Melco N1A Music Server Review

Melco N1A Music Server Review


If you listen to digital music files, whether you are using a computer with a USB DAC or a network streaming player, there is one item that is indispensable: a storage device to keep your precious music files. The methods of storing files vary widely; some prefer keeping them on their computers, others use external USB hard drives, and many opt for NAS (Network Attached Storage) devices. Each method has its own set of proponents, but I personally favor using a NAS.

Although NAS devices can be somewhat troublesome, they are safe, stable, expandable in capacity, support various software, and provide convenient network transmission. A NAS is much like a CD cabinet at home, keeping all your audio and video data well-organized. However, there is one aspect of NAS that often raises concerns among audiophiles: they are network peripherals, not audio devices, which makes enthusiasts uneasy about their use.

Melco N1A Music Server Review

To alleviate these worries, Melco has launched a NAS specifically designed for music playback, allowing audiophiles to enjoy their music without concerns. With a display screen and four buttons on the right side, the N1A can perform most operations without needing a computer.

The N1A’s power supply is internal, unlike typical NAS devices that use an external power supply, allowing users to pair it with higher quality power cables.

The Audio Heritage of Melco

Melco originated in Japan, and many may not have heard of this brand. However, Buffalo, another well-known brand, is a subsidiary of Melco. While Buffalo is primarily known for computer peripherals, convincing audiophiles that Melco can deliver audio-level NAS devices might be challenging.

Melco N1A Music Server Review

Founded in 1975, Melco started as an audio company. Its founder, Makoto Maki, was an audiophile himself, and the name “Melco” is an abbreviation of “Maki Engineering Laboratory COmpany.” Initially, Melco produced turntables, phono preamps, vacuum tube amplifiers, etc., with turntables being exported to the UK as early as 1980.

Years later, the company grew not through its audio products, but through its computer and networking division, most notably through Buffalo, which produced external hard drives, memory, routers, switches, and NAS devices. Currently, Melco combines both audio and network peripherals to meet the needs of audiophiles by launching high-tech network products, specifically NAS music servers.

Melco N1A Music Server Review

Melco believes that network products made by computer peripheral manufacturers cannot achieve the sound quality expected from audio playback. However, with its dual identity as both an audio manufacturer and a computer peripheral company, Melco approaches the storage and playback device design from an audiophile’s perspective.

NAS Tailored for Audio Playback

Currently, Melco offers two models: N1A and N1Z. The differences mainly lie in the casing material, chassis structure, power design, and hard drive type. The N1A is equipped with two 3.5-inch 2TB HDD drives and has a larger chassis, while the N1Z features two smaller 2.5-inch drives in a more compact casing. The N1Z further divides into N1ZH and N1ZS models, with the former using 2.5-inch HDDs and the latter utilizing 2.5-inch SSDs.

Melco N1A Music Server Review

This discussion focuses on the entry-level model, the N1A. Essentially, the N1A is a NAS specifically designed for audio playback. What makes it different from a typical NAS? Here are a few special features worth mentioning:

Firstly, the N1A has significantly fewer functions than a regular NAS. Is this a benefit? Absolutely, because the Hi-End philosophy focuses on excelling in a single task. The N1A retains only the functions relevant to music storage and playback, thus eliminating unnecessary clutter. Therefore, you cannot use the N1A for setting up home surveillance systems or hosting websites, nor can you watch videos on it.

Secondly, the N1A includes an extra network port that can be directly connected to a streaming player without going through a hub or switch. Additionally, the N1A can connect directly to your existing USB DAC and can be controlled via a mobile phone or tablet without the need for a computer.

Moreover, most operations can be performed using the four buttons and display screen on the panel, unlike typical NAS devices that require a computer for browser-based operations. Best of all, the N1A can also rip CDs simply by connecting an external CD drive.

The N1A can handle high-resolution files and DSD playback effortlessly. As a NAS, it supports a maximum sampling rate of PCM 32bit/384KHz and DSD512, while as a player, it supports up to PCM 32bit/384KHz and DSD256, which is an impressive specification.

Next, let’s enumerate the N1A’s features. The LAN port connects to a router or hub switch, while the PLAYER port directly links to the streaming player, which is a unique feature of the N1A.

Looking at the rear panel, the N1A has three USB 3.0 ports and two network ports, each marked differently. The USB 3.0 ports can directly connect to USB DACs. The EXPANSION port connects to USB storage devices like external USB hard drives, increasing storage capacity. The BACKUP port imports music files from USB storage devices or backs up data from the N1A. The LAN port connects to routers or hub switches for internet access.

Most importantly, the PLAYER port connects directly to network players or surround amplifiers with this capability. What’s the benefit of this? The data within the N1A bypasses the router or hub, allowing for a shorter path with fewer network cables, reducing significant interference and enhancing sound quality. This alone makes the N1A superior to typical NAS devices.

