Roon-Nucleus-Music-Server-Review 1

Roon Nucleus Music Server Review


Roon’s widespread adoption is immediately apparent from the sheer number of partner brands listed on their website.

The increasing support for Roon from top-tier streaming players, DACs, and music servers signifies a crucial point: Roon’s user interface, functionality, performance, and sonic qualities have garnered significant acclaim from discerning consumers. Its proprietary RAAT (Roon Advanced Audio Transport) architecture surpasses conventional streaming methods, compelling major audio brands to integrate Roon compatibility to cater to audiophile demands.

However, as experienced Roon users know, the system requires a “host” to run the core Roon software. This host, typically a computer or NAS, is essential for Roon’s operation. The challenge arises because these general-purpose computing devices may lack the necessary processing power or possess excessive capabilities that don’t perfectly align with Roon’s requirements. The solution? Roon has introduced its dedicated music server, the Nucleus, designed to eliminate hardware specification concerns and provide the ultimate Roon experience.

Purpose-Built for Roon: Streamlined Performance

Before delving into the Nucleus, let’s reiterate Roon’s fundamental architecture.

A Roon system comprises three essential components: Core (the host), Control (the user interface, akin to a remote), and Output (the playback device).

Control is straightforward, typically managed via tablets or smartphones.

The Core is responsible for managing music files and streaming services, transmitting digital signals to the Output for audio reproduction. This transmission usually occurs in two ways: direct USB connection to a USB DAC or network connection to a Roon Ready player.

Furthermore, Roon now supports wireless devices like AirPlay, Chromecast, Sonos, Linn, and Devialet AIR, Squeezebox, enabling direct playback over Wi-Fi.

The Nucleus embodies the Core role described above.

The Nucleus seamlessly integrates function with design, utilizing its entire chassis as a heat sink. The internal CPU directly contacts the enclosure, efficiently transferring heat to the finned exterior. This expanded surface area facilitates fan-less cooling.

While fundamentally a computer, the Nucleus diverges from general-purpose PCs. Computers are designed for versatility—browsing the internet, streaming videos, listening to music, gaming, presentations, and more. In contrast, the Nucleus is singularly focused on running Roon Core and playing music. This dedicated purpose allows for streamlined and optimized hardware and software, minimizing interference and naturally resulting in superior audio performance compared to general-purpose computers.

Despite its singular focus, the Nucleus boasts impressive hardware specifications.

It comes in two versions: Nucleus and Nucleus+. The distinction lies in their processing power and storage. The Nucleus features an Intel i3 processor, 64GB SSD, and 4GB of RAM, while the Nucleus+ upgrades to an Intel i7 processor, a 128GB SSD, and 8GB of RAM.

Determining the appropriate model depends on library size and multi-zone streaming needs. Roon recommends the standard Nucleus for libraries under 10,000 albums and systems with fewer than six simultaneous playback zones. For larger libraries or more extensive multi-zone setups, the Nucleus+ is recommended.

Another key difference is DSP capability. The Nucleus’s DSP engine handles PCM formats, while the Nucleus+ extends DSP processing to both PCM and DSD formats.

Roon Nucleus Music Server Review

All input and output ports are located on the Nucleus’s rear panel. From left to right, these include the power switch, 19V DC power input, HDMI output, RJ45 network port, two USB 3.0 ports, and a Thunderbolt port.

Robust Hardware Foundation

Both Nucleus and Nucleus+ models are built upon the foundation of Intel’s NUC (Next Unit of Computing) mini-PCs. This explains the Nucleus’s compact form factor.

NUCs are Intel’s own compact barebones computers, essentially a roughly 10cm square motherboard housed in a palm-sized enclosure. Consumers can purchase NUCs to build their own mini-PCs, and brands can leverage them to create their own compact computer products.

NUCs come in various configurations and I/O port layouts to suit different applications, offering considerable flexibility, including models perfectly suited for the Nucleus.

Roon’s choice of NUC is driven by several factors: compact size, adequate hardware performance, suitable interface options, and, crucially, ensuring a longer product lifecycle and sustained stability for the Nucleus.

