Stein Music π [pi] CD Mat Review

Stein Music π [pi] CD Mat Review


When I was writing the title for this article, I found myself struggling a bit. The Stein Music π [pi] CD Mat is technically more of a CD weight than a mat, as it is placed on top of the CD rather than underneath it, unlike the π [pi] LP mat, which is used under vinyl records. But how can such a thin, lightweight piece of special Japanese paper be called a “weight”? Perhaps it’s better to refer to it as a “mat” based on its form.

Volunteering to Write the Review

When the π [pi] CD Mat arrived at the HiFiReport editorial office, as per usual, we held an editorial meeting to decide who would write the review. This time, however, I volunteered to take on the task.

You might think that the editor-in-chief is being domineering, always picking the best gear for himself first. But actually, the opposite is true. Do you think it’s easy to write about tuning accessories? What if I took it home for a listen and couldn’t hear any difference? Should I go ask the distributor, “Sir, what’s the secret behind this CD mat? I can’t hear any difference in the sound.” Saying something like that would either mean admitting that I have “cloth ears” and can’t appreciate the benefits of their tuning tools, or it would be calling out the manufacturer for selling snake oil.

As a result, tuning accessories are usually one of the least popular categories of equipment in the editorial office. Unless an editor is confident, few will volunteer to review them. Most of the time, these items get assigned after a round of work distribution.

So why did I take on the π [pi] CD Mat? First, I had just reviewed the π [pi] LP Mat, which is made of the same material, but for vinyl records instead of CDs. Second, tuning accessories that sit on top of CDs are easier to test with top-loading CD players, and I happen to have both a North Star Design CD 192 and a YBA Passion CDP 450, both of which are top-loading designs, unlike the more common tray-loading mechanisms. This makes me the most qualified to test it. Lastly, I was curious. Having just reviewed the π [pi] LP Mat and been very impressed with its performance, I was naturally interested in trying out the CD version.

Analog and Digital Domains Don’t Always Overlap

Before testing the π [pi] CD Mat, I had some reservations. I knew the LP version would definitely have an effect, but I wasn’t so sure about the CD version.

Stein Music π [pi] CD Mat Review

Why? In the analog domain, no matter what kind of mat you use under a vinyl record, it will always change the sound. This is due to physical factors like mass, damping, and vibration, which interact subtly with the stylus as it reads the grooves, resulting in changes to the sound. However, whether these changes are good or bad is another matter.

When I tested the π [pi] LP Mat, I once tried using regular copy paper as a makeshift mat, and it did change the sound—but for the worse, making the sound thinner. This showed that the π [pi] LP Mat has some unique know-how when it comes to tuning. However, applying the same logic to the digital domain of CDs might not yield the same results.

Why not? CDs and vinyl records both rely on rotation to read signals, but they work differently. Vinyl records use a stylus that moves through grooves, with the width of the grooves guiding the stylus’s vibrations, which in turn generate electrical signals through a magnetic circuit. This is a purely analog process, so any changes in the contact surface’s resonance will affect the sound. This is why vinyl enthusiasts often have a collection of tuning accessories like record weights and mats, which they use to adjust the sound to their liking based on the type of music they’re playing.

But CDs Don’t Work That Way!

At first glance, a CD’s surface looks smooth and flawless, like a mirror. But under an electron microscope, you’ll see countless pits and lands, which represent 0s and 1s. As the CD spins, the laser reads these pits and lands, interpreting them as binary data. It’s as simple as that.

In the digital world, there’s no gray area—only 0s and 1s, black and white.

This means that the principles of vibration control and resonance management that apply to analog vinyl records don’t necessarily translate to the digital domain. Vinyl records rely on continuous analog grooves, while CDs use a series of pits and lands with absolute values of 0 and 1, with no in-between.

To put it simply, when you’re playing a CD in a car, the CD keeps playing even as the car vibrates. This is because the CD only reads 0s and 1s. If the signal is lost, you get distortion. If too much signal is missed, the CD skips. If there’s a timing mismatch between the digital signal and the decoding process, you get jitter, another form of distortion. However, these distortions occur in the digital domain and aren’t affected by analog factors. This means that the vibration control we discuss in the analog world doesn’t necessarily apply to the digital domain.

The Material is the Same

Stein Music π [pi] CD Mat Review

According to Stein, the material used in the π [pi] CD Mat is almost identical to that of the π [pi] LP Mat. It’s made from a special Japanese paper called “Tapa Cloth Tree,” which uses a mix of long and short fibers to achieve uniform resonance energy distribution. At Stein’s factory in Mülheim, they further enhance the mat with their proprietary Maestro tuning varnish, resulting in the standard version of the π [pi] CD Mat. The version I received is the advanced “Carbon Signature” model, which features a carbon coating that improves the electromagnetic wave distribution on the CD’s surface.

Does Stein’s explanation sound esoteric? Vibration control, electromagnetic wave equalization, and resonance energy distribution—these all seem like minor details. Well, I can only relay Stein’s claims as they are. Whether these subtle adjustments can bring noticeable changes will have to be determined through actual listening tests.