The N1A features two 3.5-inch 2TB HDD drives positioned on either side to balance weight, with the four feet of the drive mounts secured to the base via damping material to prevent vibrations from being transmitted to the chassis.

Internally, the N1A employs a 60-watt switch-mode power supply, achieving weight balance with the dual 3.5-inch HDD drives positioned on opposite sides. The central component is the “motherboard,” which is entirely custom-made by Melco rather than sourced from another manufacturer. Such technical prowess is typically found only among computer peripheral manufacturers, making it unlikely for average audio manufacturers to replicate.

Melco N1A Music Server Review

High Compatibility with USB DACs

In a previous review of Asustor’s NAS, I noted its ability to connect directly to USB DACs, a feature that the N1A also possesses. This allows your audio system to bypass the computer entirely. The Melco website lists compatible DAC models, and the list is continually growing. Just because a model isn’t listed doesn’t mean it’s unsupported; for instance, my Audiobyte Hydra-Z DDC, which isn’t on the list, works perfectly with the N1A, suggesting that the N1A likely has high compatibility.

Another critical point is how to control the N1A when directly connecting to a USB DAC. The answer is any standard UPnP remote control app such as BubbleUPnP, Kinsky, Audionet iMM/aMM, etc., meaning the control mechanism is identical to that of a streaming player.

Furthermore, when directly connected to a USB DAC, the N1A supports DSD (DoP mode) up to DSD256, provided that your USB DAC is capable of playing such files. If your USB DAC does not support DSD, no problem: simply set the N1A to output DSD as PCM.

Can the N1A play Tidal? Yes, but it must be through BubbleUPnP. When I connected the N1A directly to my Audiobyte Hydra-Z USB DDC and controlled it via BubbleUPnP, I captured a screenshot displaying the connected device’s name: N1-12D2 HYDRA-Z. N1-12D2 denotes this N1A device, confirming it successfully linked to Hydra-Z.

After identifying the player, you select the database, revealing three options: Local Media Server (the tablet used for remote control), MinimServer (my QNAP HS-251 NAS), and N1-12D2 (this N1A). Upon entering N1-12D2, you can access the music files stored within.

Easy File Importing

For typical NAS devices, you must use a computer with internet access to import files, logging into the NAS via a web browser. The N1A, however, does not require a computer for USB imports. Its panel display shows various information, including a row of small symbols indicating the status of the ports: an “L” for connected network cables, a “P” for streaming players, a “B” for the BACKUP port, and an “E” for the EXPANSION port. Connecting a USB DAC shows a symbol resembling a Type A plug, while outputting DSD files displays “DSD.” If set to convert DSD to PCM, it instead shows “PCM.” Inserting a CD drive illuminates a small circle.

Importing files is straightforward. Plug a USB storage device into the N1A’s USB 3.0 port, and the screen prompts you to Import. Press OK, and the device automatically begins importing the music files. However, remember that all files from the first partition will be imported without option for selection, including non-music files.

Melco N1A Music Server Review

You can set the import destination in two ways: by date or all in one folder. The date option creates a folder labeled with the current date. The “all” option consolidates everything into a folder named “all,” checking for duplicates to ensure only new files are imported. Using “all” seems more convenient to avoid redundant imports.

You can also transfer files from your computer to the N1A over the network, allowing you to select specific files for import. Enable SMB file sharing to connect the computer to the N1A. Within the N1A, you will see a folder called “share” where you can copy files for importing.

Additionally, within the “share” directory, there are folders named “import” and “import_CD.” What are these for? All files imported via USB go into “import,” while ripped CD files go into “import_CD.”

Next, let’s review how to rip CD tracks using the N1A.

CD Playback and Ripping

The N1A also provides a CD ripping function, but you will need a USB external CD drive to connect to either the USB 2.0 port on the front panel or the USB 3.0 port on the back. After inserting a CD, the N1A will prompt you to rip the CD. It automatically retrieves track data from the internet, including cover artwork if available. If multiple sets of track data are found, you can select from them, with an asterisk preceding albums that have cover art. If it cannot connect or find data, the album and track names will default to the date.

While ripping, you can choose between FLAC or WAV formats, with FLAC offering compression options: no compression, low compression, or standard compression. Since you can rip CDs, you can also play them. To play a CD, you must first select the CD Transport function from the menu. Playback, track selection, and pausing can be managed through the four buttons on the right side of the panel.

Control of Lighting

The N1A contains two 3.5-inch HDD drives, allowing for a variety of operational modes. By default, the N1A is set to ‘span’ mode, combining the two drives into one large volume, equating to the total storage of both drives. However, if one drive fails, all data will be lost, which poses a higher risk.