This longevity is evident in two key aspects.

Firstly, consider existing Nucleus units. NUC supports Linux, and Nucleus’s Roon OS is Linux-based. This allows Roon OS to be updated in tandem with Linux updates, ensuring compatibility with the latest Roon versions. Essentially, a Nucleus purchased years ago will remain current, benefiting from the newest Roon features.

Secondly, consider future Nucleus models. NUC is a popular 3C product line with continuous hardware refreshes. Despite generational changes, the NUC’s size is unlikely to change significantly, and BIOS, chipset, and motherboard layouts will remain largely consistent. This allows Nucleus to consistently utilize the latest NUC versions, mitigating concerns about platform obsolescence.

The Nucleus white paper states that development utilized 5th and 6th generation NUCs, with the 7th generation NUC adopted for the initial product launch. Platform transitions have not presented significant challenges.

The entire chassis is crafted from a single piece of cast aluminum, with only a bottom cover that can be opened.

The Nucleus is fundamentally an Intel NUC mini-computer.

Internally, a 2.5-inch HDD or SSD can be installed for expanded storage capacity.

Given the palm-sized NUC, why does the Nucleus appear larger? NUCs rely on internal fans for cooling. However, audiophiles are often sensitive to fan noise and vibration. To achieve complete silence, the Nucleus utilizes its chassis as a heat sink. The CPU makes direct contact with the enclosure, efficiently transferring heat to the finned exterior for dissipation.

Calculations determined the necessary size of this heat sink, thus dictating the Nucleus’s enclosure dimensions. The unibody cast aluminum construction eliminates seams and screws, blending practicality, aesthetics, and thoughtful design.

Roon Nucleus Music Server Review

While photos might suggest a substantial size, the Nucleus is actually quite compact, roughly the size of a military-style lunchbox, making placement exceptionally easy.

Expanding Support: AirPlay and Chromecast

The Nucleus boasts a minimalist aesthetic, with no front panel lights, only a subtly etched logo at the center.

All input and output ports are situated on the rear panel. From left to right: power switch (illuminated with a soft white glow when active), 19V DC input, HDMI output, RJ45 network port, two USB 3.0 ports, and a Thunderbolt port.

Are there analog outputs? No.

The Nucleus is a server-grade digital transport, providing only digital outputs. It connects via USB 3.0 to USB DACs, HDMI to surround receivers, or via network to Roon Ready devices, or leverages AirPlay, Chromecast, Sonos, and similar systems for playback.

Only two areas illuminate on the Nucleus: the link lights below the RJ45 network port and the backlight of the power button on the left, which illuminates upon activation.

The Nucleus’s core function is music file management and playback. Where are these files stored? Three options are available.

First, a 2.5-inch HDD or SSD can be installed internally within the Nucleus, allowing users to store music files directly.

Second, external USB HDDs can be connected via the rear USB 3.0 ports. The Nucleus can access and integrate music files from these drives into the Roon library.

Third, the Nucleus can access music files stored on a NAS (Network Attached Storage) device on your home network, incorporating them into the Roon library.

These methods can be used individually or in combination.

The built-in 64GB SSD (128GB in Nucleus+) is not for music storage. Instead, it houses the Roon OS, Roon core software, and the Roon database.

It’s crucial to understand the Roon database.

Backing Up Your Roon Database: Highly Recommended

The Roon database is compiled after Roon scans your music files, retrieving track information over the internet and storing it on the Nucleus’s SSD. This data includes album titles, cover art, track names, artists, composers, release dates, genres, and more—essentially all the information displayed in Roon’s browsing interface.

Roon Nucleus Music Server Review

This information is a core value proposition of Roon. It is comprehensive, detailed, and transforms your raw music files into a dynamic, interconnected library, enhancing browsing, searching, and playback, making listening more enjoyable. The larger your music library, the more you appreciate Roon’s intelligence, convenience, and indispensability.

