the sound’s background noise after amplification.

By now, you know how to solve the problems of 1970s optical cartridges, right? Yes, it’s LED lights. They have high brightness and low heat, completely eliminating the past heat impact on damping.

Furthermore, the early sensing elements have been replaced with solar panels, providing more precise sensing and better signal-to-noise ratio for DS Audio optical cartridges.

In other words, what DS Audio has done is apply the latest material science to achieve the theoretical dream that was impossible in the 1970s.

DS Audio DS 002 Turntable Review

Adjustments Still Require Expertise

Explaining optical cartridges alone took quite a bit of space. I want to return to the HiFiReport listening session. The DS 002 cartridge was mounted on a Danish Bergmann turntable with an air-bearing linear arm. The amplifier used a full set of Spectral preamps and power amps. The phono amplifier had no choice but to pair with the DS 002’s proprietary phono amplifier, and the speakers were paired with American YG Acoustics Hailey.

I took a close look at HiFiReport owner Mr. Zhang’s cartridge setup. He is truly skilled and daring. The DS 002’s cantilever is not long, but the bottom design of the cartridge shell is very flat. Mr. Zhang’s VTA horizontal setting is very low, almost completely parallel to the vinyl record. This is the correct adjustment. Some people, fearing the cartridge shell touching the bottom, will set the VTA slightly higher, which may result in slightly less bass.

The recommended tracking force is 1.6~1.8 grams, with the optimal value suggested at 1.7 grams. I asked Mr. Zhang about his settings.

He said he played with the DS 002 for several days, fine-tuning the tracking force several times, and finally settled at 1.75 grams.

In fact, the DS 002’s playstyle is identical to traditional MM or MC cartridges, except for the different working principle and the necessity to pair with DS Audio’s proprietary phono amplifier. You still need to pay attention to cartridge azimuth, VTA level, tracking force, anti-skating, and other details.

DS Audio DS 002 Turntable Review

The DS 002’s cantilever material is aluminum alloy, and the stylus is a Shibata stylus, resembling a barbed tip to increase the contact area with the record surface. Ortofon’s famous MC Jubilie uses the Shibata stylus.

Ask the Owner to Fine-tune the System’s Sound

Before describing the sound, I want to talk about the YG Acoustics Hailey paired with HiFiReport. I previously wrote a review when it was paired with a full set of American Aesthetix preamps and power amps. This time, it was replaced with a full set of Spectral. Hailey’s bright and transparent personality remained unchanged, and the response speed was even faster with Spectral. However, I felt the bass seemed slightly less than before. Could it be due to the change in amplifiers? Mr. Zhang immediately knew what I wanted when I mentioned this. He said to give him five minutes, and he would adjust it to the desired position. Sure enough, after adjusting the placement, the image of Hailey I had in mind returned.

In fact, when I come to HiFiReport to listen to vinyl, I don’t need to bring records because Mr. Zhang’s collection is quite rich, and each one is very “toxic.” Mr. Zhang collects vinyl meticulously, with Near Mint grades for Decca, old DG, EMI, Philips, etc., making me drool every time I see them.

However, I still brought my own vinyl, and the ones I brought are all new releases currently available, so everyone has a chance to hear “the same conditions” of vinyl records.

After all, rare famous records have different preservation status levels. If I always talk about those unavailable records, it’s hard for everyone to have a chance to listen and distinguish.

DS Audio DS 002 Turntable Review

Ultra-Quiet Music Background

I chose Yo-Yo Ma’s “Bach Trio,” a newly recorded album in 2017, and the vinyl is considered a first pressing.

Yo-Yo Ma, Chris Thile, and Edgar Meyer recorded at James Taylor’s Berkshires Studio, a studio on a farm. The previous “Yo-Yo Ma & Friends: Song of Joy and Peace” album was also recorded here. The recording style has a crossover flavor, with large instrument shapes and clearly defined musical notes. The sound of the DS Audio 002 cartridge is “unusually” clean and transparent. When I say “unusual,” I mean it’s as clean as a high-quality digital source, with very low background noise. Normally, the friction of the stylus on the vinyl grooves inevitably produces background noise, but the DS Audio 002 cartridge is extremely calm and clean. Just this quiet background already made me perk up my ears.

With a clean sound base almost like digital, does it lose the vinyl flavor? Of course not. The most charming aspect of the DS Audio 002 cartridge is here. The sound base is transparent and clean, but the tone is warm and pleasant. Listening to Yo-Yo Ma’s cello, the lines are melodious and dense, contrasting with the bright and lively mandolin and the bass cello’s underpinning. The music itself has a strong and refreshing contrast, and the DS Audio 002 cartridge brings these instruments to life with a vivid appearance.

I leaned close to Hailey’s tweeter to listen to the vinyl’s background noise. It’s really low, almost like a digital source, but the sound quality and tone are the warm and lively nature of vinyl.