Alternatively, you can select RAID 0, which also merges the two drives into one, providing the same capacity as the span mode but with greater access efficiency. Yet, if one drive fails, all data is still lost.

The safest option is to set up RAID 1, mirroring the two drives, thus offering only the storage capacity of one drive while retaining a backup, making it the most secure storage method. You can change the hard drive mode, but be aware that doing so will erase all existing data, so proceed with caution.

You can back up N1A’s data externally for added safety, utilizing the BACKUP port on the back. Connecting an external USB hard drive formatted as NTFS or HFS+, the N1A will compare the data on both sides when performing backups, ensuring only new data is backed up. This makes each backup operation quicker, allowing for frequent backups to secure data.

If the external hard drive is formatted as FAT32, the N1A will perform a full backup without comparing files. Thus, the N1A also features a formatting option to convert external drives to NTFS.

With backup functionality, there is also a restore option, but restoring data will overwrite all data on the N1A, so approach with caution.

Another feature that will please audiophiles is the ability to turn off the lights. Besides adjusting the screen brightness, you can completely turn off the display, and the LED indicating power status can be dimmed as well. Remarkably, even the indicator lights for the network ports at the back can be turned off, displaying excellent attention to detail.

Directly connecting to a USB DAC, if your DAC does not support DSD but the N1A has DSD files stored, you can configure it to output DSD as PCM format.

Focused on Doing One Thing Well

After discussing numerous features, fundamentally, Melco positions the N1A as a user-friendly NAS that doesn’t require computer involvement for management and provides superior audio quality compared to typical NAS devices. But do its unique designs genuinely enhance sound quality? To answer this question, listening tests are necessary.

Despite its wide array of functionalities, the N1A’s primary role is still as a NAS. Therefore, I focused my testing on its performance solely as a “data output” device. I used a “reference machine,” my QNAP HS-251, with two identical network cables connecting both devices to a hub for A/B comparison.

My HS-251 is not an ordinary device. It features a rare fanless design, eliminating any interference from fan vibrations, similar to the N1A. Furthermore, to facilitate heat dissipation, the HS-251 employs a flat chassis with the two drives positioned side by side, resulting in a lower center of gravity and enhanced stability, much like the N1A.

Additionally, I upgraded the HS-251’s power supply to the KECES DC-216 linear power supply, which is superior to its original switch-mode power supply. How did the comparison fare? The N1A still had the edge.

The advantage lies in the density and cohesiveness of the sound, enriching the sense of layering in the soundstage and making the musical images more three-dimensional. This demonstrates that the N1A’s focus on excelling in one task has paid off. By eliminating numerous non-audio-related functions from a typical NAS, the hardware burden is reduced, software remains less complicated, and interference is minimized, resulting in purer sound quality.

The N1A’s firmware can be updated via network or USB, with options to automatically check for new firmware releases. The screen display during playback shows the connected playback device at the top, the track title in the middle, which scrolls if it exceeds the screen width, and the sampling rate at the bottom.

A Quality File Storage Solution

These results make me keen to explore the N1A’s ability to directly connect a network cable to a streaming player; unfortunately, I didn’t have a streaming player on hand for testing. However, I can intuit that a direct network connection would significantly enhance sound quality. The performance of routers and hub switches greatly impacts data transmission, especially for sensitive audio data. By allowing the N1A to bypass hubs and connect directly to streaming players, while also minimizing the number of cables used, the reduction in interference would likely yield notable sound improvements.

Additionally, the N1A features “self-growth.” With firmware updates, the N1A’s capabilities and performance will continue to expand, such as the recent addition of the CD ripping feature through an update. Future enhancements from firmware upgrades could also improve sound quality.

For high-end users, the N1A serves as a straightforward yet high-quality file storage solution. It elevates NAS beyond just a computer peripheral product, allowing even those unfamiliar with computers or who seldom use them to manage their music seamlessly, all while meeting the rigorous demands of audiophiles.

Upon examining the chassis, one discovers that the shock-absorbing feet beneath the N1A employ a combination of wood and rubber, a tuning method typically reserved for audio manufacturers.

Equipment Specifications

  • Model: Melco N1A Music Server
  • Supported File Formats (Server): DSF, DFF, FLAC, WAV, ALAC, AIFF, AAC, MP3, WMA, OGG, LPCM
  • Supported File Formats (Player): DSF, DFF, FLAC, WAV, ALAC, AIFF, AAC
  • Maximum Sampling Rate (Server): PCM 32bit/384KHz, DSD512
  • Maximum Sampling Rate (Player): PCM 32bit/384KHz, DSD256
  • Ports: LAN×2, USB 3.0×3, USB 2.0×1
  • Internal Drives: 3.5-inch 2TB HDD×2
  • Dimensions: 436×70×352 mm (W×H×D)
  • Weight: 7 kg