Furthermore, if you find any track information in Roon to be less than ideal, or if the selected cover art differs from your physical media version, you can edit it or choose to use the metadata embedded in your files. These modifications are saved back into the Roon database.

Roon’s album browsing interface. Album art is sourced from the Roon database, ensuring complete visual coverage and a polished, elegant presentation.

This brings us to a crucial point: beyond backing up your music files (standard practice), backing up your Roon database is equally essential. Why? Imagine your external hard drive connected to the Nucleus fails, resulting in data loss. If you have a music file backup, you can reconnect the backup drive, rescan with Roon, and resume listening. However, any custom edits or adjustments you’ve made to the metadata over time will be lost, requiring you to start from scratch. But, with a Roon database backup, these customizations are preserved.

Additionally, the Roon database stores information about each album’s Dynamic Range and the waveform of each track.

This is a fascinating Roon feature. It analyzes every track in your library, displaying the Dynamic Range for each album and the waveform of the currently playing track at the bottom of the screen. The waveform provides a visual representation of the track’s dynamics.

This analysis is CPU-intensive, performed track by track. When you add music files to Roon, the CPU begins this process in the background. For libraries of thousands of albums, this analysis may take several days. The results are stored in the Roon database, reinforcing the importance of backing it up to avoid potential re-analysis.

How do you back up the Roon database? In “Settings,” there’s a “Backups” option, allowing you to specify the backup location and automatic backup schedule.

Roon analyzes each track in your library, displaying the album’s Dynamic Range below the cover art. For example, Chen Ming-Chang’s “Last Train from Suao” has a Dynamic Range of 13.

The playback screen’s bottom section also displays the waveform of the currently playing track, providing a visual cue to the music’s dynamics—a thoughtful and engaging feature.

Remote Control Performance Matters

Let’s discuss Nucleus usage.

First, a Roon subscription is required—$119 annually or $499 for a lifetime subscription.

Admittedly, Roon isn’t inexpensive. However, upon my annual subscription renewal, I opted for a lifetime membership. Once accustomed to Roon, going back is unthinkable.

Second, a remote control device is essential. I recommend a tablet with reasonable processing power. Roon’s website suggests compatible models. Smartphones can also serve as remotes, although the smaller screen may be less convenient for browsing extensive libraries.

Roon Nucleus Music Server Review

Why emphasize tablet performance if it’s just a remote? To keep pace with the Nucleus. The Nucleus constantly streams browsing information. If the tablet is sluggish, resulting in choppy scrolling, it negates the Nucleus’s high performance.

The review unit is the high-end Nucleus+, accompanied by a Brik Power Master power supply, providing a 20V DC output. While slightly higher than the Nucleus+’s 19V requirement, it’s within the acceptable voltage range. The Nucleus+ typically ships with a laptop-style switching power supply.

Roon allows users to experiment with aftermarket power supplies, including switching or linear power supplies, to potentially refine the listening experience. However, ensure any chosen power supply is safety-certified and has adequate heat dissipation to prevent damage.

The Nucleus’s included 19V switching power supply.

The accompanying Brik Power Master linear power supply, with a 20V output compatible with the Nucleus.

The review Nucleus+ arrived pre-configured with a Roon account, Tidal service activated, a pre-installed SSD, and some music files. Minimal setup was required. Simply launching the Roon app on my laptop (used as a remote) allowed control of the Nucleus+.

I connected an external USB hard drive to the Nucleus+ rear panel, adding my own music files to the library for familiar listening material.

Seamless Operation

Previously, I ran Roon Core on a computer and recently transitioned to a NAS as a Roon Server. My experience suggests that as long as the hardware isn’t too underpowered and has at least 4GB of RAM, Roon operates smoothly. Using the Nucleus+ elevates this smoothness to an impeccable level. Browsing and playback are utterly seamless, with album art loading instantly when scrolling, exhibiting exceptionally fast and responsive operation.

Roon remains perpetually ready. Even after an hour of inactivity, a simple press of the play button instantly awakens the Nucleus+, with music flowing immediately, requiring no waiting.