Testing with a New System

My home audio system has recently undergone significant changes. I’ve upgraded my speakers to Wilson Audio W/P Sasha 2, while keeping my Electrocompaniet EC 4.8 preamp and NuForce Reference 18 power amp. I’ve also added a VTL TL 5.5 Series II preamp and ST-200 power amp to the mix, so they’ll be part of the listening tests as well.

The DAC is still the Merging NADAC, but the CD transport has been upgraded to the YBA Passion CDT 450, connected to the NADAC via a Transparent Reference XL AES/EBU digital cable.

For the listening test, I chose Radu Lupu’s performance of Schumann’s Piano Concerto, with the London Symphony Orchestra conducted by André Previn. The piece opens with a powerful orchestral blast, followed by the piano’s forceful chords. After the initial burst, the woodwinds enter with a gentle melody, echoed by the piano, leading into the concerto’s main theme.

First, I listened without the π [pi] CD Mat. The newly acquired W/P Sasha 2 speakers did an excellent job of rendering the orchestra’s massive sound, contrasting beautifully with the woodwinds’ softness.

It sounded great! Even without the π [pi] CD Mat, the performance was impressive. Then, I added the π [pi] CD Mat, simply placing it on top of the CD and adding the CD weight before listening again.

Stein Music π [pi] CD Mat Review

The orchestra’s powerful opening and the piano’s forceful chords were still there, but the contrast between the woodwinds’ softness and the piano’s response seemed more pronounced with the π [pi] CD Mat in place. The melodic lines flowed more smoothly, and the music felt more dynamic.

It’s hard to describe this sense of musical flow. When playing legato passages on the piano, you can hear the seamless connection between the notes, while staccato passages are crisp and distinct. With the π [pi] CD Mat, these subtle emotional contrasts in the music became more pronounced, and the lines felt more fluid.

I didn’t notice a significant increase in bass or a brighter treble with the π [pi] CD Mat, but the overall musical flow did become clearer. This wasn’t just about smoother lines; the expressive dynamics of the music also felt more alive.

In the first movement of Schumann’s Piano Concerto, there are many solo piano passages. With the π [pi] CD Mat, these sparkling piano notes seemed even more polished and crystalline.

Enhancing the Dramatic Effect of Music

After removing the π [pi] CD Mat and listening again, the performance was still excellent. Although the W/P Sasha 2 speakers are still breaking in, their sound has already exceeded my expectations. However, without the π [pi] CD Mat, the music felt a bit flatter. The dramatic shifts in the music, which are key to Schumann’s romantic expression, were less pronounced.

Putting the π [pi] CD Mat back on, the dramatic shifts in the music returned. The π [pi] CD Mat made the music feel more intense and engaging.

The more I listened with the π [pi] CD Mat, the more intrigued I became.

As I mentioned earlier, analog principles don’t always apply to the digital domain. So, in theory, I don’t believe that a CD mat, which is an analog tuning accessory, can have a significant impact in the digital realm. Yet, the π [pi] CD Mat did seem to enhance the expressiveness of the music.

Stein Music π [pi] CD Mat Review

What’s the explanation? I don’t think resonance control or electromagnetic wave equalization are the key factors. Instead, the carbon-black coating on the π [pi] CD Mat might be improving the accuracy of the laser’s reading. It’s similar to how YBA uses a special blue light in their CD transports to eliminate unnecessary spectral interference and improve laser accuracy. The carbon-black π [pi] CD Mat might be doing something similar, which could explain its impact on the sound.

The Theory is Unclear, but the Sound is Interesting

Regardless, I still don’t fully understand what’s going on with the π [pi] CD Mat, but if it works, I’m happy to use it.

If you’re interested in trying the π [pi] CD Mat, I recommend starting with simple music, like Martha Argerich’s recording of Schumann’s “Kinderszenen.” This is an early DG recording of Argerich, and I’ve often felt that while the sound is clear, the piano can sometimes sound a bit dry and harsh. Listening with the π [pi] CD Mat, the piano’s dynamics felt more pronounced, and the dryness I used to hear was completely gone.

In “Kinderszenen,” the “Träumerei” movement is soft and gentle, with Argerich showing a rare dreamy quality. But contrast that with the preceding “Wichtige Begebenheit,” and the piano’s power becomes evident. With the π [pi] CD Mat, you can clearly hear the contrast in the music. I used to think this Argerich recording sounded a bit thin, but that was likely due to my previous speakers. Now, with the W/P Sasha 2, I can appreciate the beauty of the music even more.

Is it because I changed my speakers that this CD sounds better? Or is it the π [pi] CD Mat that’s enhancing the music’s liveliness and flow? I think it’s a bit of both, with the speaker change playing a larger role in making the piano sound fuller and richer. But the π [pi] CD Mat does have an effect—it doesn’t alter specific frequency ranges but instead enhances the music’s flow and emotional expression, making it feel more natural and alive.

Every night, as I listen to music at home with the π [pi] CD Mat, I find myself increasingly torn about whether to keep it.

In the end, I’ll just keep listening. At $300 (converted from 9,000 NTD), the π [pi] CD Mat isn’t cheap, but it’s not unaffordable either. If I fall in love with it, spending a bit of money for long-term enjoyment isn’t a big deal.