Next, I listened to chamber music, Argerich and Perlman’s “Schumann, Bach, Brahms.” Listening to Schumann’s Violin Sonata No. 1, the violin gently plays the theme, with the piano accompanying like waves. The music becomes more intense, with the piano and violin intertwining. The DS Audio 002 cartridge has a rational side, clearly depicting the lines and weight of the violin and piano. The clean sound base and musical lines attract my attention. The more I listen, the closer I get to the musicians’ expressions. That’s the emotional side of the DS Audio 002 cartridge. When Perlman meets Argerich, the gentle violin gains a touch of sharpness, and the piano’s bright colors are effortlessly controlled by Argerich. However, during several strong performances, it almost overpowers the violin, showcasing Argerich’s passionate side.

DS Audio DS 002 Turntable Review

A Fresh Analog Sound Experience

For me, the DS Audio 002 cartridge offers a very fresh sound. It has a clean and transparent music background, as clean as a CD, yet it also has the warmth, richness, and solidity of traditional vinyl. Achieving both is quite challenging, but the DS Audio 002 cartridge manages to do it.

Using chamber music alone cannot fully showcase the charm of this cartridge. I switched to Rostropovich’s “Dvořák Cello Concerto,” listening to the third movement Rondo. Conductor Giulini uses a slower pace to build up, with the orchestra leading from soft to strong, reaching a peak before continuing with the cello theme. During the crescendo, the instrument sections gradually join in, and when the percussion enters, the triangle pushes the climax. The DS Audio 002 cartridge beautifully presents the triangle’s bright sound, almost allowing you to “see” the triangle’s position. Then the cello enters, with Rostropovich’s rich and heavy cello, a large presence. The DS Audio 002 cartridge beautifully depicts the instrument’s shape, contrasting with the orchestra’s repetition, the triangle’s echo, and the cello’s continued solo theme. Even in a concerto with intertwined and layered voices, the DS Audio 002 cartridge clearly conveys the music’s layers.

Left: Richter’s “Schubert: Trout Quintet.”

Right: “Kogan: Tchaikovsky Violin Concerto.”

Subsequently, HiFiReport owner Mr. Zhang began to bring out his treasures, listening to Richter’s “Schubert: Trout Quintet.” The strong and lively string performance brings out the flowing music, with the piano leisurely wandering among the strings. The DS Audio 002 cartridge can present the violin’s smooth and glossy appearance, with flowing lines, while making the piano’s notes clear and bright.

DS Audio DS 002 Turntable Review

Mr. Zhang also brought out the rare “Kogan: Tchaikovsky Violin Concerto,” and annoyingly, he has two copies. Listening with the DS Audio 002 cartridge, the music is vibrant and lively. In terms of sound personality, the DS Audio 002 cartridge leans towards a bright and lively direction, with the low-frequency range being tight, responsive, and fast. Listening to Tchaikovsky’s lively violin concerto, the DS Audio 002 cartridge is very fitting. However, Mr. Zhang’s vinyl collection is not to be listened to too much; it’s very addictive!

Using “The Rite of Spring” for Final Testing

For the final test, let’s try something challenging, listening to Rattle conducting the Berlin Philharmonic in “Stravinsky: The Rite of Spring.” This piece almost caused a riot at its premiere in Paris. The music is eerie, with a grand contrast between the orchestra’s dynamics, posing a difficult test for any audio system. I wanted to see if the DS Audio 002 cartridge could maintain stability in complex music and large intertwined voices.

As soon as the music started, I planned to listen to the entire side. The eerie woodwinds emerged from behind the speakers, a deep and distant sound. The music’s imagery is of spring gradually awakening the earth, but what follows is the heavy pounding of strings, advancing step by step. The strings play dissonant harmonies, with brass occasionally producing strange sounds. The DS Audio 002 cartridge lays out the dissonant sounds with clear layers of rationality while capturing the emotional musical imagery. When the heavy percussion appears, the DS Audio 002 cartridge’s downward force is excellent, with fast and elastic transient response.

Listening to the DS Audio 002 cartridge at HiFiReport, an afternoon flew by quickly. If I continued listening, they would have to invite me for dinner! This is truly a “pure analog optical cartridge” with a captivating sound charm. I feel like I haven’t listened enough and want to keep listening.

It’s hard for me to compare the sound of MM or MC cartridges with the DS Audio 002 cartridge. It feels like a completely new analog appearance, with a very deep and transparent music background, yet with the warmth and richness of traditional cartridges. This contrast between richness and freshness is what fascinates me most about the DS Audio 002 cartridge.

Equipment Specifications

  • DS 002 Cartridge Type: Optical Cartridge (Optical Cartridge)
  • Signal Output: Photo-electric Conversion
  • Output Level: Above 500mV
  • Tracking Force Range: 1.6g~1.8g; Recommended 1.7g
  • Channel Separation: Above 25dB
  • Cantilever: Aluminum Alloy
  • Stylus: Shibata Stylus
  • Cartridge Shell: Ultra Duralumin
  • Weight: 8.1g
  • DS 002 Phono Amplifier Rated Output: 500mV (1kHz)
  • Impedance: 120 Ohms
  • Input Terminals: RCA
  • Output Terminals: RCA x2
  • Dimensions: 310 x 92 x 235 mm (W x H x D)
  • Weight: 4.7 kg