Roon is engineered for this user experience. This focus on seamless operation is a key factor in its growing popularity among audiophile manufacturers and enthusiasts. The Nucleus fully realizes this vision.

You might wonder if the standard i3 CPU Nucleus offers the same fluidity as the Nucleus+. I believe that for libraries under 10,000 albums and systems with fewer than six playback zones, the standard Nucleus will perform equally smoothly. This configuration already meets the needs of most users.

Roon directly integrates Tidal. If you have a Tidal account, icons may appear next to tracks. The CD icon indicates multiple versions of the track in your local library. In this example, “2” signifies two versions by different artists.

The four-dot icon represents the number of versions available in the Tidal library. Here, “129” indicates 129 versions. Clicking it links directly to Tidal, allowing exploration of those 129 versions.

If you have a Tidal subscription, you can stream directly via Roon.

This is Roon’s Tidal homepage, showcasing the latest albums on Tidal.

Roon Nucleus Music Server Review

You can also browse Tidal music by genre.

This genre is Billboard’s Hot Country Songs, curated by Tidal.

Regarding audio output, as mentioned, Nucleus/Nucleus+ offers three playback methods: HDMI to surround receivers, USB to DACs, and network connection to Roon Ready players.

Without a surround receiver, I couldn’t test the first method. However, I tested both USB DAC and Roon Ready network playback.

I used my Audiobyte Black Dragon and a forthcoming NuPrime Evolution DAC. Both DACs were recognized by the Nucleus+ via USB and played flawlessly, demonstrating excellent USB DAC compatibility.

However, a specific behavior emerged when playing DSD. Both the Black Dragon and Evolution DAC displays showed 352.8kHz. This indicates that the Nucleus+ doesn’t natively support DSD playback for these DACs. However, PCM support is maximized, so the Nucleus+ automatically converts DSD to PCM 352.8kHz before transmission to the DAC.

This intelligent design is commendable. It’s unrealistic for the Nucleus+ to have native USB drivers for every DAC. Instead, it detects its compatibility level and automatically adjusts accordingly, preventing playback issues.

Furthermore, DACs that are Roon Tested (listed on Roon’s website) will not exhibit this behavior. Roon has USB drivers for these tested DACs, ensuring playback at the DAC’s maximum supported resolution.

To truly leverage Roon’s network streaming advantages, Roon Ready players are invaluable.

Here, the AURALiC Aries Mini serves as a simple example.

Once the Aries Mini is connected to the network, the AURALiC ARIES_MINI option automatically appears in the “Networked” section on the right side of Roon’s “Audio” page.

Click “Enable” on the right.

You can assign a recognizable name to the Aries Mini in the “Zone Name” field.

I retained “Aries Mini”.

Returning to the playback device selection menu, “Aries Mini” is now an option.

Roon Nucleus Music Server Review

Roon Ready players are my preferred source to pair with the Nucleus. A single network cable connection and the Roon Ready player’s analog outputs connected to an amplifier provide an ultra-convenient and streamlined setup, truly unleashing Roon’s streaming potential.

For example, my AURALiC Aries Mini wireless streaming player supports Roon Ready, even eliminating the need for a network cable by utilizing Wi-Fi for high-resolution streaming.

An increasing number of player brands support Roon Ready, spanning various price points from thousands to hundreds of thousands of dollars, offering ample choice to suit your needs.

If you use HQPlayer playback software, it can also be controlled directly through the Nucleus.

HQPlayer is a computer-based music playback software renowned for its sophisticated algorithms that enhance audio performance and provide diverse listening experiences.

HQPlayer can be controlled remotely by Roon. Computers running HQPlayer function as Roon Ready players without needing Roon Bridge. In this configuration, the Nucleus is the music server, and the HQPlayer computer is the streaming player.

Computers with HQPlayer can function as Roon Ready players, even without Roon Bridge.

In Roon’s “Setup” page, locate the “HQPlayer” section and click “Add HQPlayer” on the right.

Enter the IP address of the computer running HQPlayer.

After entering the IP, click “Add”.

Then, navigate to the “Audio” page. A “HQPlayer” option will appear in the “Networked” section on the lower right. You can assign a recognizable name to this HQPlayer computer in the “Zone Name” field.

I retained “HQPlayer”.

Returning to the playback device selection menu, “HQPlayer” is now an option.

Embodying a Premium Streaming Transport

Having detailed Roon’s advantages and the Nucleus+’s design and functionality, the most pressing question is likely the Nucleus+’s sonic performance.

Assessing the sound quality of a server-grade streaming transport like the Nucleus+ is challenging, as the sonic character largely stems from the DAC or player. Therefore, I employed A/B testing to compare its sound.

Roon Nucleus Music Server Review

I used an Intel i5 CPU laptop running Windows 10 with Roon Core installed, logged into my Roon account. The source was connected to the Black Dragon DAC via USB. The Nucleus+ was also connected to the Black Dragon via USB. This setup allowed a direct comparison between the Nucleus+ and a general-purpose computer.

The verdict? The difference was apparent within 10 seconds: the Nucleus+ decisively outperformed the laptop.

In comparison, the laptop sounded somewhat dull and sluggish, with perceived limitations in high and low frequency extension. In contrast, the Nucleus+ exhibited a noticeably cleaner sonic backdrop, purer texture, and effortless extension at both frequency extremes. The sound was relaxed, natural, balanced with both composure and brilliance, and simultaneously transparent and full-bodied, with clearly rendered details and textures.

In my experience, the primary sonic differences between various CAT (computer as transporter) setups lie in naturalness, realism, and musical vibrancy. The Nucleus+ excels in these aspects, unequivocally embodying the qualities of a premium streaming transport server.

To further refine the Nucleus+’s sonic performance, upgrading the power supply is recommended. However, a linear power supply isn’t mandatory. Focus on a well-engineered, high-quality power supply.

Roon offers various DSP (Digital Signal Processing) functions, providing users with diverse sonic customization.

First, Headroom Management prevents distortion caused by exceeding volume limits after DSP activation by preemptively reducing volume.

Roon provides versatile upsampling and downsampling, allowing PCM to be upsampled to DSD output or forcing PCM or DSD to output at a fixed sample rate.

For headphone users, Roon’s Crossfeed function mitigates the extreme stereo separation of early stereo recordings, preventing instruments from being localized entirely to one side.

Roon also offers multi-band EQ, allowing users to adjust specific frequency ranges with powerful control.

Intriguingly, Roon includes Audeze headphone-specific calibration filters, enhancing the naturalness of Audeze headphones, mimicking the experience of listening to neutral speakers in a well-treated room.

The Optimal Platform for Roon

Who is the Nucleus for? If you’re considering adopting Roon or are already a Roon user seeking improved audio performance without relying on a computer or NAS as your Roon Core, the Nucleus or Nucleus+ is ideal.

Furthermore, it suits those aiming for system simplification, wanting to eliminate a separate USB DAC. Increasingly, streaming players support Roon Ready, enabling playback via network connection, bypassing the USB interface, which is not always optimal for audio transmission.

The Nucleus and Nucleus+ offer a clear solution for music streaming playback. They are far more than just an Intel NUC mini-computer with a cast aluminum heat-dissipating chassis. They represent Roon leveraging its software expertise to create a tailored music server for optimal music playback and user interface experience. It addresses numerous streaming challenges and surpasses the capabilities of a meticulously assembled DIY music server PC.

Crucially, the Nucleus and Nucleus+ deliver enhanced sound quality, making them exceptional value propositions when considering performance.

Specifications

  • Roon Nucleus+ Type: Music Server
  • Processor: Intel i7 CPU
  • Hard Drive: 128GB SSD
  • Memory: 8GB
  • Interfaces: HDMI×1, USB 3.0×2, RJ45×1, Thunderbolt×1
  • Dimensions: 21.2×7.4×15.6 cm (Width×Height×Depth)
  • Weight: 2.5 kg